Software
Houzz Logo Print
elizabetheva

Hood vented into cabinet?

10 years ago

I'm posting a question on behalf of my mom, who is currently standing in her house that is under construction and probably having a panic attack, after a series of odd mishaps that have left them a week past their close date.

My parents are inexperienced builders, this is the only home they've ever built, so they assumed the oven hood would vent to the outside because it did in our old house. When they were working on the kitchen, it came up because they noticed it wasn't. The builder agreed to vent outside, but they had to add a soffit, and they didn't center it in the wall, so in the end my mom said to forget it and they removed the soffit. At the time my mom asked the appliance guy if they need a different hood, and he said it is intended to be used either way, vented to the outside or not.

Well yesterday they installed the oven vent, and apparently it vents into the cabinet. Which seems completely crazy to me, although I'm not much of a cook so I don't know a lot about hoods. Why would anyone want to vent hot air into a small wood cabinet? My mom knew she would lose part of the cabinet space due to the unit, but the problem is that now when the hood is on the cabinet doors blow open, which is the round about way this issue came up. The builder wants to nail the doors shut. This also seems crazy to me - it doesn't allow access to the part of the unit that is recessed into the cabinet. Aside from the fact that there are other ways to secure the doors aside from nailing them, with latches or magnetic catches, it just seems like a bad idea - isn't that going to mean the cabinet will absorb all of the food odors and steam from the cook top, and won't that damage and possibly warp the cabinet?

I'm trying to piece this together second hand, but I'm guessing that the unit can be converted either way to a vent system or a fan, but that if it's used as a fan system it's not supposed to blow air into a cabinet, but be installed with a filter like mine. Can anyone clarify this for us?

Comments (20)

  • 10 years ago

    Bad bad bad don't accept that. It will put hot wet air into the cabinet and wall. It will warp. Split and pretty quickly have mold growing. It must vent outside, not into the attic or any other space. The only type that doesn't is a simple recirculating vent. This is not one of those. I can't even imagine suggesting nailing the doors shut.

    EvaElizabeth thanked ravencajun Zone 8b TX
  • 10 years ago

    There are hoods which can either recirculate or vent. Can you find out what hood has been installed?

    EvaElizabeth thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 10 years ago

    The appliance guy told my mom this hood could be used to vent or to recirculate. When they bought it the intention was to vent, but then their plans changed and they were told they didn't need to get a different hood. As far as I know it hasn't been retrofit in any way, so maybe he meant it could be used either way as long as it was retrofit somehow?

    It is an Air King, but my mom isn't sure what model. She guessed Seville, but I think she just did a search on her phone and guessed based on the picture.

    What are the different methods of allow for recirculation in the room? Can they just open up the top of the hood cabinet?

  • 10 years ago

    If the hood is or can be used as a recirculating hood, that recirculating happens within the hood itself. Some hoods allow for either and it is a function of installation. So if she has a hood that can be made to potentially be recirculating, it may be installed incorrectly. If she can identify the hood for certain, you can look up the manuals for it online and see if that's a possibility. Alternatively, she should be able to get the manual from her contractor and take a look herself.


    The current installation is clearly wrong, but what needs to be done to fix it depends on the hood--it may just need a small and easy fix with the existing hood or it may require a different hood.

    EvaElizabeth thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 10 years ago

    I have a Broan hood insert (not the one linked above), and there is a recirculating kit sold to fit that insert. There might be one sold to fit your parent's hood, too. SMH about the builder's solution.

    EvaElizabeth thanked mama goose_gw zn6OH
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    If it's able to recirculate, then simply pipe it to the top of the cabinet. Hard to tell anything about it without knowing the make/model of the hood/vent.

    EvaElizabeth thanked Taylor's Cabinets & Interiors
  • 10 years ago

    I don't see why they couldn't have centered the vent or at least hidden the fact that it was off center with a centered soffit, and continue to vent outside. Maybe something was in the way? The day they put it in we walked in one day and there was just the hose sticking out of the wall several feet above the cabinets, off center from the hood cabinet. When my mom brought it up they said they could do a soffit in the laundry room on the other side of the wall, but it would have obstructed part of the doorway, and at that point she just said forget it. I remember thinking at the time if they could do a soffit on one side of the wall, why couldn't they do a soffit on the kitchen side? But, at this point the house was already weeks past it's completion date and I think my mom was just tired and wanted to pick her battles.

    In the end they are opening up the top of the cabinet. I am thankful for the responses, though, so my mom could push their builder to do something better than nailing the doors shut, which still astounds me. It still doesn't make sense to me that the air would go through into the cabinet at all if it's supposed to be recirculating, and if it's "recirculating" back into the kitchen through the cabinet, I would want a pipe to take it through the cabinet to release it above, because I think the same thing about grease and junk in the cabinet. BUT, at least what they have worked out sounds reasonably safe compared to nailing the doors shut.

    Also, it's an induction range, I think a Bosch?

  • 10 years ago

    In the end they are opening up the top of the cabinet.

    Doesn't solve the problem. If the hood is doing anything other than working as a recirculating hood (not requiring a vent pipe at all) it needs to be vented to the outside. Not the cabinet. not above the cabinet not to the attic space but to the outside.

    Often the vent pipe goes through a cabinet (the cabinet hides the duct) but the end result is the duct ending at the roof jack on the roof or through an outside wall. Nothing less is acceptable.

    EvaElizabeth thanked wildchild2x2
  • 10 years ago

    "The builder wants to nail the doors shut."


    That would have been the signal to invite him to take the rest of the day off to think about his asinine approach to the issue.

    EvaElizabeth thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    Ridiculous. Your parents are being ripped off make sure that they do not make the final payment before these people disappear. Hire a separate building inspector to inspect their work and get it fixed.

    EvaElizabeth thanked practigal
  • 10 years ago

    I'm trying to talk my mom into a centered soffit above the hood, extending from the existing cabinet, to vent to the outside, straight up through the ceiling. This was her original plan, she just didn't consider that there would be a soffit, and when it wasn't centered she freaked out. She thought about extending the cabinet, but it looked terrible in the renderings. I'm wondering if anyone has seen pictures of a soffit, maybe with some kind of facade, extending vertically from the cabinet above the cooktop? They are building a fairly traditional home and have vaulted ceilings, and the pictures I'm pulling up are all in homes with low ceilings, modern homes with vaulted ceilings, or are of hoods with exposed ducting that extends all of the way to the ceiling. Aesthetically I might not be able to talk her into it, and since I haven't seen pictures of this it's possible that's because it would look terrible, but it's worth a shot. I know my mom, and if she had known about the soffit she would have designed the area above the stove completely differently. I think the idea of starting from scratch panics her, so I'm trying to think of a way to work with what she has.

    Right now they are so far past their expected completion date, I don't think my mom is really thinking logically. There are other things that she can let go and deal with on her own when the house is complete, but this is one that would be a huge expense to deal with after the fact, and I think she will really regret it. Besides, if she was just going to install a recirculating system, she could have spent a quarter of the money and it would be the same, since as far as I can tell, a fan is a fan.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you for the reminder about the independent inspector, by the way. My mom is a high stress person so I have to admit, there were times before this that I thought she was overreacting, but now I'm starting to think this builder has probably been taking shortcuts and because this is a retirement community a lot of these people don't know any better. This is off topic, and not really that important, but in retrospect, I'm curious: is it normal for a builder to learn after the fact about the need for a sump pump and then install it without consulting the buyers about where it could go?

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    When I look up the Seville, it doesn't look to me that it would allow for venting other than to the outside. If it is indeed the Seville. Seville Install instructions. I would agree with you and try to talk them into the venting outside if they stick with that model. That or go back to the appliance place who supplied them with the hood and some obvious incorrect information regarding the venting either way. Given the incorrect info, they should return the Seville and get a hood which can indeed vent into the room. However, even with venting into the room, they should have a charcoal filter. Some exhaust hoods allow for the fan inside to be rotated within the appliance for ducting up or ducting forward.

    EvaElizabeth thanked Design Loft Bracebridge
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This is our improvised soffit because I wanted it vented outside. Vent is to the far left inside the box, due to a rafter in the way in the center.

    I can't get the photo to show up. So will keep trying


    EvaElizabeth thanked lyfia
  • 10 years ago

    What I have learned is that this particular model is intended to be used as part of a ducted system, but can also be retrofit to recirculate and pull air through the filter and then recirculate it back into the room (rather than just installing a recirculating system that is really just a fan) in situations where venting isn't practical - like Lily'smom described. It was most definitely installed incorrectly. So, since they have to go back to square one anyway . . . they are going to have them vent to the outside!

    When they walked through the house yesterday, they learned that the vent on the roof for the range vent has been there all along. It turns out, the ducting was installed in the attic above the cooktop and out through the roof, but somehow the drywall went into the kitchen without ducting. Which is really weird to me for a bunch of reasons, but i'm just glad they're moving forward.

    Thank you for posting the picture of the wood-clad soffit! It gave me a few ideas to suggest to her. It's a little harder now that we're working with the backsplash and side cabinets that are already there instead of designing the hood from scratch, but I know we can make something look great.

  • 10 years ago

    No it is not normal.... Get that independent inspector. Don't let her make anymore payments until you do.

    EvaElizabeth thanked practigal
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Our cabinets were all in along with counters etc. when they had to add the wood box too. Not my favorite feature for sure, but it was better than any of the alternatives at the time.