Software
Houzz Logo Print
renk777

Kitchen tile...where to end?

9 years ago

So we started our kithen reno almost 5 years ago :D Today, my husband started to put the backsplash up. He does everything as correctly as possible...I like to bend rules and cater to my artistic nature. Ha! My question is this....it's a small space and it occurred to me that if we extend the white subway tile around the entire room...not just above the counter but above the wainscoting on the opposite wall as well. ...that it would make the space appear more connected and larger. I know that's not the way to do it and my husband is against it but I can't shake the feeling that it would give the kitchen a more open feel as opposed to a choppy feel since the counterless wall in question is broken up by 4 doorways. It's not like it would be a vast expanse of tile...just a few glimpses to tie the space together. Am I crazy or can I win this argument? :D


Comments (17)

  • 9 years ago

    really we need photos.

    Its not about one partner being crazy and the other one not............believe me, I know.

    It's just about good design; what works the best according to one's preferences.

    Houzzer's opinions will help you both clarify.


  • 9 years ago

    It's an old house with section 8 housing across the street ..and up the street...in a les-than-desirable district. Our reno isn't anything epic...just simple changes and improvements from the dive that it was to make our stay here a little more enjoyable and selling a little easier. I fear you'll be underwhelmed considering all the beautiful renos I see on here LOL But I would love your opinions so I'll try to grab and post some photos tomorrow when it's daylight. Thanks so much!

  • 9 years ago

    less* I can spell. Really. I can. Haha


  • 9 years ago

    I think both would work actually - just depends, YHL did it:

    Blog post: http://www.younghouselove.com/2016/10/bright-white-kitchen-remodel/


  • 9 years ago

    The only problem 'i think would be the wainscoting. With both that texture and the tile, they might compete too much and be visually distracting.

  • 9 years ago

    no judgments Ren! Good design is good design - even on a dime.

    Best.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I would be concerned about too many "features" which would confuse the eye. So I wouldn't do the tile above the wainscoting. In your circumstance, probably not worth the money to do that. Paint in a interesting color that is pleasing to your eye and leave it at that. Not taking sides, just saying what I think will work best now and in a resale situation.

  • 9 years ago

    Grace H...that's beautiful! And I agree about the distraction with the wainscoting. Had we had the tile home when we installed it, I would have chosen something with a wider board for the wainscoting so that the textures and lines didn't compete. Too


    late for that ! Here are some photos. ..mid-project so it's a mess. Glad no one is judging! As for paint, I'm thinking a light blue/green grey above the tile in the few areas where wall is exposed... The last 2 photos show the counter and wall where I'd like the tile to pull the space together.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I was thinking about your wall color and I kind of think you might want to go with white same as the wainscoting! That would give you the best of both worlds. No line above the wainscoting that drives you batty and no extra eye distractions in a very busy looking space. Think about that a bit. You can always bring your accent colors in with a few accessories. Jade green pottery, a wall hanging, towels, etc.

  • 9 years ago

    I had thought about the all-white walls but I detest all white walls in my own space....love it in magazines...not in my space. My mom was off the boat from Germany. All our walls were white and she had no design sensibility when it came to my childhood home. Granted, we were poor but regardless of lack of income, mauve carpets and elastic waist bands are just a no. Haha. So anything that reminds me of that is automatically purged. The room does look busy but it's usually pretty bare...and the blinds are going, the pet door will be removed, the exposed wood will be white. ..including around the sink. It usually has a more open and uncluttered feel. But I do have 3 small children and 2 large dogs, 2 cats, and all sorts of fish. Due to time, it can clutter up quickly. ..so I really need to consider your advice. Wish we'd started on another wall with the tile since it already extends past the cabinet and counter edge....fine if we're wrapping it around but if hubby wins, not so much ;)

  • 9 years ago

    And Flo, I love the idea of three wainscoting up to the under-cabinet height. That would have solved everything. ..but it is a bit late now. I'll remember that for the next house!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Well, given your "history" I can understand, but this kitchen is anything but boring! Just consider it or go with a very "off white" to the color you want. If you see greens in the countertops? Then do an off white to a similar green. You would be surprised how much color is in the "off whites". Sherwin Williams has a brochure of their "off whites". Pick up one of those and bring it home to put in your light. See if a couple strike your eye. Then get some samples and do "sample boards" because you will need them to get a feel for what your cabinet, flooring, lighting etc., will do to the colors. Also, the off whites really don't give you the full "color" feel until you have a whole wall done and can actually see the undertones coming through. At first you will say, "that's too white", but as you get more up, then you will go "oh, I see what she means!" lol Tip of the day, sample boards on good white foam boards, or the pre-primed boards that SW has for sale.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi Ren - check out Kentucky Haze by BM - after I heard your story with "white" I do think a bit of color will work - but Flo has made excellent points.

    There is very little wall to be painted a color so I would go for it - easy to change if you don't like it after living with it for a few weeks.

    Everything looks great!

  • 9 years ago

    Visualize Maven...you rock. The color I had picked out was 'Rhino' by Behr. I was contemplating going a few shades lighter after the advice above but ultimately, that's the hue I'm looking for. I looked up your Kentucky Haze...look up Behr's Rhino and you'll see that they are VERY similar. I'm leaning towards letting my husband win the argument but then he'll still lose...because he'll have to remove tile he already installed that extends past the cabinet AND peninsula/counter. If we're not wrapping the tile all the way around, it just looks stupid being there. It really needs to end with the cabinet since ending with the counter edge would intersect a switch plate. So either I risk his fury and ask him to remove the tile, or I just go with the original plan of wrapping it...which would be tough now that I understand how it will achieve the opposite of what I was going for. Regardless of which option of keeping hubby happy that I choose, I appreciate all of your insights! Have a great week!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Probably not the biggest problem you will ever have and I'm all for "harmony"! :)

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for the props Ren - very appreciated!

    You sound like you know how to create harmony in a marriage and in your kitchen design!

    Keep us posted!

    Best.