Software
Houzz Logo Print
numbersjunkie

Dallas white granite?

10 years ago

I have Ikea Bodbyn gray cabinets and wanted a counter that would lighten them up and read more white than anything. I fell in love with Fusion quartz by hanstone but the price is ridiculous for a vacation rental home. My fabricator showed be this granite that looks good and will cost $3k vs $5k for the quartz. Add a few hundred for 15 year sealer. what do you think?


Comments (9)

  • 10 years ago

    It doesn't read very white to me. Can you get a less expensive white Quartz?

    numbersjunkie thanked lisadlu16
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Don't get the 15-year sealer. Several reasons:

    - most granites just need annual sealing. The smallest bottle of $15 sealant from Home Depot will last you probably longer than you will live in the home. It takes 5 minutes to wipe on the sealer once a year.

    - some granites are so dense they need no sealing whatsoever. I've had mine for 10 years, never sealed it, spilled everything on it, and it looks like the day it was installed.

    - "15 year sealant" tends to leave a plastic-y film on the granite, marring its beauty.

    numbersjunkie thanked friedajune
  • 10 years ago

    Yes, I know it does not read "white" but it really does have white background, some cream, gray, and little specs of the dark red - not as much as some pieces I saw from another lot. I think with a white subway backsplash it will be OK. It really does have white in it - this lot more than an other they had.

    Unfortunately, all quartz is going to be much higher I'm sure - the one I wanted (Fusion) was $75 and this granite is $40. Huge difference. Also, if I go elsewhere for my slabs, that will increase the cost. I was actually shocked that I found something at Level 1 pricing that I liked.

    Also, a few concerns I had about quartz was, because we rent, I was afraid of people putting hot pots on it. I know granite isn't bulletproof but it is much more forgiving that way. Also, most of the quartz looked too modern for my space - or too formal. And the cost of course. The $5K would have been more than we paid for our IKEA cabinets! It just felt crazy to pay that. And then I would stress about damage occuring.

    I was originally looking at solid surface - for about the same $3k cost as the Dallas White. But could not find anything with enough white but not all white. It just had no personality.

    Interesting comment about the 15 year sealer. I will definitely have to ask about that and maybe get a sample piece coated. One place I found online said this stone apparently has a absorption of about .35, another said .24. I know light granite's tend be be very prone to staining, and that was my main concern. I can apply sealer on my own, but this way it is guaranteed - whatever that means! I was hoping for comments from anyone who has this installed - as far as staining and maintenance.


  • 10 years ago

    If you frequently rent this property, why not put in laminate? This way, if it's damaged, it won't hurt as much. Scatter a bunch of trivets and pads around. There are a lot of very pretty laminates. I've seen some that were so close to marble I have had to go touch them to make a determination. The fact that the house is rented would change my thinking about the money I was willing to commit to the project.

  • 10 years ago

    I think it goes well with the cabinet color. The light in that pic isn't great. If that's a sample of the cabinets, I've seen them in person and they're lighter than they appear on my screen so I imagine the counter is too. If you like it and it's in your price range, what exactly is it that you're questioning?

  • 10 years ago

    I love the color combo and with the white subway tile (make sure you get a good match), it will look great!

  • 10 years ago

    homechef - I should probably clarify that we are planning to
    retire and spend a lot more time at this house which is why we are doing the
    remodel. For that reason, I really
    didn't consider laminate as an option. We
    will still rent it out on occasion so I do worry about others not being as
    careful as we would be! Also, we have a wide peninsula that would
    require it to be custom fabricated and I doubt the cost, including 2 sinks, would
    be very much less that the $3K.

    I agree that the lighting in the picture is not great and makes things appear darker than they are. I think it will look fine and that the "color" of the white tile will be important.

    The purpose for my post was really to see if anyone had
    really bad things to say about the granite we are considering – does it chip or
    stain easily, or would it be prone to darkening over time as I have seen with here
    with some other light granites? I guess
    I worry that something so inexpensive just must have some problem! And I was also wondering about the 15 year
    sealer – if others had experience with it.
    I know I can seal it myself regularly, but then if it stains anyway I
    can’t hold the fabricator responsible!

    I did get a sample from the other lot of slabs (a bit darker). They had no samples yet from the lot I was considering as none of it had been cut. I will test the sample I have just for fun.

  • 8 years ago

    I'm late to this discussion! We just redid our kitchen less than 2 year's ago, and we chose Dallas White for our counter top. It wasn't the least expensive, OR the higher end either, somewhere in the middle. We got a good price on it, because we live in a very expensive area, where the drive further out makes most things much more affordable! We have not had any problems with it, but I am always very careful not dropping heavy things or ever cutting directly on it, for fear of staining! We have White cabinets and it just goes beautifully! I think all Granites are lovely, even the lower priced levels with the right colors can be quite nice.