Software
Houzz Logo Print
daryl_r

Is a Warming Drawer worth it?

9 years ago

I am re-doing my kitchen cabinets. I bought a powerful new stove and I need a powerful new hood to go with it - this necessitates redoing pretty much all the cabinetry. The cabinetry is old and ready to be replaced anyway. The question: I have a double wall oven as well as the oven in the stove. We often find ourselves using one of the wall ovens as a warming device - and it really doesn't seem to be optimal, so we were wondering if a warming drawer makes sense. Those of you who have one: do you use it? Is it worthwhile? Does it work well? What temperatures do you keep food at? We don't have that much extra space - would it be worth taking up more space for a warming drawer? (We will not be buying any other new appliances, so the double oven stays, the new stove-with-oven stays, ...). If you like warming drawers, can you recommend any particular brand? At the moment, every appliance in my kitchen is from a different Mfr, so merit over uniformity . . .

Comments (12)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Warming drawer usage is all about location. If it is located, e.g. on the bottom of a stack which has two ovens above it, it will not be used. That location is too close to the floor, have to bend too much, and poor ergonomics of moving food from the oven above it to down to the warming drawer, and then pulling it out of the warming drawer near the floor up to the counter.

    People who enjoy their warming drawers have placed it closer to the counter, and next to the oven. IMO, immediately under the counter is where it should be placed. That way, it's an easy move of food from the oven to warming drawer, and then when you want the food, it's an easy move onto the counter. I believe some people place the warming drawer one drawer down from the counter. It's a matter of preference. Just don't install it far from the oven, and don't install it too low.

    Jan Russak thanked friedajune
  • 9 years ago

    A friend of mine hosts several parties each year for 50 people in his 2000 square foot home with a mid-sized kitchen. He does 5-7 meat dishes plus about 20 appetizers/sides. He uses crock pots and chafing dishes to supplement his 48" range and stores them in the garage (no basement) when not in use. If you have a large kitchen it's a nice luxury to have but in a mid-sized kitchen I'd want the premium storage space left for things I use regularly.

  • 9 years ago

    I have never had one and when we remodeled our kitchen decided not to have one and use the second oven for warming if needed. Just didn't like the idea of such a specialized appliance taking up room in my kitchen (nor the added expense of it). I did use the second oven quite a bit for keeping things warm or warming plates, etc. I have since moved to a house with a regular range with one oven. I did miss the separate warming compartment so when I replaced the range I got one with a lower warming drawer and I do use it.

    Jan Russak thanked 3katz4me
  • 9 years ago

    I used to work behind the line and a warming drawer was an essential for what will hopefully be our last kitchen (before the microwave, blender and a cup with a straw kitchen). Luke warm food served on cold plates does not make for happy customers or guests. As above posters have noted, close to the range is critical: our setup is much like a restaurant so the warming drawer is a foot from the range, on a peninsula just below the counter top--it's a pivot from the range. We entertain a lot and it doubles as a warm serving area for buffet and seconds as well as holding area for cooked items. They also are much more sanitary if you know the 40-140F rule for holding cooked foods over 140F. Ovens are not a WD substitute. One suggestion: other than the max 30" size they have a narrow height and can't hold as much as you might think. You may want to check serving and related dish fit in the sizes you're looking at.

    Jan Russak thanked teachmkt1
  • 9 years ago

    I'd like to thank you all for the answers. Out kitchen is medium sized but the re-do is going to recover a good deal of space that was previously wasted - and I think I'm leaning toward adding a warming drawer. The oven we currently use for 'warming' bottoms out at 200F and may not be that accurate. It also seems to dry things out a bit more than I'd like.

  • 9 years ago

    It is the heat that dries things out -- that will happen with a warming drawer as well.

    I thought I had posted earlier, but don't see it. I have a warming drawer and definitely agree that the placement is a HUGE factor in how much you will use and enjoy having a warming drawer. Anytime I see one underneath double ovens at the far end of a kitchen, I wonder whether it actually gets used. However, the first thing I would give up in my kitchen is the warming drawer. My ovens heat faster, have better temperature control and accuracy (proofing functions are lower than keep warm), don't leak hot air into the kitchen or heat up adjoining cabinets, have greater capacity, control and flexibility. Also, my micro drawer has a keep warm function. I also have warming trays for serving and use my pizza stones for holding food warm at tmes (especially in transit or outdoors).

    If you are re-doing, I would put the priority on getting a really good cooktop and oven(s) or range. Those will be used far more and are far more important to both daily living and entertaining. Don't skimp to get a warming drawer. But if you have all the essentials covered and have leftover space and money, then look at whether you have the right space and enough use to put that extra into a warming drawer. It is hard to say the warming drawer is essential for 99 percent of all home kitchens. It is the only appliance in my kitchen we could have a conversation about giving up. I would part with mine before I would part with my second DW (but I still have both). Whether it is worth it for you depends on whether it adds solutions to your needs and you use it on a regular basis.

    Jan Russak thanked lascatx
  • 9 years ago

    Cat, just find a good place for a darned warming drawer.

    You actually do the warming thing, so it IS something you'd use. YOU WANT THIS!

  • 9 years ago

    If you're interested in plate warming, you need under 100 degrees Fahrenheit. If you want your food warm but not cooking more, you need something like 135°, though for food safety we say 140°. If you have a heavy, pot full of dense food, you might need 185° to keep it really warm. If you want to slow cook, you might want up to 215°.

    There are actually three potential optimal placements for a warming drawer depending on usage: If you're accumulating pancakes/crêpes/burgers, etc., right next to the cooking surface at counter height, or just under a utensil drawer is ideal. If you're keeping pots of various components of a meal, especially if you dish up in the kitchen and serve in the dining room/area, closer to the table can be more useful. If your layout doesn't lend itself to either of these, or if you want a compromise between both, the warming drawer can be on the path from the cooktop to the table, so long as it's in a convenient place, and at a convenient height. It shouldn't be more than six steps from the stove, however, if it's meant to serve the stove.

    The problem with using the oven or microwave as your warmer comes when you're entertaining or otherwise using your kitchen to capacity. The other night, I had the meat and some potatoes in the main oven, the root veg/dressing in the secondary oven (steam oven), the turkey in the sous vide circulator, the green vegetable casserole in the tertiary oven (speed oven), the soup and beef gravy on the gas and the matzah balls and turkey gravy on the induction. The only place to put things to warm as they were being dished up for serving was the warming drawer. There was no room, without a tent outside, for chafing dishes, etc. The sous vide was in a wheeled ice chest on the floor.

    So if you're not having five courses sit down for three dozen people, what about a busy normal evening? Dinner's ready, but there are still cookies for the bake sale in the ovens, you're using the microwave to defrost the meat to go in the crockpot tomorrow, and the kids are hungry but the teens are still on their way home from practice. Warming drawer can be a lifesaver.

    Re dry/moist: Many warming drawers have vents with levers to let steam out or retain it. If something is getting too dry, just make sure it's on the moist setting and put a ramekin of warm water in as well.

    I live in a mild climate where food doesn't cool down very fast so I don't use my warming drawer all the time. OTOH, when I do want to use it, I'm thrilled it's there, even when the ovens are otherwise empty. It's also far easier to use. Mine just has a dial lo-med-hi, which essentially says how much power it's putting out. An oven thermometer can show the exact temperature, but that's only necessary if one is slow cooking in the drawer. Mine is right below counter height, with the speed oven above, several steps away from the cooktop, and a straight shot to the dining room. I love it.

  • 8 years ago

    Will warming drawer be too hot for small walk in pantry that is part of kitchen?

  • 5 years ago

    In the end, we did not get a warming drawer - and haven't missed it. When we need to warm something, we set one of our two convection ovens on 200F or thereabouts and it works fine. We've never had an issue (including when "cooking the mail" during the early, panic-driven months of the pandemic). Our main consideration is that we did not want to dedicate additional space to a device that wasn't really needed. We are short people so counter/under counter space is at a premium. We ended up with: a Capital Connoisseurian stove with an electric convection oven - this is the stove which drove the entire project and I cannot tell you how much I love this thing,, a Miele Combo-Steam oven, a single KitchenAid wall oven (so a double wall oven pair, one Miele and one KitchenAid), and a countertop microwave (we're short - and we don't want to lose cabinet space). I'm very pleased with the set of things we ended up with. The Capital Connoisseurian fulfilled my every desire for a stove (36" 6 burner) - it is especially good at wok heating/cooking. The Miele combo-steam oven is a bit hard to program but superb for things that need wet heat. I had my doubts at first but I'm really glad we have it. The KitchenAid is a very good convection oven, but there is nothing staggeringly special about it. It's our 2nd KitchenAid, so we like the brand. We mostly do our "warming" in the KitchenAid and do not miss having a warming drawer in the least. Overall, I was delighted with how things turned out.

  • 5 years ago

    I have a Samsung range with a warming drawer on the bottom. I had my kitchen renovated about 2 years ago and have not yet used the drawer. I have been very busy with other house renovations since, and really have not had many people over requiring me to warm up anything. I will probably use it when I throw my first gathering with a larger group❣️