Software
Houzz Logo Print
arlieehammons

Painting interior house

9 years ago

Getting ready to have house interior painted. Need advice on best paint for walls and more important I have oak doors and trim everywhere in the house that is to be painted. The contractor is specifying a oil based primer and two coats of Super Paint from Sherwin Williams for the wood. And two coats of paint or the walls. I just went to Sherwin Williams website and read the comments on their Super Paint. Many of the comments are not positive. If anyone has direct experience with what works best that would be great. The home is large (9000 sq ft) as is the cost to have it painted.



Comments (11)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I would not paint that oak. At least not on site, if you have really made up your mind. You have a 9k square foot home with some pretty amazing features...though a little bit 80s? Maybe 90s... Painting the wood is final.

    Are those solid core doors?

    If they are solid, I would have them removed and sprayed in a shop. If they are hollow, perhaps it doesn't matter .

    The staircase is problematic. There could be a lot of chipping if not done right. You painting the treads as well? I don't think your painters are up to the task. Superpaint? Well, at least they didn't suggest Annie Sloan.

    Best of luck. Please post photos. I think it will be exciting to see how it turns out.

    Arlie Hammons thanked User
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    quote"Superpaint? Well, at least they didn't suggest Annie Sloan." LOL, or any paint and primer in one!

    Arlie Hammons thanked Christopher Nelson Wallcovering and Painting
  • 9 years ago

    Superpaint is paint. It looks fine, but it's just cheap, so it won't be as durable as the more expensive paints. Pro Classic is better, but I will only spray it. It's not a self levelling paint, so the brush marks may show, especially if the painter is a noob. I stay away from SW for trim paints for the most part, but all painters have their preferences. If you paint that oak staircase, it will not wear well on the steps where you walk and my opinion is that painting it would not look right. I realize we are living in the era where people paint all stained wood, but the staircase should be left alone.

    Arlie Hammons thanked paintguy22
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Even after three coats of paint, oak will still show its heavy grain.

    I agree with Paintguy, the treads will not wear well. Also, all varnished woodwork which was painted over is more chip prone. If you go ahead and paint the woodwork, make sure you save plenty touch up paint is small jars with no air in them, so that it will last for several yeas of touch up.

    As far as the finish coat, I would either use oil paint or one of the new water based alkyds. SW does have a version of it, as does Ben Moore and Behr. Spraying is going to give a far superior look than brushing.

    Your contractor is not choosing a premium paint! Using less than top quality paint is "penny wise and pound foolish"!

    Arlie Hammons thanked Paint sales at Home Depot
  • 9 years ago

    9K sq ft, I would leave the trim till last, if at all. Update your wall color to compliment the wood trim and your current decor and furniture. You can have a updated look without painting the trim, and that's what I would do. BTW, it doesn't pay to cheapen out on paint or labor in the long run.

    Arlie Hammons thanked Steph
  • 9 years ago

    I don't know enough to comment on types of paint, but since I can't even imagine how much this is costing, I'd be sure to have picked a contractor I know does good work. Reviews online can be priceless.

    Regarding the wood. I understand the want to update it, and I would. However, I'd do a bit more research in painting it or having it restained into a more current color. Staining it, if done properly as with any job will last you longer. Especially the stair treads, I would not paint those, I'd stain them.

    Arlie Hammons thanked Lindsy
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you everyone for the comments. Looks like I need to do a bit more research. Where I live quotes for work range all over the board. And believe it or not hiring long established firms no longer guarantees a good job. Frustrating.

  • 9 years ago

    Tried Zinsser Smart Prime on a couple of windows I had to get painted before additional glass was added. I put on the primer, waited until the next day and added another coat of primer. Waited another day and then put on two coats of Benjamin Moore Impervo. It been 2 weeks now and I can scratch the paint and primer with my nail. Thankfully, the windows are high so not much of a issue but I still must find a primer that isn't going to scratch or chip. And should I be using a oil paint?



  • 9 years ago

    Oil paint is not required. A high quality 100 percent acrylic or hybrid will do just fine. SmartPrime is a cheap primer, one step below 123, though I am still surprised it did not stick. You should sand the existing finish to dull and be sure the wood is clean before priming. I would use Benjamin Moore Fresh Start primer, which is more expensive but when you are painting over stained and varnished trim, you really want to use a good primer that will bond.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    It is kind of a given that "latex" paints don't bond to oil and varnished surfaces. This once true opinion goes back to the early days of "latex" paints, many of which actually had natural latex resins in them 60 years ago. Today's 100% acrylic based primers and paints are actually capable of giving a good bond directly to the hard, slick, old oil finishes.

    I have personally tested Behr Ultra Semi-Gloss Acrylic Enamel and Behr's Water Based Alkyd directly over high gloss oil paint and urethane varnish. Wanting to see the worst case scenario, I did not even scuff sand the surface. In both cases, I have tried hundreds of times to scratch the paint off with a finger nail to no avail.

    If a dedicated primer is to be used, My preference is for BIN pigmented shellac. Nothing is better over super slick surfaces. BIN will stick even to glass and ceramic tile! BIN was my primer of choice when spraying varnished kitchen cabinets: great adhesion, super fast drying, and no "fish eyeing".

    Arlie Hammons thanked Paint sales at Home Depot