Can you post another pic with the granites reversed? I'd like to see the lighter one next to the backsplash

Warm wood tones and grays don't love each other. I like both countertops but suggest a different floor.

Here are the countertops, one pic of each in front of the backsplash (the pic in my original post shows the color of the backsplash better). I added the floor tile to the pic. Instead of left and right, please refer to them as darker and lighter.

Backsplash looks best with the lighter counter. But really the backsplash feels like the odd man out. The tile and the darker quartz both go with the cabinets. They're all warm and casual feeling. The backsplash not so much.

The backsplash doesn't work with your other selections. Your cabinet stain, flooring and counters are all very casual and rustic looking but the backsplash is very modern. I like the darker quartz better with your cabinet & flooring (but prefer the lighter quartz in general). I would repick your backsplash.

prefer the lighter quartz

DARKER

I prefer the contrast of the lighter. Agree the backsplash is a touch modern.

Light countertops but find another backsplash. I would get everything else installed then focus on the backsplash. I have a similar barnwood look tile floor, dark cabinets and fantasy brown quartzite countertops. What are your Quartzsites?

My tile

What doesn't work are your cabinets - they're just totally different than your other choices. If they're a fine deal, you need to start over.

Like the lighter countertop. Don't care for the back splash with the other selections.

I agree that your backsplash doesn't fit with your other choices. If I had to pick out of those two, I would say the lighter Quartz.

I like the cabinets with the darker color counter and the floor but the backspash is the odd man out. Or if the cabinets, backsplash and floor are already decided I would go with the lighter counter but then the cabinets kinda don't go.

I think the best counter for the cabs and backsplash is the darker one.

What wall color are you using?