Software
Houzz Logo Print
jendeslauriers

To paint or replace

9 years ago
See pic attached as these are the shaker doors we have in the house. We are replacing all the trim with white/modern trim and I want the doors to be white. Should I paint them or replace them? Anyone done either approach?

Comments (7)

  • 9 years ago

    Definitely paint them. It isn't cheap to get someone in to fit doors. Are they varnished or waxed?

    Jen DesLauriers thanked shelleyuk
  • 9 years ago

    You may want to send the doors "out" for deglossing and spray-painting. Saves you the mess and fumes, just make sure the contract states the newly painted doors to be properly "wrapped" so there's no damage during delivery. I agree that all the baseboards and door trim should be changed - you will be amazed at the difference.

    Jen DesLauriers thanked chiflipper
  • 9 years ago

    paint

    Jen DesLauriers thanked dyliane
  • 9 years ago

    Wood moves with changes in temp and humidity which will leave hairline cracks at the joints - doors have lots of joints. If that will bother you, replace with MDF white doors, which are more stable as to temp changes, and sell your wood ones. In general, stained wood doors have more value than white doors - which are usually MDF.

    You can paint or replace the trim with white and leave the doors stained.


    If you are painting the doors white to go with the gray trend, keep in mind the gray trend will end leaving you with a "dated" house. Changing out the trim is not a big deal, but a whole house remodel from warm tones to cool can get expensive.

    Jen DesLauriers thanked jhmarie
  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Hello Jen. I would possibly explore the idea of keeping the doors as is. The doors look to be fir, very nice! I have done many jobs with stained doors and painted trim. To me it looks sharp. I find beauty in wood and personally like it. It has character and is beautiful. Have your new trim put in. Have a look at it against the wood doors. From the trim not even being painted you may be able to get a good idea of how it will look. It is all about one's preferences really when it comes to their own home and what they find appealing and comforting. You can select your preferred trim colour and have a look at it once the trim is complete. Doing the doors in-house is not big deal. Many of the homes I do are lived in so, often I do things on site by hand as opposed to being sprayed. It is less intrusive and more cost effective. With the right professional and the right product one can have a very sharp glass like finish done by hand as one see's when trim is done by spraying application. It is really all about the application and products being used along with the knowledge and skill of the applicant. This could be much more cost effective than a company coming on site, removing the doors, spraying them in a shop, protecting and packaging up the doors, and shipping back to site. as the trim could be done by hand and come out looking smooth and great.

    I guess depending on your area in world there are varying styles. But style is somewhat always part of one's personality. As far as fumes go and cracking in the joints of the doors, well there are a few amazing latex based primers and new hybrid topcoats that are out there that will do what the old oil based/shellac based paints did in the past. Only exception being is that these paints breath unlike oil based products and they also allow the wood to move. That means you joints will not crack and smell and toxicity levels are very minimal. It would be just like if you painted the walls in house, some smell but nothing toxic.

    I hope my advice and opinion is somewhat helpful to you and help you in the decision making process. One thing at a time and go from there. Get your new trim package in, select colours, and proceed from there.

    Jen DesLauriers thanked Palace Painting & Decorating
  • 9 years ago
    It's a great style door, I would paint and keep. If it's solid wood, then it's a no brainer to keep them.
    Jen DesLauriers thanked ycity