Software
Houzz Logo Print
ana474

Anyone here use marble on kitchen counters?

13 years ago
last modified: 13 years ago
I am at the process of having to go look for my counters for my new kitchen. Honestly I have been looking for 4 months. I really wanted calacatta marble on the counters, but could not find the nice golden color (all were taupe) and cream, and many many people told me never marble on the counters.

I can not decide what to do. I have an off white creamy kitchen perimeter and cherry islands (2) that are going in now.

I was going to do a black absolute leather finish on the perimeter, but then can not find a nice plain cream leather finish for the islands. I think going absolute black on all counters would be too much black.

Anyone have advice on whether to go with the marble (we are Italian and cook tons) or what goes with an absolute black leather finish that I can do in a cream on the islands that comes in leather finish? Do I have to do a leather finish on the islands? I am really confused

I will have between the fridges these glass doors and on the ends of the center island the same glass doors

Vetro Neutra Bianco Lux Glass Mosaic Tiles · More Info


love this look for counters, but I think the island is marble right?

New Display · More Info


and love this look, but in reverse with black on perimeter and cream on island, but again marble

Classic White Kitchen · More Info


Is there any resolution to get this look in a cream non speckle granite, orrrr?

Sorry for my messy kitchen, it has been a mess (house molded) so you are seeing it mid construction with super worn and dirty marble, but doors and hood between the big center cabinets go in next week and the white make shift island is what I have been cooking on for months, so ignore that too.

I have to also consider the back splash which I like in all these pics too.

I'll post a pic of my kitchen before the mold for size and stuff.

Comments (29)

  • 13 years ago
    here is my kitchen before the mold, I reversed the room putting the hood this time on the longer wall and got rid of the breakfast bar thing in exchange for 2 islands so I can have 2 fridges and have it more open to the family room. I also made it more contemporary because I felt it was too old world outdated to do it the same all over. This photo also gives a more true color to my marble as well
  • 13 years ago
    ah, I will go back and look, thanks so much :) I think this is a BIG issue for many of us. It is hard enough I lost an entire kitchen and have to make new decisions all over again, the old kitchen was only 6 years old to begin with :(
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    feeny, yes, other very popular ones include "should I keep my tub for resale," "do I keep the same finish," "desperate with backsplash," "do I need a rug here," "what do I put on this wall," "which tile," "which paint color"... :) I think Houzz should do a Top 10 FAQ or Top 100 FAQ :)

    Ana, yes, all the choices can be overwhelming at times. Our kitchen (and the rest of the home) is 30+ years... so much work. :)
  • 13 years ago
    yes, but this is not only the question of JUST marble, but also can I put leather finished black perimeter with a non-leather finish islands in different colors? Would that look stupid? I can not seem to even find a cream non speckle granite at all, which is the reason I was still even considering the marble.
  • 13 years ago
    Ana... yes! So many choices and options! :) Thus design Dilemma indeed! :)
  • 13 years ago
    Ho, Ana, I read and added to that thread mentioned above. I'm going to go with the marble on my k countertops. I've always wanted it and was talked out of it during the last k remodel. I think you really have to read everything you can about the pros and cons ( look at yesterday's post) and then do what is right for you. I love the wear and tear the patina of aging things. Do you? Keep learning and looking. But get what YOU want.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Sweetdee- nope, I hate the look of worn patinas on things. This is exactly why I was told not to use the marble even though I love the look of it. I would love my kitchen counters to look the same in 5 years as the day I installed them, but hate the speckle granite and prefer the veining of marble.

    I guess if that is the case I am answering my own question. The problem still exists of what material then? I see people mention this quartzite, but have not seen it in 6 granite yards in south florida.

    My husband wanted to go with the man made quartz on the islands with the leather finish of black absolute on the perimeter, but I think that would look really bad. Hubby is pushing me after so many months to make a choice, but every granite/marble yard I go to there is never a nice creamy veined or pretty looking granite so I keep going hoping I might find the perfect one before the kids are all grown up lol
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Eztia, thanks, but corian is def not my taste.

    I really like this counter, but have never seen Kashmir White that was not grey, but cream as this appears. If anyone knows of a similar granite that is this kind of warm color please let me know. It also looks like they did mix the honed black with the regular finish on the island. It looks good so I guess you can do it.

    Kitchen · More Info
  • 13 years ago
    Quartzite.
  • 13 years ago
    Evelyn, yep, I think you are 100% right, I can just not find it. I have been to so many granite yards here in S Florida. Also, I have no idea how much quartzite costs, is it super $$$?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I would recommend a different color and finish on the island countertops than the perimeter countertops.
    I would also recommend that you consider one the marble look a likes in quartz from either Cambria or Silestone. Quarried Marble is high maintenance.
  • 13 years ago
    The problem you're finding about the color is a fear of mine. I haven't even started to look at slabs yet. I prefer the creamy opposed to the gray, also. What about limestone? Going to look at the quartz, too. I think the pictures on line that we're looking at and dreaming about might be unrealistic. ??
  • 13 years ago
    http://hillcountrygranite.blogspot.com/2010/12/quartzite-in-lost-creek.html. Just found this site, pictures of quartzite counters. Really pretty!
  • 13 years ago
    This is one of the few granites I like. Maybe you could try to see it in person? It is Alaska white.
    http://houzz.com/photos/2030508
  • 13 years ago
    This alpinus is also a dramatic looking granite.
    http://houzz.com/photos/3166947
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I was just about to suggest quartz when I saw you mention it in one of your comments. I definately think it would be a good idea to check out Silestone and Caesarstone. Also think about look-a-likes like the picture above. If you are dead set on the look of marble, you can find other stone that has that look without being so porous.
  • 13 years ago
    Too bad you can't find quartzite. I just redid my island countertop in a dark quartzite and I found it at the first granite yard I visited. It's pretty expensive - at least the cost of a level 6 granite, but it's beautiful and harder than granite. I'd probably have both perimeter and island either leathered or shiny. Keep looking for quartzite - I think it's just what you're looking for.
  • 13 years ago
    On the quartz look counters just make sure you see a large scale sample in person. I know they are coming out with more realistic ones all the time (I believe cambria torquay is a good one) but some look great in a small sample and not much like marble on a large scale.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Sam0705 I agree, that Alaska White is really pretty granite.
  • 13 years ago
    I've had honed Carrera Marble in two kitchens and, while I love it, it definitely shows signs of use over time I think that adds character but understand why others wouldn't find it appealing). We currently have polished Carrera in our main bathroom and that looks exactly the same today as it did two years ago when installed. So, if you really want marble, you should consult with your stone fabricator regarding the finish. A friend installed quartz countertops in her kitchen -- look very similar to mine in terms of overall look but seem to be more durable. You might want to take a look at quartz - perhaps you could find something similar to to the marble you like.
  • 13 years ago
    Well, I bought my counters today. I ended up going with a honed black absolute for the parimeter, and a honed crema marfil marble for both islands. The fabricator told us it will need sealing on the marble every 3-6 months, but has a wipe on sealer he will give us. It was just the perfect color to compliment my cabinets and my marble floor as well.

    I tested lemon juice, palmolive, and tomato paste on the marble and on the polished side within one hour the lemon juice pitted the marble and the other 2 left a dull spot on the polish. On the backside that was unfinished, but matte (more honed look) the lemon juice left a bleach like spot, but nothing else bothered it, so the fabricator assured us if we are diligent in sealing on the honed it would be ok.

    I am going to have my husband cook with brown paper on the islands regardless though :)

    I spent so many months looking for counters and the only thing that was making me happy was marble as far as looks, I could never find the color of calacatta I wanted without any grey, so I just had to take a chance and go for it. It was so reasonable too, which was a deciding factor. I got all 4 slabs (which covers my islands, parimeter, an entertainment center top, and 2 cutting boards) and a 2" mitered straight edge on all edges for 5K including the fabrication and install so it was just too good to pass up. We'll see how it goes.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Every fabricator I have talked to discourages marble for the kitchen. It scratches and hard to maintain. Not a good idea for such a busy area of the home.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    MBB I am aware of the issues with marble, but I was looking for a specific look (going on a 3rd kitchen in my house) and not a fan of man made quartz or busy granite (have had it and not been happy for 12 years), so although I will have to maintain it more so than granite I am prepared for that. This go around it boiled down to 'settling' vs 'buy what I really love'.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I have had a marble counter for 9 years. I wanted a certain look as well that I could not find in granite or Quartz. It Really needs to be maintained constantly. It does show every water mark or scratch even though mine is a golden marbleized looking pattern. Remember to wipe up water immediately and to reseal it every year. It is pretty but very unforgiving!
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    They currently have marble in many, many old castles. Yes, it stains and spots, develops a worn out look, but, as a solid surface it can be sealed, refinished, buffed out or left. It is unsuitable from the standpoint that it will not stay perfect, but it will be there and probably fixable. I am a fan. Have a lot of it. The cheapest product w/ the most luxurious look in my opinion. Truthfully, if quartz had been an option for me $$$wise, I probably would have.
  • 13 years ago
    We have honed white cararra in our kitchen and it looks quite nice. We have had a few spills with no issues. Citrus definitely does etch. We had also gotten a few scratches but we knew that going into it. The best sealer is dry treat stainproof (good for 15 years)but you must carefully follow instructions.

    http://www.drytreat.com/
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    catz1 I agree. I have had royal oyster marble floors in my entire downstairs for 12 years. I have spilled so much stuff on it, dropped numerous things, people walk on my floors with shoes daily, it survived 2 major renovations, 1 mold out of the downstairs, 6 people living in the home, and numerous parties with women and high heels. Does it need refinishing after all the abuse and has the polish matted down, yep for sure and as soon as the kitchen renovation is done the floors will need to be refinished. I figure if my floor can take all this abuse for 12 years and still be fixable, then surely the counters will survive, especially if putting brown paper down for cooking purposes.

    Are marble counters a pain, probably, but to me beauty is never easy to maintain in any sense.

    Thanks grubstake for the tip :)
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    We agree with many of the good comments here. Marble's maintenance is an issue. The person who tested the lemon juice etc. had some excellent points. You should look at Quartz. The big three companies; Cambria, Caesartstone and Cosentino all have marble looks but with all of the benefits of Quartz. Cambria Torquay is a beautiful white with small flecks of taupe and pale grey. We have used it many times for people who first wanted marble. In the kitchen photo, we used Cambria Torquay on the island and Berwin on the perimeter. Quartzite can also be a wonderful choice, but it does have more maintenance than Quartz. You need to ask about the specific selection before making a purchase. We hope this helps, good luck with your project! Share photos when it's done, it is going to be beautiful!

    Dazzling Transitional Design · More Info