I agree, see if you can see a bigger sample. From what you are showing here, I prefer the one on the left, but both are nice.

I have seen full slabs of both of those samples and I do not think they are too busy. What color are your cabinets?

Thanks everyone. The cabinets will be BM Cloud White. I am trying to see full slabs of both colors this afternoon.

I think they both work, but like the one on the right more. I would love to see more of its overall pattern.

catlind:

Your picture is showing something no one is ever going to see, countertops right on top of tile.

Thanks Joseph. I realize the counter isn't right on the tile floor ...but there is a lot of counter and I'm nervous about it looking too busy. I'm not sure how else to judge it. I visited Caesarstone and came back with two additional options - London Grey and ginger. The Ginger certainly goes ...but it's darker and not a lot of life. I think the London grey might work - it has a bit of light caramel and dark grey with a marble effect.

Does anyone have experience or knowledge of either the London Grey or Ginger?

I like them both but liking darker a little bit more!