The round rug seems to fit very well, but for some reason I've never seen a round rug that looked good to me when it was in place. I would go for the rectangular, preferably the larger one if it fits nicely into that space.

I prefer the 5x7, so you can arrange it as close/far away to the fireplace.

You can then fit the 2 chairs on it more or less.

The 5x7 allows you more options.

Cowhide. Neither round nor rectangular, and can be rotated to wherever it works best. Plus, cowhide.

Yes to the cowhide!

I love a good cowhide! Otherwise 5x7.

5x7. No cowhide. It's a tripping hazard.

If I were to do anything in an animal rug it would be a sheepskin. Gotta honor my New Zealand citizenship and Scottish heritage. But the two little rugs I have over by the bed are sheepskins which I already have. The other big rug over by the tv is a MacKenzie tartan pattern.

Here is the big area rug,

I have a stack of these and was planning on one on either side of the bed,

And found this to go in front of the stove,

These are the two existing chairs I'm going to use there, they are swivel chairs.

bad lighting, but they are an apple or leaf green

Ok, you all have helped me figure out what to put where. I'm going to start a new thread to get opinions on the colors and styles to put together. Or should I just keep going here?