For the wood vanity, so a white or marble look quartz.

Since they are both small, you may be able to use the same slab for both.

Fantasy Brown for both if you can find great slab of granite it would look good in both baths. Don't let the name fool you. It is grays and whites. On one slab, you could work out largely white piece for one bath and grayer side for other.

Heather, I believe in you! you can make this decision on your own! :)

I would use white quartz for both - clean and simple.

I would think twice before you pick a black counter top in the bathroom. It show every water mark, toothpaste and generally never looks clean after one use. We just switched our top out to a lighter granite. The installer said he does these switches all the time. Black is too hard too keep up.

Thank you all so much for your advice! Flo, wouldn't Fantasy Brown be to busy with this shower? I like the idea of white Quartz for his....black with his dark cabinet may be too dark.....still not sure about mine.

Thanks Dishington for the confidence:) kchap, is the water spot problem only with plain black granite? We were thinking of using
patterned black for the perimeter counter in the kitchen....same problem?

I've got a sample of the black granite. I put ketchup, red wine ,salad dressing and a wet glass on it. Will check it tonight.

Today's the day for choosing all the Quartz, granite or marble for the kitchen and 2 bathrooms. Exciting and a little scary! We're going to a big stone yard and they just got a shipment in, so lots of choice. :)