Software
Houzz Logo Print
uscroy

A very OCD bathroom question

10 years ago

I am putting two medicine cabinets over each sink in my double-sink vanity. The one I'm using is the Robern below.

The sinks are four feet apart and there will be three feet of open wall in between the cabinets. The cabinet comes in a left hand hinge version and a right hand hinge version. Does it matter if both medicine cabinets are hinged on the same side or should one be left hand and the other be right hand?


Comments (15)

  • 10 years ago

    How far in from any wall on the sides of the sink are the medicine cabinets? That would be the only reason I can think that it might make a difference.

  • 10 years ago

    On one side the wall is 12" away from the cabinet and on the other side the shower glass is 12" away from the cabinet.

    Just realized I got my measurements wrong in the original post. There is two feet of open space between the cabinets, not three. So 12" open on the edges and 24" open in between.

  • 10 years ago

    The obsessive in me would want the most symmetry possible - if possible. If they can't comfortably open towards the wall, then maybe towards the center space?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    On both sides they can comfortably open in either direction.

    The reason I have this dilemma is that I have an opportunity to install two cabinets with the same side hinge at a huge discount over the regular price. I don't want to let stupid OCD get between me an a good deal.

    The pragmatic in me thinks that most medicine cabinets only come one way, there is no left or right option. So if I had chosen such a medicine cabinet this wouldn't have even crossed my mind and I'd be fine with them both being the same.

    But since there is an option the OCD in me wants them to be symmetrical.

    Robern probably makes two versions so that people with space constraints can buy the one that works best, it's probably not so that people with two cabinets can have symmetry.

  • 10 years ago

    The cabinet we recently installed had option for opening on either side. I think my preference would definitely be for both cabinets to open from the center toward the wall.

  • 10 years ago

    Unless you are trying to "cure" your OCD or can't really afford it, I say get the ones you want. Otherwise why go through all the trouble of a remodel/build?

    ;-)

  • 10 years ago

    There is a big difference between "can't afford it" and don't want to waste money. If I just bought everything I wanted because I could afford it this remodel could easily cost double.

    I'm not trying to cure my OCD. I'm trying to figure out if there is any downside to having both cabinets hinged on the same side or if there is a practical reason to have them hinged on opposite sides.

    I like chispa's 3-way mirror effect suggestion.

  • 10 years ago

    Looks like it could be turned upside down and open the opposite way with no issues. Most cabinets can.

  • 10 years ago

    Definitely not this one. The cabinet has electrical outlets and USB inside on the bottom shelf. If I turned it upside down those would be pretty useless. Power for the vanity light is also at the bottom and would be unreachable if it was upside down.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    >>>I'm trying to figure out if there is any downside to having both cabinets hinged on the same side or if there is a practical reason to have them hinged on opposite sides.<<<

    Depends on how you use the space and how you plan to use the medicine cabs. Are you able to mock them up for example by taping cardboard "doors" to the wall? Personally in most cases I would want to be able to stand in the middle and open both doors away from the center (hinged on the outside), but that's just me (don't really style my hair or anything like that). YMMV so why not try out different configurations and see what feels most comfortable to you?

  • 10 years ago

    I'm with chispa: If you can arrange to have the hinges toward the center, I know that the 3-way mirror effect can be useful, having previously had this in another house. In my current house I have a custom built pair of medicine cabinets with a center mirror, but the cabinetmaker put the hinges on the outside so I can't get that effect, and I miss it. Not a huge deal, but nice to have if you plan for it.

  • 10 years ago

    Are you and your spouse/roomie/etc. each getting your own cabinet? If so, are you usually in the bathroom at the same time? If not, it just might not matter where the hinges are--it looks like the cabinet is pretty much symmetrical.

    But the back-of-the-head view can be pretty nice!

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Quote : '' But since there is an option the OCD in me wants them to be symmetrical. ''

    Kinda answered to yourself , with this .

    First feel , most of the time , counts in the long run . You can ask yourself ...... how would you feel more comfortable if you have one open -- left one -- and need to open the other one -- right one -- in the same time to take an item from it ?

  • 10 years ago

    To get the back-of-the-head benefit do you need both cabinets to have a center hinge? If there is a mirror between the cabinets, can't you see the back of your head using one cabinet with a center hinge and an adjacent mirror on the wall? Or do you need that third one?

    If you need the third one, will you still get the effect if the cabinets are three feet apart or is that too far to get a good look?