I'm not going to sweat to it but fleshy, waxy leaves that look like St. Aug & break very easily sure sounds like doveweed. If it were springtime my guess would be Crabgrass, but that's not likely this late in the year. Either way, kill em all when it comes to weeds

Its a strange one to me that's for sure, this is first season I've seen this. It is a very tough and thick feeling grass blade. Definitely not crabgrass, but obviously some sort of grassy weed. I've left a few of them alone in the turf for a while to see what they do, never spread or changes much at all.

Where do you live? Could be course fescue

I'm located in the midlands of South Carolina. I never even considered it could be fescue. I just looked at some pics of course tall fescue and it does look similar. I'm going to hit it with some celsius and see if it has any affect. If it's fescue, celsius should knoc it out or at least hurt it.

Turflife419, What cultivars are in your turf?

Bkoomug, it's a monostand of tifway 419 bermuda.

I think I might have an idea what this could be. I found one growing under a shrub and was able to get down to the root. What I found attached to the root looks a lot like a tiger lily bulbil. I did have a tiger lily that came up voluntarily within a bed of liriope that I transplanted from my parents yard. I left that lily for a couple seasons and I know it produced lots of these bulbils during its time. What do y'all think?

Here's what the bulbils look like.