Software
Houzz Logo Print
ps6fsu_de_z7

Need help picking a new tree.

9 years ago

I recently moved to Wilmington, DE and looking for some advice on a tree to plant in my front yard. There is currently a large Tulip Poplar tree there that is rotting and since it is very close to the house I will be taking it down soon. I am looking for something that will get tall enough to not block the front of my house but somewhat narrow so that it will not grow into the house about 15-20 ft away. A moderate to fast growing tree would be a plus. Im also looking for something that won't make a huge mess of my front lawn (sweetgum spike balls). After some research, my favorites were Black Tupelo, Freeman Maple, Trident Maple, and Silver Linden. Any thoughts on these? Should i consider something else? I am open to anything really... smaller tree...maybe even no tree at all.

Comments (23)

  • 9 years ago

    Does it have to be in the same spot? Now is your chance to start afresh and think about where you want a tree or trees. A bit farther away from the house might make sense.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Sara. It doesn't have to be in same exact spot. The picture doesn't show it but there is also a medium sized Pin Oak closer to the street to consider. My only reservation is turning my front lawn into an obstacle course for my large mower. I honestly would like to make a small round bed around the small tree on left and turn the rest of that bed back into grass. Google maps has an old picture that can help illustrate....

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for the compliment. Unfortunately I do not have any pictures of the front yard when yes are full. We moved here late in the spring and focused on the inside projects first. Between the oak by the street, the two poplars, and the neighbors maple... i have tons of leaves.

  • 9 years ago

    It looks like you have a large property (and a lovely home by the way). Perhaps you should consult a local landscape architect whose portfolio you admire. Personally, I would cut the tulip poplar, grind the stump and sod that bed. But we each have our own aesthetic and yours is the only one that matters.

    Paul_DE-7a thanked cecily
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Cecily. I actually agree with you. I would prefer more grass. Easier to maintain, less leaves to clean up, and peace of mind during storms. However, my wife really wants to replace the tree. My only concern about trying to sod the are is the work involved. The bed is raised at least a foot so I assume bringing it back down to level ground will require digging up the entire root system.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago


    @ Toronado... Thanks for the advice. I actually have a few Dawn Redwoods in the backyard. One is massive. It my absolute favorite tree on our lot. My wife likes it too but doesn't want it in the front. She wants something with fall color. That's kind of why i was leaning towards the maple trees.


  • 9 years ago

    I would agree with Cecily. If the tree has to go I'd take the opportunity to remove the bed altogether. It looks rather fussy to me and interferes with the sweep of lawn in front of the house. Not for practical reasons but for aesthetic ones. It's not as if there is a paucity of trees around. You have a beautiful yard.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    well ... as far as the forums i visit.. you get the gold star .. for being the first to work your drone into a garden forum post.... lol..

    remove tree ... great pile of mulch.. if you do it leafless ...

    spend this summer.. just doing flowers... and go zen on the tree decision ...

    i think your in too much of a hurry ...why does the tree have to be planted this spring ... fall is usually just as good a season ... and in the mean time.. the answer will come

    what about a tri color breech???

    ken

  • 9 years ago

    American Holly or Southern Magnolia.


  • 9 years ago

    Wish i could take credit for the drone usage Ken but this was a picture the real estate agent took when listing the home before we purchased. I absolutely love the Magnolia idea Dave.

  • 9 years ago

    cool pictures

  • 9 years ago

    Beautiful yard. I love the evergreens.

    Personally, I find grass a million times more work then trees. All that mowing. Think how many times a year you have to mow the lawn vs. raking leaves once or twice.

    Anyway, I like black gum. Good fall color, a bird and pollinator favorite, super wind resistant. (The later is a good thing if you are worried about storms) A bit slow growing, but sounds like you aren't super worried about that. Freeman maple are fine trees but a bit over planted. Silver linden have good form but are a bit boring to me and have no fall color or flowers. Holly and magnolia are interesting ideas, although magnolia can be messy.

    Is the soil clay or sand? Does it get swampy? Will the tree be to the north or south of the house?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The tree to the right also looks like a candidate for removal.

    Sorry, in Wilmington there's no reason to mess around with native Ilex opaca unless you have some political preference for native plants. Any of the various non-native hollies you could get at say, McLean Nursery in Baltimore or Patuxent Valley Nursery in HoCo., MD would have a glossier, showier leaf and - if correctly pruned - often a more desirable shape too. Recommendation might be Koehne Holly, 'James G Esson', or English Holly 'Lewis' if you like the traditional Christmas decoration look. (I think 'Scepter' might not be quite hardy enough.) Even a SE native hybrid like 'Longwood Gold' will be a better looking plant, long term, than a randomly-purchased-somewhere-in-Delaware Ilex opaca. Remember to get a suitable pollinator. I have huge native Ilex opacas in my yard, and various other hollies I've planted...the non-native ones just look better.

    And btw watch out for the nurseries there, the one in Hockessin isn't bad, per se, but back pre-recession it had the most breathtakingly high prices I'd ever seen at a "local garden center." Same with the new, urban-outfitters owned Styers. I can give other recommendations offline but don't want to seem to be be advertising. If you have money to burn, sure, shop at those places! OTOH, McLean in Baltimore has outrageously _reasonable_ prices. (it's different to recommend the couple places I did specifically for hollies, vs. plants generally)

    PS I personally do not recommend any maples other than Asian ones, but that's just me! An Acer griseum, for example, might look nice off the right, replacing the tree with a split trunk.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    "Silver linden have good form but are a bit boring to me and have no fall color or flowers."

    Huh? They have delightfully fragrant, small flowers. That being said, I don't see them as "first line" trees for suburban landscaping; though they have a niche appeal.

  • 9 years ago

    I used Silver Linden as a front yard tree for one of my houses. The season long summer foilage was the reason. The silvery undersides shown in the breeze was very pleasing.

    Another vote for changing that bed line. It doesn't make any sense visually or functionally. I'd put low growing perennials and confiers in this area as there are already multiple trees anchoring the house.

    Example of how the bed line can change...imagine mowing that line vs the current. Plus it flows better.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for the comments everyone. Very interesting getting different opinions.

    @Edlincoln... i have a 46" garden tractor so the addition of grass will be little to no extra maintenance. In fact, the obstacle makes it much harder to mow currently. With these trees I am picking up leaves every 2-3 weeks from Halloween until Christmas. The soil is tough to describe. Deep down is clay but there seems to be a good 2 feet of rich black/brown soil on top. The house faces south so the tree will help shade the front of the house until early afternoon.

    @Davidrt28.. the tree to the right with a split trunk is also a Tulip Poplar. The previous owner must have spent some serious money on this tree bc it has a thick wire cabling system installed as well as 3 or 4 long threaded rods drilled through at the base to help keep it from splitting. Thanks for your feedback on nurseries. I would love to find out more. We are new to the area and have no idea where to go for this stuff.

    @Whaas_5a... im beginning to buy in to your (and others') suggestion to not replant a tree. The idea of less leaves and faster mowing (less obstacles) is appealing to me. Maybe I can sway the wife with your narrow bed proposal along the pavers.

  • 9 years ago

    Whaas' bedline looks much better to me. The current shape looks like a jigsaw piece.

  • 9 years ago

    I too like the Wass' red line, flora, although I think it should come
    out more on the right side so the tree stump area will be in the bed
    rather than the lawn. That area is going to settle a lot after the tree
    is removed and the roots ground down. Pack new soil down as hard as you
    can and it will still settle. A flower bed can handle settling better
    than a lawn.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Beds, schmeds...I think there's already enough going on in the front of this house. There's no harm in just leaving the walkway to the door next to some lawn. It will help people see how to get to the front door LOL. If you put a big magnolia there, what's the point of that? Hiding the front of the house?

  • 9 years ago

    I'm one of those crazy people that thinks the more leaves the better! I want easy mowing but you can just mow the leaves. The benefits are extraordinary.

    Earthworms help create humus—a dark brown-black type of soil which holds important nutrients in place for plant growth and use. Earthworms also help create good soil structure; their burrows open up the soil and create aeration and drainage channels.

    Earthworm castings or excrement are rich in nitrogen, phosphorous, and potassium the key minerals needed for plant growth. Earthworm castings also help bind calcium, iron, and sulfur to soil particles—minerals that also help plants thrive.

    Adding chopped leaves, grass clippings, semi-rotted compost, and animal manure to your garden will encourage earthworms to take up residence in your garden, be active, and thrive.

  • 9 years ago

    Wow, that is a great property.

    I would remove the tulip tree and eventually replace its current bed with grass. I think it is best to let a nice walkway like that "breathe" with grass on one side, as opposed to having it boxed in on both sides with beds over the entire walkway length.

    Putting in a replacement tree is totally subjective. But if you do, I'd push the tree away from the house another 10 or 15'. I think an open, understory tree like a redbud or parrotia would look good there.

  • 9 years ago

    Just figured i would post an update. After some thought I was able to convince the wife to sod the area after taking down the tree. I also got her to agree to sod over an additional PITA large flower bed. I just got done with re-doing most of the beds and mulching. I think this layout is 100 times better. Thanks for the advice everyone.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths