Software
Houzz Logo Print
jill_coopersmith

Sheet Vinyl vs LVT

9 years ago

I am shopping for new flooring for my kitchen, 2 bathrooms, laundry room, and back hallway. Our home is a one-story townhome on a concrete slab, which I know needs to be considered in choosing flooring and installation method.

Two stores I went to convinced me that LVT was the way to go, and then yesterday I went to another store and the owner told me that sheet vinyl would be best for concrete. She insisted that nobody would ever know the difference between sheet vinyl, LVT, or Ceramic.

Here is where I am challenged:

1. So far I have not been able to find an LVT pattern that I like or that coordinates with my Cambria Bellingham countertops. They are all too busy, too yellow, too pink, too... something... I do want a grouted stone/tile look, not wood.

2. I am sensitive to repeating patterns and I worry about that with LVT because the samples are so small as to hide that. How can I really assess if I like a floor if I cannot see enough of it to get a sense of how it will look when installed?

3. While it may be entirely incorrect, the notion of sheet vinyl feels "cheap" and "low budget." I am installing luxury finishes in my kitchen - Custom cabinets, quartz counters, marble backsplash, ... struggling with how sheet vinyl fits into that picture.

All of this is making me wonder if I should just go with ceramic tile.


Thoughts?

Comments (8)

  • 9 years ago

    Have you looked at stores that offer Armstrong sheet vinyl. I am interested in their duality line and one pattern I loved was called Havana. It comes in different colors.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Ceramic tile is not a great option on slab. Porcelain tile would be better. Sheet product can work if you need the "sheet" side of things (lots of water on the floor, leaky pets/humans, etc). A porcelain tile is always a higher end floor than sheet or LVT vinyl.

    If you feel your home deserves the higher-end finish (such as porcelain) then go ahead and get porcelain. The vinyl products are great...so long as you accept repeat patterns in a stone/tile look.

    Jill Coopersmith thanked Cancork Floor Inc.
  • 9 years ago

    I dislike pattern repeats, but most of my customers either don't see them or they accept it.

    Manufacturers are getting better at producing product that hides repeats.

    Homogenous sheet vinyl or genuine linoleum is not produced using a rotogravure process, so there are no pattern repeats.

    Even some ceramic and porcelain tole can have unsightly pattern repeats. Only real way to preview a product is to visit a full line retailer showroom or view the product you're considering in situ.




    Jill Coopersmith thanked glennsfc
  • 9 years ago

    Cancork, What is different about porcelain (compared to ceramic) that makes it okay on slab? I always categorize porcelain and ceramic as one in the same, but it helps to know there is a reason to differentiate. I think most of the tiles I have looked at are in fact porcelain.

    Can you tell me if porcelain costs more to install than grouted LVT?

  • 9 years ago

    Glennsfc, Can you tell me what "homogenous sheet vinyl" is and how it is different from other sheet vinyl or linoleum? I did not realize that sheet product was immune from repeats but I did notice that the samples are always larger and that I didn't notice them as much. I actually found some sheet product that I thought looked nicer than LVT, but as I said, I just can't get past the "cheap" aspect and I worry it will look cheap (and feel cheap) once installed.

  • 9 years ago

    Homogenous sheet vinyls have no pattern. They are produced by laying down a calendared field of colored vinyl particles, which are then are fused to create a solid product. Or, the product is 'extruded' from particles. There is no printing produced from a photograph, hence no pattern. You will usually find these resilient products in tiles or sheets mostly in commercial settings. Genuine linoleum is produced in a similar way, although with natural raw materials and dyes.

    Jill Coopersmith thanked glennsfc
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for the insights! It is very helpful. I am now back to leaning towards grouted LVT. I just looked at Armstrong Alterna and these tiles look so genuine I was impressed. I also find their "patterns" to be toned down a bit - fewer swirls, pits, and obvious markings that could be spotted as duplication from one tile to the next.

    The challenge now is choosing the right color. I am going with Cambria Bellingham quartz, which is taupe with black, gray, and white. So many of the stone looks are brown or cream, which I don't want. I'll need to get some samples to see all the surfaces together in my home lighting.