Software
Houzz Logo Print
tarolli2011

Heat greenhouse with compost?

10 years ago

I have a cheap 6x6 greenhouse surrounded by gallons of water at the ground. By early AM, it is the same temp as outside air so I could not put plants in it too early last spring. I will add bubble wrap this fall.

I am thinking of adding a 6x3x3 compost bin along the north wall. I would bury tubing in the compost with the ends piped into the greenhouse. My idea is that the hot air in the tubing would get hot and expand, releasing heat into the greenhouse. But I need some way to draw cold air into the tubing.

Has anyone used compost to heat a greenhouse? How did you do it?

Comments (15)

  • 10 years ago

    Never done it.


    Natural convection would move the air in into the tubing. Inlet at ground level and outlet higher. Once the outlet pipe is in the greenhouse you could also put a 90 on it and run it up a few feet to act like a chimney. You will likely need a fan of some kind to circulate the air within the greenhouse as well.

  • 10 years ago

    You would need a constant supply of browns and greens to keep your compost pile hot. You may want to use a combination of cold frames and the green house. There are some YouTube videos that show people having great success using the combo and having very early planting.

  • 10 years ago

    this works best in a larger greenhouse, as the surface to volume ratio is more favorable. as John says you need massive amts of OM, and possibly a scheme to put said OM in columns or walls on the North side of the GH for the purpose of greater OM aeration (and greater heating power). also the water needs to be inside the GH, at least 100 to 200 gallons, and the seedling trays right on top of the buckets, if possible in direct contact with the water, to maximize the temperature at the tray's surface.

  • 10 years ago

    The amount of heat a compost pile of that size puts out would be rapidly withdrawn if you circulate air. I would leave it static and let it warm the surroundings as well as it can that way.

    That's just based on my gut feeling from messing around with heat, air, cooling and related subjects. And having a lot of chemistry, a little physics, a wood stove, and a family member who takes me on HVAC and boiler service calls for fun.

    You would need quite a large one to heat a room for any length of time. Back in the 70s or early 80s, Mother Earth News had a story by someone who made a huge wood chip pile with tubes in it and preheated their water with it during the winter.

  • 10 years ago

    Insulation first.

    That size compost heap will not produce much heat, certainly not enough to keep a greenhouse warm. Any efficient air movement would suck the heat out of the compost.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This is a great video that shows how layers of protection can move you as much 1.5 growing zones south (northern hemisphere) per layer of protection.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I've thought about doing something similar, but I was going to keep the compost inside in a hot bed. It would give me an elevated surface for working, more thermal mass inside, more heat where I want it. But, I was only going this direction because I have no power where my big garden is. If i did this at my home, I would take an easier route and toss some blankets over the top at night and use soil warming cables or a small heater on a thermostat.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Some years ago Mother Earth News had an article about using a compost pile to heat a greenhouse and the New Alchemy Institute has done more research on this. some people have put piping in to a compost pile while others have simply built hot beds in the greenhouse.

    https://attra.ncat.org/attra-pub/viewhtml.php?id=57

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    I agree with layers of insulation. Some kind of a blanket that could be rolled over the top at night would be ideal.

    I don't know whether this greenhouse is up against your house but I've had some thoughts on that arrangement. I have a patio on the south side of my house. Always wanted to put a greenhouse back there with one side against the house. There's a basement door there that could be an entrance to the greenhouse from inside the house, so it would act like an unheated lobby of sorts, and an outside door to the greenhouse will still allow access to the outside. Anyway I would think having a wall up against the house would not only provide insulation for that wall against the cold, but might actually shed some amount of heat into the greenhouse. On warmer winter days the door could be left open to harvest some heat from the greenhouse.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I understand that the desire is to use compost, but years ago raw manure mixed with bedding was used to add heat to greenhouses. People still use the technique with hot beds, but it was much more common back when horses were the transportation of necessity. The aisle ways in the greenhouses were over-top troughs for the manure. Smelled like a barn I'm sure, but manure smell was more common years ago.

  • 10 years ago

    A very, very OLD book on hothouse gardening in Scotland recommends a bed of horse manure several FEET deep, inside a pit in a brick and double-glazed "pinery".

    It take a large volume to keep the heat up.

  • 10 years ago

    that is what farmers do around here to produce early melons. Low tunnel (which will have low volume), and under it, a big deep trench of manure.

  • 10 years ago

    I've seen that in gardening books for keeping a cold frame warm. Gotta wonder how the manure gets enough air to heat up when it's several feet deep.

  • 10 years ago

    Many people here are talking more about making a hot bed rather than using the heat generated in a compost pile to heat a greenhouse. Probably a 4 x 4 x 4 compost pile would not be large enough to heat a 6 x 6 greenhouse.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    I really greatly appreciate the wonderful help. Here's my current plan:

    I will still do the compost because I need it, and I will put some tubing in it to help with the greenhouse heating, but not rely on it. Since I will not be depending on it for heat, I changed the height of the compost to only 2 feet tall. (Because I am 71 years old and disabled, I have to shovel while seated, and it would be hard to get the compost out of 3 feet high bins.) My original plan was to use grass and leaves in the fall, and to fill in with fresh horse manure as the compost sank. Now I will just use my many bags of fresh grass clippings that I have stolen on garbage days, plus added leaves this fall. I will let it sink down over winter and not refill.

    This fall, I will dig a pit in the greenhouse as deep as I can manage. I will make a frame to extend it above the ground and wait until spring to put in the fresh manure. Since I am not very agile, It will not be much bigger than 2-3 trays of seedlings. I can rotate the plants within the trays.

    I also plan to buy/make one or two layers of cold frames to cover the hot bed inside the greenhouse. I am also very careful to cover my plants with old quilts on especially cold nights.

    Just in case, I will plant my precious tomato and eggplant seeds a second time a month later in case I lose the early batch. In zone 6B, my first, main planting will be Feb 15, which is a month earlier than normal. I set out plants in the garden with waterwalls May 1 and cover every single night. I have not lost them to cold.

    With your great advice, I think this is the best plan.