Software
Houzz Logo Print
koki1_gw

M1234567890`1-=

9 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

M

Comments (18)

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    It is a double edged sword, aesthetically pleasing house design verses a perfectly performing roof. Always keep the roof in mind throughout the design process of a house. It helps when the homeowner realizes the ramification of certain roof features.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    So what about butterfly roofs beloved by multi-award-winning architects?

    architect: Frank Harmon

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I think he is writing more from an efficiency perspective; I think it's interesting that a lot of his "bad" roof ideas are also "bad" design ideas. It looks like the "valley" on that butterfly roof is raked which would help. But I bet it collects a lot of leaves.

    He has a ton of informative building articles here: http://www.greenbuildingadvisor.com/search/node/Martin%20holladay

  • 9 years ago

    Nice if you have a way to collect the water, but around here they tend to get airborne and take the house with them.

  • 9 years ago

    That house is local to me. Frank is a really good architect. That lot is really challenging, and it's a cool house, but can't imagine the leaf issue. One of our original designs had a roof like that. Hubby said "why in the world would you want to direct water toward the MIDDLE OF YOUR HOUSE?" and therefore, was nixed. I wanted a flat roof - also nixed. (however, from the front and the sides, we LOOK Like wet have a flat roof - so he appeased me)

    It's funny when you see the roof plans of some of these neo-eclectic and then contrast it with ours... LOL

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I was just investigating butterfly roofs because I went to an open house with sort of one (not obvious, it's over the carport) and was wondering what a pain in the #$@ it could be in a snowy climate. Checked out when I noticed all the drywall repairs on the interior and started reading about installing radiant heating strips at the seam. Some things do not go well with ice and snow. Love the look of them, though!

    Two or three winters ago we had an extremely harsh, snowy and icy winter with a lot of freeze thaw cycles. So many low slope roofs failed, you'd be dodging buckets of water at the pharmacy and watching the roofers visit multiple homes on the block. The ice dams were unbelievable.

    Around here a lot of the modern architects are now doing steep gable roofs and it fits well in the local vernacular (they're still doing flattish and shed roofs too of course).

  • 9 years ago

    Interesting, robo. But, uhoh, looks like those steep gabled homes do violate part of rule 4: In all climates, make overhangs generous. (Roof overhangs help shade south-facing windows in summer, and help keep siding dry on all orientations. Remember: every exterior door needs to be protected by a roof overhang or its own roof.)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The only rule I question is eliminating gutters. Even in areas of moderate rainfall, say 800 mm (31.5 ins.) per year, that's a load of concentrated water just a few feet from the foundation wall. And unless it's landscaped with rock or paved, your yard becomes a river of mud.

  • 9 years ago

    Modified butterfly here. The leaves are a pain. Also, local ordinances require rainwater be collected and pumped back from the bluff to reduce the risk of landslides.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We don't really need the overhangs for sun protection (stupid cloudy cold Nova Scotia climate) but rain protection over the front door is nice--actually rain comes in sideways a lot here more so than down so the best front door protection is alcoves.

  • 9 years ago

    Seems to me designing a house for reliability is more dependent on location than 'rules'.

    Using those rules in New Mexico/Arizona would not apply.

    And, trying to build an apartment building in a city would be nigh on impossible.

    There are some good points like limiting roof penetrations, attic venting(ridge vents are non mechanical and work on natural air movement properties), flashing, and ice dams.

    As he stated several times, some of his 'rules' are simply opinions. And many work only in certain locations.

  • 9 years ago

    They're still trying butterfly here. This is a suburb close by. IMO...would not go for it.

  • 9 years ago

    A brave choice in a climate where daily deluges up to 104mm (4 ins.) occur from time to time.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Martin's list is written from a roofer's perspective; rules of thumb to eliminate leaks and sheathing decay. Certainly we can achieve those objectives without every home having to have a simple gable roof.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Well, he is a Yank from New England, where the saltbox home was for nearly two centuries the height of architectural adventurism. I'm a hip roof guy myself!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Mr. Worthy is a Hipster! So was Mr. Wright!

  • 9 years ago

    Don't forget the water collecting Flat Roofers(illegal in some states!).