Software
Houzz Logo Print
knightzerox90

Retaining wall vs deck

9 years ago

Hi,

I've been debating back and forth on an issue with my home that has caused a lot of frustration.

Short story, builder screwed up and didn't plan an appropriate exit out the back door of the home. The door exits to a 13 foot drop to grade. The house is on a slope and going from left to right when viewing the home, the grade drops.

The front entrance is fine and also on the front of the home. The laundry room exit was made to be also on the front but opposite side of house. The builder offered to put wooden stairs down which I rejected because of leg injuries and my dogs will use this as a exit as well.

My options are pay $17,500 to "fill in " dirt with a double stacked retaining wall about 16'x 35' to make the area level or do a deck for about $11,500. There is also an option to just build a small ramp upward to the exit instead of a full deck area as well.

I've attached photos of the site. Any help appreciated. Very frustrated with the builder.

Comments (8)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    "...builder screwed up and didn't plan an appropriate exit..." Well I guess. Is the builder willing to rectify the situation?

    It looks to me that it may be possible to build a deck outside the back door which projects beyond the face of the house, with minimal steps and/or ramp in the direction of the left side of the photo, parallel to the face of the house. In other words, a deck projecting out beyond the house for whatever dimension you want with access/egress toward the left margin of the photo, where the grade appears highest.

    It appears that the ground slopes off so much to the right side of the house that it's impractical to build anything in that direction.

    What do you prefer to do?

  • 9 years ago

    Its hard to believe a deck wide enough to allow egress from the house would cost that much.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi,

    The builder is willing to give $2500 credit off the price to resolve the issue. The numbers I posted are AFTER credit. The actual cost of retaining wall is $20,000!


    I should be more clear, the door is in the back of the photo posted. The side entrance you see first is where an Ac unit. I've attached more photos.


    I would like the retaining wall wall because I need a yard area for my dogs. If I just do a small ramp the yard could be on the grade side minus the deck, but I worry about long term maintabilty and if that will look really that for the house.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    You do not want to have access in this direction--it makes no sense with the fall off of the ground. You need to look at access in the opposite direction toward the high ground. You and your dogs can easily access grade up there. Why don't you want access where the grade is more positive and convenient?

  • 9 years ago

    Hi Vrigil,


    I do want access from the high ground. In the photo above you can see scaffolding to an entryway. The laundry room exit door is there. The easiest solution is to have a ramp come from the higher ground to a small deck and make a right angle turn into the laundry room door. It can be made with just the entrance being decked or making a much larger deck for a sitting area.


    I'm waiting on a final quote for just the ramp and smaller deck, but I worry about wether it is really worthwhile to spend the larger amount of money on filling the area with dirt to make the entryway level and provide a larger flat yard.

  • 9 years ago

    How is this just coming up now?

  • 9 years ago

    I notified the builder of it during before foundation pour and they said they would take care of it. Notified them again and was told they would take care of it and fill it with dirt and it would be fine. Then finally as we get close they swap out to just building some cheap wooden stairs as something to meet code because of cost. They aren't owning to their mistake and I don't know what legal actions I can take against them to fix it.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Franklin County's Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting