Software
Houzz Logo Print
kklembara

modern vs traditional artwork

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

I am looking for a picture to go in the gold frame above the fireplace- any suggestions for a type? Abstract, landscape, geometric, etc. I am attaching the second picture because it is in the room and I have to take it into consideration when choosing the smaller picture for above the fireplace.

PS- I would love to get rid of the artwork above the buffet but my husband said no. I was considering painting the frame entirely black to make it less "gaudy". Thoughts?

Comments (30)

  • 9 years ago

    What are the measurements?

    kklembara thanked apple_pie_order
  • 9 years ago

    Sorry- I wasn't clear- I am looking for a picture to go in the frame on the fireplace. I just have to make sure to take the "gaudy" painting into consideration. :)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Simple black and white of some architecture.....something like this..maybe a historic building in your area or a city you love..will work very nice.

  • 9 years ago

    great idea- thank you!

  • 9 years ago

    Home Interiors with Ease- how do I get a print of that picture? :)

  • 9 years ago
    You need portrait not landscape dimensions to fit over your fireplace.
  • 9 years ago

    I'd leave the frame as is, gold ties back to the frame you're trying to fill.

    I would not go abstract art. Keep the style complimentary to the other painting and your decor. The photo may not be bad idea.

    kklembara thanked User
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Etsy...has loads to choose from!

    this one I just found on a google search...

  • 9 years ago

    Before investing any money for that frame, I'd cut out a picture from a magazine to see what the impact of that size of frame is on the mantle. Plus you can play around with black and white, color and style.

    Regarding the black/gold frame. You might think about putting a light glaze of black over the gold so that the gold and detail still shows through but quiets the gold a bit.

  • 9 years ago

    Oh sorry I misunderstood about what your plans were. I don't think a fireplace surround like that needs art. Were you planning to hang it or lean it? I'm assuming you intended for the mirror to stay? I'd take both the small frame and the mirror off.

  • 9 years ago

    Taking both off just seems so plain...

  • 9 years ago

    and a glaze sounds helpful- I like the idea to "quiet the gold". :)

  • 9 years ago

    here is a picture of the mantel straight on- I am wondering if without the mirror there isn't enough height?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I think it is perfect! The shapes and sizes work very well together....

  • 9 years ago

    The frame over the buffet is appropriate for the ornate and formal style of your room's fireplace, wall coverings and furniture. I'd remove the floral arrangement in front of the picture, especially the dried grass part that overlaps the picture.

    To my eye, the mirror frame is too modern and plain for the style of the room, also too short and wide.

    I'd have a piece of mirror cut to fit the inside of the molding over the fireplace. Then place something substantial in front of it - a vase or sculpture that looks good reflected in the mirror. There's a bit too much going on, on the mantle, and it takes away from the fireplace itself.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I like patim idea of having a piece of mirror cut to fit the inside of the molding. And you could always do a light antiquing on the mirror surface if the mirror wouldn't reflect anything of interest. And yes, without the mirror the gold frame is to small on its own.

  • 9 years ago

    I have mixed feelings on doing the antiquing glaze ("black glaze" noted above). It will tone down some of it, but the antiquing glaze with proper application will likely still have a bit of the gold show through so if your intention is to mute the gold entirely, this may not be what you want (the application done properly may turn out very nicely, but I guess I am saying that I'm not sure if it will "mute" the color in the way you may be thinking). You wipe off the glaze in application, typically, so it will extenuate the details of the texture and "carving"-- with this level of detail on the frame it can turn out wonderfully, but just be aware that it's not usually meant to be a paint that you "paint over" like traditional paint to cover over colors, if that is what your intentions are with the application. If you don't know what the frame is painted with, I would be a little cautious as well; sometimes certain types of paint interact differently together impacting adhesion. Test a small area first, if that's something you decide to do.

    I personally would leave the ornate frame as is until you get the mantel done. If you dislike the frame that much, perhaps you could consider having it reframed entirely to select something that you feel matches your decor better that still also compliments the piece. I would, again, not paint it flat black-- thick frame and will of balance with the size of the painting (put draw attention in maybe not a good way). You could consider priming it, painting it a light color then doing the antiquing glaze to bring out the details to reduce the "gaudiness" without flattening the detail as an alternative consideration if you want to rid the gold entirely.


    Re: mantel. It's a tall space... the full photo... I have to agree with partim. The mirror setting on the mantel doesn't actually balance the space to my eye. And, I agree that it doesn't match the over all style of the mantel. I would second considering an application as partim noted. That would likely match the style, and permit it to be complimentary and balanced as far as style, orientation and scale.


    There's a lot of options, as you can see from the feed back. Ultimately, what looks good to you is what matters the most, so I hope you'll share the results once you make the decisions and applications!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    A graphic photo on the wall and a black and white architecture print on mantel. I'd take the lamps off the chest and get one really cool modern lamp, and leave the mantel, it looks great! I like how you have the mantel styled. Unless you can find a similar mirror that is taller and fits within the molding. But the black frame is a nice contrast and i love a leaning mirror and the layered look on the mantel. Go with what you love!

    Can I ask what you have in the vase on the mantel? I like the sparse look of the foliage and the color!

    Beautiful room!

  • 9 years ago
    Thank you all for the ideas- I appreciate the thought you put into your answers. I will definitely look into the type of paint before I do anything to the larger painting- and I would love to find a larger, thinner mirror but haven't had much luck. And it will all be leaning- I don't have the nerve to drill into the cast stone. ;)
  • 9 years ago

    What kind of foliage is in your vase? it's pretty!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    P.s. after looking at the room again, if you left everything AS IS, and just found an abstract drawing to put in the smaller frame on the mantle, to mimic the pillows, I think the room looks great the way it is! (I think that was your original question)

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I just put this in a gold frame to see how it would work. I like it in your room. Linear.

    http://www.greatbigcanvas.com/view/scattered,1912520/?s=XM8MlU72D9X2UWp0QNc33G6KglgxIQEuF5MLNR1C7sC334mt7MU67kW17G6wuc7d

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    As to the gold on the frame that your hubby wants to keep. Buy some antiquing glaze at hobby lobby, 2$ bottle, rub on to desired look, it tones down the gold. I've done it on many a gold frame.

    kklembara thanked 007homey
  • 9 years ago
    Thank you willowshome- I love the vase too. I bought it at a consignment shop probably 20 years ago!
  • 9 years ago
    What is it about the painting above the buffet that you dislike? The style? The subject matter? The color? The medium? Just curious because art is such a personal matter it is very difficult to guess what you might like in the space (look at the difference in reaction between you and your husband, for example).

    I see the gold frame above the mantel you want to use. Is it archival quality framing with UV protection in the glass/acrylic? Is there a specific medium you desire? Are you looking for something more unique or are you looking more for staging type decorative pieces?
    kklembara thanked Hello Kitty
  • 9 years ago

    You can go to a custom frame shop and have them frame a mirror to your specs. If they can't provide the mirror, you can get one to the exact size you want from a glass & mirror store. Or if you find a "standard" frame, you can have the glass/mirror company add the mirror for you.

    kklembara thanked tedbixby1981
  • 9 years ago

    JudyG Designs- I like the painting for a different wall in that room, but it comes in too large of a size. Still searching for the "right" architectural photo. I really like that idea- along with a "better" mirror. Ill post when I find something- thank you all again!!!!