Software
Houzz Logo Print
dewdropin2cme

Floor transition help

9 years ago



I am having tile put in my kitchen and have an awkward transition that I would like to put a decorative cobble stone (picutured) transition to separate the tile and wood. What are your thoughts on this? The wood is 1/2" engineered wood and tile to be 20x20 neutral light honey brown porcelain tile. Thanks for feedback!

Comments (10)

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Why not just change to the wood at the doorways? That would be a more natural transition. Don't add a third material to the mix. That would be a disaster.

    dewdropin2cme thanked BeverlyFLADeziner
  • 9 years ago

    I was hoping to connect the two rooms off of the "mini" hallways. I have had others suggest just a straight line from cabinet peninsula to corner of cabinet encasing the fridge. What are your thoughts on that?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Agree with what Beverly is saying. The fewer the materials, the less problems.

    dewdropin2cme thanked Flo Mangan
  • 9 years ago

    I am concerned due to how hard we live in our kitchen to bring wood through there. (We can our vegetable garden yields) My thought is that tile wood be more durable. The wood we are going to use in rest of house is 1/2" engineered acacia wood. Do you think that would be durable enough in a kitchen that gets heavily used? The plywood under seats was a patch job to buy time for the remodel completion when we opened up the wall between the kitchen and the room on the left and put in the peninsula.

  • 9 years ago

    WESTWOOD WAY · More Info

    It's hard for me to get past how narrow that fridge-to-island corner is -- will cause you problems when it comes time to sell.

    But anyway, you have wood in the kitchen now -- has it been a problem? Lots of people do it these days for the unifying effect, and with proper sealing, they have no more problems than with other flooring types. But if you want tile, go for it. I'm with those who'd lean toward a clean division, even if that's a square that continues the line of your other counters and fridge wall (i.e., doesn't go all the way to doorways, but doesn't stop at arbitrary line connecting overly small walkway). The transition idea seems cool, but I think it might emphasize the very aspect of the design that you're hoping to downplay. The two don't really need any transition if the flooring is laid well.

    Contemporary Dining Room · More Info

    Jamie Herzlinger · More Info
    Another option would be to just do a tile "rug" in front of the sink and stove area(s), like this:


    Kitchen · More Info
    That would cover your worries about canning spills, while keeping the maximum continuity between the spaces throughout this floor...

    dewdropin2cme thanked acm
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Best would be all one material. 2nd best is 2 materials. There is no need for a 3rd material especially not those stones. And why don't you just put one material all the way to the corner? It is normal to have transitions in the doorways.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I agree natural transitions are in doorways and IMO all one floor would be the best option

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    No to the 3rd material. That's a disaster. Why can't you just do tile over the entire kitchen and end at the doorways?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I think with some simple care, like a tarp on the floor when canning, can help protect wood flooring. After all, you only "can" a small percentage of the year? A good engineered wood product for all the floor would be best option IMO. You might also create another place in your basement or garage for doing the canning. All you need is sink and some type of heat source? Get that whole process out of your kitchen. My neighbors in the north, use a second kitchen, typically in the basement for these type operations. Very popular.