Software
Houzz Logo Print
nicholsworth55z6indianapolis

best patio door?

need to replace a 60 inch wood sliding patio door..so what brand?..vinyl?..fiberglass?..wood interior with aluminum clad exterior?..looking online today and the prices are scary..

Comments (22)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I love my jeld-wen box store door, but it was $2500 installed. It is wood with aluminum clad exterior, wide stile. I had it factory painted since parts were inaccessible to me after it was assembled. (It was too heavy for me to move a door off the tracks.) It was installed less than a year ago. I believe it was called a 4500, the higher end.

    When I went to a window store, they wanted around $4K for a similar style.

    Andersen had a similar style for about the same price, but I liked the jeld-wen better because the adjustment access was more hidden, and I think the Andersen had a visible logo, but I'm not sure. My installers preferred the Andersen. Mine has a black threshhold which some people don't like, but I'm ok with it since the floor is dark.

    Definitely look at the door model in person before you buy, and go over all the options on your spec, because sales associates will make assumptions or may not know all the details.

    Be ready for imperfections and ask for touchup paint. Have an estimator come out and measure for the door before ordering. My door opening was problematic but we knew all that going in, and I am happy with the result even if it's not perfect. A nice door framing a beautiful view makes the house much more upscale.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Jane
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    millworkman..took this pic last week after cleaning our deck..the patio door is out of view but to the right of the kit window..it's 60 x 80..want a dark frame..want it to be "invisible"..interior of the house has lots of dark wood..so would it look bad to have anything other than wood for the door?..the view is pretty..don't want grills just glass..sliding is a space saver and cheaper right?..am sort of shocked about the price..husband is handy but if we can find a GOOD installer we would pay..scared after reading lots of bad comments..what's really true???

  • 10 years ago

    Jane..we're leaning towards a wood with aluminum exterior too..have a guy coming in an hour and another next week..so did the installer come from the big box store?..just because he preferred Anderson(maybe it's lighter and easier to install?) doesn't mean that your door isn't as good..were you surprised at the price of these doors?..I would take the most simple and easiest to maintain as long as it was good quality and functioned well..I agree with you in that I don't want it to look cheap and stand out like a sore thumb..

  • 10 years ago

    can see the door on the left side of this pic..there is cedar trim around the door..the framing on the door is not as wide as you might think..see how we need a dark color?..the interior vertical blinds are HIDEOUS and will be removed..

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    You should go to Home Depot where they have a display of several doors and see what quality and style you want. Be sure to look at the exact model of door in person - the little details matter. Have them work up an estimate and give you the paperwork. You don't have to buy it.

    The installers were contractors hired by a home depot company (forgot the name) and home depot stands behind the installation and took the payment. But I had the option of using an independent installer. They have a network of installers online to choose from, or you could pick your own or diy. Look at reviews if you can find them. I could not find reviews of the specific door I ordered.

    I had been planning to replace the door for years. I had been asking them for estimates for years so I was not surprised it was so much. However it was a LOT less than other estimates. A big part of that is that it was a wide stile door. There was not a lower end option of wide stile door that I liked. Had to have satin nickel hardware and wood with aluminum clad exterior. That limited my options. If you are open to vinyl, fiberglass and/or narrow stile doors, then you'll have a lot more options at lower costs.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Jane
  • 10 years ago

    In my opinion stay as far from box stores and ANYTHING they sell (especially Jeldwen). 80" height will be an issue as that is the size the old aluminum sizes were from the 70's. I would get a retrofit Bronze vinyl from Softlite were it me

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    Jane..even though I like simple clean lines they still cost more than I thought they would..better start shopping..

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    millworkman..not a precise measurement..have not removed the trim for an exact measurement of the rough opening..or to get the measurement on the old door unit but it would be less than 60 x 80..what is your best guess on a price for the Softlite door and installation..

  • 10 years ago

    I couldn't even fathom a guess as I do not work in residential nor have in sometime. Also very dependent on the area of of the country.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked millworkman
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I've got a buddy who's been in the window/door business for 30 years and he swears by Windoor. I saw one in person and they are simply not comparable to others. Not by a long shot. Of course you'll pay for this quality, but it's nice to have that option.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    millworkman..when I call dealers they will NOT even say a ballpark estimate for the door..one guy said "I need to see your house"..wasn't asking about installation..just the cost of the unit so why does he need to see my house?..why is the price of "the door" such a secret?..the big box stores are upfront about prices..

  • 10 years ago

    Joseph Corlett..will check Windoor..thank you

  • 10 years ago

    They may need to see your house to see if you need a custom size or reframing. Home Depot won't reframe, but they did retrim my exterior and interior, and they added some threshhold shim pieces and a top piece, I think. They caulked, I painted. (I may have caulked the interior trim, don't remember.)


    If they have to expand the opening, it could cost more. If they have to order a custom size or extra pieces, it could cost more. Custom size could cost a lot more. There may be a permit issue if structural changes are required, IDK.

    You could compare doors only based on a standard size.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Jane
  • 10 years ago

    How can they quote installation without seeing where they will install it and into what they will install it. Box stores will throw numbers at you for crap, send over hacks who screw up the entire magilla and then you will be here complaining about shoddy work and crap products.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    Jane..we went to Home Depot last night..our door is a standard size..they gave us a price on a door..1127 for a Permashield..we know the wood/aluminum clad is at least 500 more..not ready to buy yet still deciding..got an Anderson and JeldWen brochure..had an appt yesterday..waiting on an email on that one..not sure about their brand Quaker..this is stressing me out!!

  • 10 years ago

    millworkman..I am concerned about a quality installation..I would like to use a window company..but I feel like I get the run around when I'm not asking for a complete price just the door and they're so secretive about it..I hear good things about Marvin..so before I drive 45 mins would like to get an approx price for just the door..would I consider it or is it out of the question?..but all I got was where do you live?..are you available tomorrow?..maybe I'll let them come and when I turn them down because it's too high I wasted their time!!

  • 10 years ago

    Don't stress - there is a lot of pressure in the replacement window biz so beware, be strong, NEVER be intimidated. Take a deep breath and don't sign anything until you have slept on it and you are sure of what you want and who you are doing business with.

    I think doors may be easier than windows as far as the transaction goes.

    BTW, I was home when the contractors were here and I watched almost everything they did. I tried to stay out of their way. I was nice and complimentary, I tried to be helpful and told them I wanted to learn. No surprises, and I got a crew that was OK with my level of interest. They were working for a rating - they wanted the highest score.

    After a bit of shopping, you will be a pro.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Jane
  • 10 years ago

    good advice Jane..I'm an over analyzer and a perfectionist..decisions are stressful for me but my husband has a good head on his shoulders..it will work out..we're always here when work is going on..mistakes are less likely to happen..learned more about sliding glass doors in the last few days than in my entire life..time to make more calls..

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I installed a $1,500.00 Jeldwen for $1,500.00 or so and took an absolute pounding. If I made nine bucks an hour on that job, I'd be surprised. That's what you get when you bid before checking with inspection for their requirements.


    They made me run rebar from the footer to the lentil inside the block walls and fill the cavities with concrete. If a hurricane ever comes to the west coast of Florida, that 60s house may blow down, but my door will be standing, guaranteed.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Joseph..we don't have hurricanes..our install is probably different..we know UNTIL the old door is out you don't know what's what..but I hate how the dealers avoid pricing on JUST the door..comes across as deceitful..

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I don't even bid door work any more. It's as hyper competitive and stupid as the granite business. I'll wait until the people call me after their job is screwed up.

    I was called to repair this floor next to the new door installation. Looks good, duddnit?

    It's sittin' on a bed of canned drywall mud. That's a hacksaw blade I shoved under. Of course inspection approved this. Hey, it looked good.

    I never made it back to this job. Once the homeowner told the licensed contractor what I'd found, he pulled the door, made the appropriate repairs, and threw in the floor fix to keep me from coming back.

    You can't make this stuff up.

    nicholsworth Z6 Indianapolis thanked Joseph Corlett, LLC