Software
Houzz Logo Print
ral1121

Organic nitrogen fertilizer?

9 years ago

I live in San Antonio and have a Bermuda lawn in a neighborhood. I am looking for a nitrogen only organic fertilizer to use once a month. My wife does not want me using the lesco 39-0-0 products t because she says it is harmful to the environment. I do not think it is that big of a deal but am trying to make her happy. Anyone have any suggestions? Thanks for any help.

Comments (35)

  • 9 years ago

    There's no control over the NPK of organic materials. The absolute highest N factor comes from animal materials like blood meal and fish meal. These still have P and K but not as much as the grain type fertilizers have. The negative to these is that they are extremely potent and can burn the grass if you spill any or get the dosage wrong. The application rate for these high N animal products is more like 5 pounds per 1,000 square feet. The easiest way to control that is to thoroughly mix the product into a carrier like another fertilizer. If you can find a feather meal based fertilizer, which is also very high in N but glacially slow to act, you could mix 5 pounds of blood meal with 15 pounds of feather meal and apply the mix at 15 pounds per 1,000. After you use a feather based product a few times the soil microbes should adjust so they can handle the feather meal much more quickly.

    I realize the bermuda bible suggests a nitrogen only fertilizer; however, there are some bermuda people who have been very satisfied using alfalfa pellets alone on a monthly basis. Many of the feed stores in San Antonio are hep to the use of alfalfa pellets on lawns and carry exactly what you want. They will sell you one without all the vitamins and minerals required by rabbits and chinchillas. The Ful-o-Pep store on the corner of WW White and Rigsby, for example, knows what you want.

  • 9 years ago

    dchall,

    So the 15 lb mix per 1000, that is what I should apply every month during the summer growing season? Also where can I get it around San Antonio? I need enough for about 2500 square feet of lawn. Thanks for your response.

  • 9 years ago

    One more question, if I do the alfalfa pellets, how many pounds per 1000 do I use and do I fertilizer once a month as well?

  • 9 years ago

    Alfalfa works great, fish fertilizer or kelp meal works great too

  • 9 years ago

    @reeljake

    Could you please check out this thread as well and provide some thoughts to this gentleman on how to move forward :

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/4585543/lawn-turned-brown-overnight?n=11

  • 9 years ago

    Reread the second paragraph of my first reply. Your answers are in there.

  • 9 years ago

    Here is a thread that addresses the rate for alfalfa:

    Application rate question

    The point of Dchall's second paragraph is that alfalfa could be used INSTEAD of the blood and feather mix he talked about in the first paragraph (and for that matter instead of synthetic fertilizer). Bermuda is usually fed monthly during its growing season. There are other grains that can be used: soybeans, corn, cottonseed. Why don't you check at your nearby feed stores and see what they have? Milorganite is another product you might consider.

  • 9 years ago

    Milorganite is 40% synthetic N. Bad.

  • 9 years ago

    Milorganite has 40% water soluble nitrogen, 60% water insoluble nitrogen. But it's all from biosolids. If you think of organic fertilizer as derived from living materials, synthetic fertilizer as derived from nonliving materials, Milorganite is organic. Here are some FAQs from the Milorganite website.

  • 9 years ago

    Where did you get the information that the water soluble portion is derived from biosolids ? The product page only lists the slow release part as derived from biosolids.

  • 9 years ago

    I don't see anything on there about processing the biosolids into a water soluble form of nitrogen. Nor would it make sense for them to invest in such an expensive process, since they can probably buy urea for $0.10 a pound in bulk. My guess is the biosolids are low on N, they didn't want to sell it as 3-4-0 since one bag would only cover 1,000 sq ft, so they enriched it with urea to bring it up to 5-4-0.

  • 9 years ago

    Perhaps part of the nitrogen in the biosolids and microbes is naturally water soluble. Here is a composition list for the 6-2-0 Milorganite: safety data sheet

    The bulk is activated sewage sludge (86.8-90.8%), followed by water (4-8%), followed by iron chloride (1-3%), iron sulfate (1-3%), calcium carbonate (1.2%). No urea listed.

  • 9 years ago

    I did some more research, as I was curious, I always just assumed it was synthetic. There's a thread on the other forum from 2011 when the change to 2% WSN was made and everyone was up in arms, someone there spoke to the Milorganite people they said it's urea. So there we go.

  • 9 years ago

    You are aware that urea is in urine? I dare say there is some urine in the sewage sludge. It would just be naturally occurring urea that's part of the sewage rather than the urea produced synthetically.

  • 9 years ago

    That's a good try, but the chances of urea making it through the process intact are slim to none. The nitrifying bacteria get to work on that right away.

    I think I may have been wrong about the biosludge being only 3% N. It's probably around 5-6, and they cut it with filler (there's calcium carbonate in the MSDS) down to 3 then add urea back in to raise to 5. That way they double it. There's a Pro version with 5% WIN and only 1% WSN.

  • 9 years ago

    If they were adding urea, they would have to declare that on the MSDS.

  • 9 years ago

    That's not necessarily true, there's a threshold below which they don't have to declare it. In this case, urea would only be about 4% of the product by weight, and probably falls below that threshold.

  • 9 years ago

    4% is a lot and would surely need to be declared. Is there any documentation that specifies that urea (non-biosolid derived) is added? Sounds like your statement is based on hearsay and nothing else.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Is there any documentation that specifies that urea (non-biosolid derived) is added

    No, like I said it's on on the MSDS. What we do know is that there's 2% water soluble nitrogen. Could be urea, ammonium sulfate, ammonium nitrate, calcium nitrate etc. Regardless, it's in a salt form. Based on the "hearsay" - folks that claim to have called or emailed and asked directly - it appears to be urea, and I find the claim credible because it would the the cheapest way to "enrich" the formulation. If you think it's something else, feel free to share your opinion.

    Now you added the caveat "non-biosolid derived", and I'm not sure why. First things' first, CO(NH2)2 is CO(NH2)2 , regardless of what it was derived from. Having said that, I'm not aware of anyone that would be silly enough to try to derive urea on a mass scale from biosolids, it wouldn't be very cost effective. Not to mention, a pound of organic N is sold for 20x more than a pound of water soluble N. Are you saying it's organic or that it wouldn't need to be listed on the SDS if it was biosolid derived? Synthetic urea is derived from natural gas which is derived from plant and animal remains, that doesn't make it organic. And if 4% is a lot, then it would need to be declared regardless of what it's derived from.

    Tell you what, I will email the Milorganite people and ask what the WSN is so we can put this puppy to bed.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    There is a big difference adding urea to the mix and not declaring it on the MSDS, or having it in the biosolid and declaring it. One is in compliance and one isn't. Your "research" to date basically amounts to "I read it on the internet so it must be true".

  • 9 years ago

    Maybe you can post the documentation that you base your MSDS compliance claim on.

  • 9 years ago

    BeckyinRichmond posted a link to the MSDS. There is no urea listed for Milorganite. You claim it is added. The burden of proof is on you.

  • 9 years ago

    Correct, and I have just emailed Milorganite to obtain the info directly from them.

    I am asking you to provide proof of your claim on MSDS compliance:

    There is a big difference adding urea to the mix and not declaring it on the MSDS, or having it in the biosolid and declaring it. One is in compliance and one isn't.

    You are claiming that "having it in the biosolid" is different than "adding it to the mix" from a compliance standpoint. So given 4% urea, MSDS compliance differs based on the source of that 4%. Post the document that you're basing that claim on.



  • 9 years ago

    I am not saying the N is from urea at all. I am saying the N is in the biosolid. You claim it is urea added from an exogenous source. "some guy off an internet forum" is not a reliable source of info. The MSDS is.

  • 9 years ago

    I am saying the N is in the biosolid.

    In what water soluble form?

  • 9 years ago

    Ammonium

  • 9 years ago

    Some good info about biosolids in general--not specific to Milorganite, Oceangro, etc.

    https://catalog.extension.oregonstate.edu/sites/catalog/files/project/pdf/pnw508_0.pdf


    "Biosolids contain organic and ammonium-N;

    nitrate-N is absent in most biosolids.

    Ammonium-N is available to plants immediately

    after application. Organic N provides slow-release

    N "

  • 9 years ago

    I looked over that 2011 thread and the takeaway from it was that Milorganite changed the labels because they were getting less industrial waste and more household waste than they had before. The WIN and WSN varies according to whatever happens to be coming down the pipes to them. By law they have to state the minimum N on the bags. There very well could be more total N in a bag than stated on the label. There could be more WIN or WSN than stated. So I don't think we can assume 40% WSN and 60% WIN just because a bag states 6% N with 3.5% WIN and 2.5% WSN. Elsewhere on the product page, Milorganite describes its WIN as 85%. Maybe that's 85% in an average batch rather than a minimum WIN one? The idea that they would mix in synthetic urea to raise its N numbers is a bit crazy. They have enough work as is to make their product and they are selling it to people who want that product, not a particular NPK value.

    Apologies to ral1211 who just wanted to know some organic fertilizer sources and application rates.

  • 9 years ago

    We're fixing to find out.

  • 9 years ago

    That was an exhausting read, but at least it's settled.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    j4c11, thanks for posting that. Very interesting read. I love Milorganite and after reading that, I love it even more.

  • 9 years ago

    This whole discussion about whether Milorganite is truly organic was absurd. I thought I was just noting a misunderstanding of WSN as a synonym for synthetic, when all it meant was water soluble nitrogen. Instead I was roped into researching Milorganite. Milorganite's explanation and video about how it is made did not suffice. The label did not suffice. I don't know for sure but I suspect in the urea in urine stays water soluble even after the microbes digest it and break it down. I put down 25 lb/k of cracked corn this week. I half expect j4c11 to now say that's not a truly organic feeding as the corn probably was raised with synthetic fertilizer. So I make no claim that my cracked corn is an organic feeding.

  • 9 years ago

    I half expect j4c11 to now say that's not a truly organic feeding as the corn probably was raised with synthetic fertilizer.

    Yes but the urea that it was fertilized with was made with natural gas, which comes from decomposing organic matter from a billion years ago. So it's organic, you just have to go far enough back the chain :-)

    There's rules about what can be labelled "organic", and we had a good conversation on this last year, it's worth a read.

    http://forums2.gardenweb.com/discussions/3824084/what-is-this-is-it-organic