Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_981897

Seeking grow light recommendations

9 years ago

Allow me to detail my use case:


I am building an indoor herb rack as per this design:



The expected width of foliage is about 6 ft. Now what I'd like to do is mount above the upper rack a rectangular or cylindrical grow light (maybe two smaller ones) which will sit in a reflective shield facing toward the wall. The lights in shield in turn will be clamped into a bendable gooseneck arm that is mounted to the wall.


My reasoning here is that the room does not receive sufficient natural light to promote growth, but I don't want that light permeating the entire room (hence the shielding) and the gooseneck mount will give me the adjustability to experiment and adapt with the plants, and aim them so that both levels of the rack get sufficient, if not perfect light.


So my general questions:


1) What kind of lighting would best serve this purpose? The growing goal is leafy foliage and lots of it - not seed or flowers - so I figured metal halide, but maybe a higher frequency weighted LED would be good enough? This will be in a main room of the house, so I'd rather the light look closer to natural than be optimized for color. I’m not just looking to maximize yield, but to build a house decoration that is overall pleasing to the eye.


2) Can anyone recommend specific brands for the design purpose I laid out?


3) What am I not considering?


I'll consider all suggestions.


I am definitely less experienced with DIY than others, but I'm not afraid to spend a few dollars and get my hands dirty to do some craftsmanship with wood, plaster, drywall etc. but I'd draw the line at welding, or any kind of metalwork.


Thank you in advance!

Comments (5)

  • 9 years ago

    You have an interesting situation. Does it get any direct natural sunshine on that wall? Let us say you 4hrs of direct sun coming through windows then you want to make use of that. You will be hard pressed to beat that intensity. I would probably think of say 4 ft 4-6 bulb led tubes suspend from top and angled towards the plants say at 45 degree angle and say 6-8 inches away from the plants. If you adjust it correctly you can still not shadow the direct sun.

    Jon thanked tropicofcancer (6b SW-PA)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thank you for responding, @tropicofcancer. The fixture will be an in an open floor plan room that gets a lot of low grade ambient light, and there's not much I can do about that, nor can I obstruct the windows with the apparatus. I've tried growing indoors before using natural sunlight several times, and there's just not enough intensity. I was thinking along the general lines of what you suggest in terms of placement. Do you think LEDs will be enough for herbs? If so, do you know of any brands that have a "natural" looking spectrum (I know that's subjective) in roughly the wide and thin bulb shape I'm describing, and where I can get a close-fitting, but wide angle reflective shield? The product lines from the online grow light manufacturers I've come across seem geared mostly to larger greenhouse and hydroponic setups, where whole rooms can be dedicated and high yield is paramount - not the lesser strength, more aesthetically appealing approach I had in mind. Thanks again for your help.

  • 9 years ago

    I missed the aesthetically pleasing part. There is a company that manufactures showroom style led grow lights that fits the bill most closely. The name just escapes my mind right now. They are expensive - like $100 per fixture or so.

    Most grow lights or any fixture adapted for growing is going to look "industrial". But here is what you can try: Avoid full spectrum red/blue type grow lights. They have this awful purple color. Aim for high CRI daylight type lights. 3500K-4000K lights will look more natural and still have enough blue in them for leafy plants. Any higher it will look harsher bluish coloration. If the lights are going to far away from the plants you are better off looking for higher wattage and more focussed beams of lights.

    I know I did not fix your issues but hope that helps.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I would say an MH grow light (Metal Halide) would be the best type for your situation. Here's a pretty useful article explaining:

    http://www.htgsupply.com/informationcenter/resources/hps-grow-lights-vs-mh

    TL;DR

    This gives off less 'red' light, and more closely matches the spectrum natural light has. Also, the article specifically mentions this type being good for herbs :)

    Hope this helps.

  • 9 years ago

    I grow with HID's & agree with Brian. They really pack a punch & are well worth the $$.

Sponsored