Software
Houzz Logo Print
joeblfsk

banana switcheroo !

Have been growing Goldfinger bananas now for nine years and despite their scrumptious taste, have gotten tired of them taking so long to ripen. So last year I decided to switch over to Ice Cream bananas.

Right now the Goldfingers are all gone and I am anxiously awaiting my first stalk of ice Creams. Have about ten plants now in my raised bed, - the largest is up to almost 7 feet tall and every morning I am out there scanning it like an osprey for the first flag leaf. So just curious at this point,...anyone out there have any experience with these Ice Cream bananas that I am so looking forward to ?

Would appreciate any comments,..pro or con. Thanks !

Comments (10)

  • 9 years ago

    Awesome! I have a flag on my largest ice cream banana baby (guess it isn't a baby anymore). The others STILL haven't all ripened, but I'm eating them one at a time. Still have 4 hands left. They sometimes put out a fall bloom, but that wouldn't be a problem where you are. Here, fall fruit seems to get a bit of a core, but I'm finding that the ones that are hanging on and ripening now have less of a core.

    They are extremely cold hardy. Mine haven't died back at all in the past 2 years, but I"m sure they will at some point if we ever get a hard freeze that lasts more than a couple of hours. The leaves burn back easily, but it doesn't seem to hurt the fruit. Honestly, if this was a less cold-hardy banana, the fruit would be mush by now, but it's still hanging in there.

    I'm not going to comment on the taste, because this fall fruit I'm told will not be as sweet as summer fruit. Still, it's sweeter than store-bought bananas. The flesh is sort of mushy, but again, this isn't normal fruit.

    I can't wait to see how my summer bananas fare.

    jofus, ( Englewood, Fl zone 10a ) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    I had a icecream at my old house they where pretty good and a good size but i liked my Apple bananas better.

    jofus, ( Englewood, Fl zone 10a ) thanked Glenn Jones(9b)
  • 9 years ago

    Yes, I love apple bananas! My friend in Punta Gorda had a lot of different kinds of bananas, but the apples were the best. They were so fat and creamy.

    jofus, ( Englewood, Fl zone 10a ) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Wow, a thumbs up from experienced gardeners like you two has energized me to where I just ordered two Apple banana plants online from a nursery in Melbourne. Now I'll have both Ice Creams AND Apples to drool over. Hopefully in a year or so I'll be much more knowledgeable about both,..especially their different tastes, and be able to get back to you with my views on each. Thanks !

  • 9 years ago

    Ah, Joe. There are so many luscious bananas that will grow where you are. I wish sometimes I was back down there, but I do love Gainesville.

    jofus, ( Englewood, Fl zone 10a ) thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    Hi Jofus

    I had a lot of varieties of bananas in different places, a lot of them are good. The ones that I prefer for fresh eating are the lady fingers bananas, for cooking and fresh eating the Hawiian Hua Moa but is not disease resistant in my area, my very favorite is the red banana, again it did not produced too well in my area. The ones that I don't prefer are the ones that are supposed for fresh eating and have a starchy kind of center, few of them are like that.

    Right now in my garden I have the variety FHIA-23, and I like it for many reasons, taste, productivity and disease resistance. I usually have 2 branches at the same time, this time is only one but I am looking forward for the fruit...

    Silvia

    jofus, ( Englewood, Fl zone 10a ) thanked whgille
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    DG : Being an avid Florida Gator fan, I can understand you liking your life in Gainesville ! ( smile )
    I also agree with you that in zone 10a, where Englewood is ( best kept secret in Florida ),.. my options for banana plants is almost unlimited. Looking forward however, anytime a childhood pal from the grimy streets of Manhattan ( not Kansas ! ), gets back in touch with me, I will have to inform him or her, that living where I am is not exactly easy ! Every morning I will have to decide which banana slices I should put on my bowl of cereal,..freshly picked Ice Cream bananas, or freshly picked Apple bananas,...or, after June 1st,...which type of four freshly picked mango slices I should add. I tell you, sometimes living in South Florida gets a bit stressful !

  • 9 years ago

    Silvia : Thanks so much for your ideas. I have a feeling you have more than a couple of acres up there to experiment with and admire your search for the best banana for various purposes. Regret not living closer,..I might be tempted to sneak off with some of your luscious harvests. lol !!
    Down here I only have a 1/4 acre lot, so will limit my bananas to two types. Can't wait to see how they turn out.
    In the past I have spent many years growing Nam Wa,..Dwarf Red,...& of course Goldfingers ! Hope I am now at the end of my time-consuming quest,...reminds me of my pal Don Quixote ! ( smile )

  • 9 years ago

    Jofus,I hope you like you apple banana. They are my favorite. There short bananas but fat great for fresh eating and cooking.

    jofus, ( Englewood, Fl zone 10a ) thanked Glenn Jones(9b)
0
Sponsored