Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_28510257

Tow behind vs backpack sprayer

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Looking forward at the next year of lawn care, I think it would be worthwhile to get some sort of electric pump powered sprayer. I have about 7,000 sq ft of lawn and am currently using a 4 gallon manual backpack sprayer to spray the front, about 3,000 sq ft of it. The back has not been receiving the same amount of care but will starting this year. I expect to be blanket spraying on average about every 2 weeks, possibly more frequently in the summer:

  • PGR
  • Fungicides
  • Iron + N

I am currently thinking of two options: a battery powered 4 gal backpack sprayer or a 15 gallon tow behind sprayer. The backpack sprayer would probably take 2 fills to do the entire yard. Any opinions on which one you would use? Any recommendations on a good quality sprayer?

Comments (31)

  • 10 years ago

    I'm all about playing with big fun toys in the yard though!

    Me too! I have two garden tractors (a Cub Cadet 1450 and a 2072) and I need neither :-)

    I agree with your concerns related to the tow behind. I also do have one concern with backpack sprayers. The spray pattern is so narrow you have to make many passes to cover the entire area. It's almost impossible to not miss a strip of grass, and in the case of PGR it becomes very visible very quickly. I wish dyes would work a little better.

  • 10 years ago

    I can see how that would be an issue. The tow behind spray rig would certainly be more consistent--I'm sure you have your eye on one already, how wide is the boom on that one?

  • 10 years ago
  • 10 years ago

    That's pretty sweet, but I have 2 questions right off the bat:

    1) How much will an appropriate 12V battery cost & does the trailer have somewhere to mount it? I assume a motorcycle battery is the right size & you'll need a charger for it if the mower battery isn't compatible or too far away.

    2) Since the wings don't fold & there's only 2 nozzles, do you have 7 feet of clearance everywhere on your property? It is nice that the nozzles are able to rotate for a narrower pattern, but if you can't get through the trees you may be pulling out the backpack anyway.

  • 10 years ago

    I bought a Chapin 4gal battery sprayer a few months ago. I use it every 2 wks for PGR, etc. It is so fun and easy. The included tip and wand assembly works just as well as the custom wand/tip assembly suggested on that other site. Since the pump is battery operated you have constant pressure and won't need all that other stuff recommended. The pump actually performed worse when I had the additional pressure regulators and stuff attached to it.

    I have bleached my fence, shampooed my carpets with this thing. It has made spraying the lawn a very easy task. I have 5k and it take less than 10 to mix, spray, and clean. Also if you have any 20v black and decker battery packs, they are all interchangeable so you will never have to worry about that.

  • 10 years ago

    1) How much will an appropriate 12V battery cost & does the trailer have somewhere to mount it? I assume a motorcycle battery is the right size & you'll need a charger for it if the mower battery isn't compatible or too far away.

    My understanding is that it runs straight off the mower power/battery. If it doesn't, it will :-). The engine puts out 15A, should be plenty to run it.

    2) Since the wings don't fold & there's only 2 nozzles, do you have 7 feet of clearance everywhere on your property? It is nice that the nozzles are able to rotate for a narrower pattern, but if you can't get through the trees you may be pulling out the backpack anyway.

    It's a concern, I can think of two spots where this might be an issue. Also, the whole thing has to be stored somewhere, so it will take up space.

    I bought a Chapin 4gal battery sprayer a few months ago[...]

    Thanks, that helps a lot hearing from someone who has already used it.


  • 10 years ago

    Thank you all for your input. The winner is:


    https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00Q03MMDO

  • 10 years ago

    Man, I'm adding one of those to my Xmas list right now

  • 10 years ago

    I do recommend one upgrade if possible. If you have an old solo wand lying around, remove the red trigger locking clip and install it on this hanle. Having a trigger lock does wonders for this when cleaning, volume testing, etc.

  • 10 years ago

    I received the package from Amazon and of course, immediately took it for a spin to spray some iron. I turned it on, pressed the trigger and -- nothing. I was sweating bullets. Eventually it started spraying, I guess the pump was priming. This thing is great, nice even pressure, much easier than the hand pumped one. The only thing I really missed was the locking trigger, so I'm going to buy the solo one and swap it. Overall very happy with it, this is going to be great.

  • 10 years ago

    Glad it worked for ya! Spray some fish fertilizer or kelp extract with that iron & you will be shocked at the results. I know it would offend your anti organic sensibilities, but those liquids are extremely cheap compared to your usual chems & go a long way.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, I actually do include ammonium sulfate in the mix with the ferrous sulfate so the fish fertilizer would be redundant. But what does the kelp extract do?

  • 10 years ago

    It's a bio stimulant, you have one of morpheus' kelp recipes on the lawniac site. I use it on bare spots, underperforming or leggy areas in the shade, or to boost the uptake of whatever I apply. It works especially well as a "kicker" when spraying weeds with herbicide--Cuts the burndown time in half.

    What is ammonium sulfate & how does it do the same thing as the fish fertilizer? I bet it smells better than the fish...

  • 10 years ago

    Well really fish fertilizer is just a source of N, so the plant takes that in foliarly (is that a word? my spell check doesn't think so). Ammonium sulfate ((NH₄)₂SO₄, 21-0-0) is a synthetic source of N, it is used as a fast release fertilizer. As opposed to say urea which has to be processed by bacteria, the ammonium is directly available to the plant. Along with the iron, it deepens and darkens the green color of the plant. It does not smell at all.

  • 10 years ago

    Urea can also be used as a foliar spray with similar results. I've never tried urea but I may next round.

  • 10 years ago

    I think the fish fertilizer is a lot more than just a source of N, but I see what you're saying.

  • 10 years ago

    Good choice on the chapin, I think they make really good products. Are you using a boom with your new backpack?

    +1 on kelp, good stuff there in my opinion. Check out these articles, they're pretty interesting:

    http://blog.planthealthsolutions.com.au/kelp-helps-demonstrate-benefits-natural-chelation/

    http://grounds-mag.com/mag/grounds_maintenance_biostimulating_turfgrasses/

  • 10 years ago

    Dang, that grounds mag article says seaweed extract increased bentgrass root mass by 66% in their tests at Virginia Tech. I would call that significant!

  • 10 years ago

    A boom with the backpack sprayer? What a wonderful idea. The Chapin is 35-40 psi, is that enough to run 4 nozzles?

  • 10 years ago

    Reeljake, Quite amazing the many benefits seaweed extract has to offer!

    J4c11, I'm sure a boom would serve you well, but 4 nozzle might be a bit much. I think it would depend on nozzle setup though. I currently utilize a chapin 2 nozzle boom on my chapin 62000 manual pump sprayer with 21psi Cf valves and teejet 110 02 extended range nozzles. Pressure only has to be maintained just above 21 psi for this boom to work properly. I'm really intrigued by the electric pump model though and was curious if you were going to use a boom with it. Here's a pic of the boom I use

  • 10 years ago

    I'm definitely going to get some sort of boom setup, probably the Chapin 3 nozzle. I'll let you know how it goes.

  • 10 years ago

    That is awesome! You hold it out in front of you, or out to the side, or it attaches to the backpack somehow so you can just walk?

  • 10 years ago

    At this point, my plan is to build a small "cage" out of angle iron with a sleeve hitch yoke welded to it and a few clips for the boom. Then I can just drop the sprayer into the "cage", hook it up to the boom and start riding around.

    I modified a standard pull behind Brinly core aerator last year for sleeve hitch attach and it's been great, no more getting off every time you have to cross the driveway.



  • 10 years ago

    Personally, I would refrain from making any changes to the Chapin sprayer. You are going to be at serious risk of a pump failure with any alterations (ask me how I know).

  • 10 years ago

    Nope, no changes to the sprayer, just adding a Chapin approved boom.

  • 10 years ago

    Is the hitch hydrolic?

  • 10 years ago

    Yes it is. It will lift 250lbs, possibly more, but I tested 250 on that aerator. Front wheels went up in the air a little but hey, it worked out :-)

  • 10 years ago

    If you could spray & aerate at the same time, that would be amazing!

  • 10 years ago

    The pull behind is nuclear grade overkill. I have been killing 6 acres of kudzu using a 4 gallon pumper and have had great results. Just make sure you have the correct nozzle on the backpack sprayer and are not walking too slow. I can sray about an 8th of an acge with one 4 gallon fill.

  • 9 years ago

    Chapin a good brand . Smith seems really good also.