Software
Houzz Logo Print
jacqueline9ca

Need ID help on old HT

9 years ago

This rose is growing in a large pot at my niece's house. It is in a pot because last summer when she & her husband purchased the house I found one gorgeous bloom on the bush. Unfortunately, the bush was languishing in full shade, and was being strangled by ivy, overtaken by Dr. Huey suckers, and had blackspot, rust, etc. Only 3 very old canes remained of the original rose. So, I got my DH to dig them up, and to my delight all of the canes had tiny roots at the bottom of them. I had to put them all in one large pot (in the sun, on the patio), and tie string around the top of all three of them to keep them from falling over. Fast forward 9 months, and they have rooted, sprouted new canes, & bloomed, and are sending out long new canes. I am trying to convince my niece & nephew that the rose needs to be planted in the ground - they have a big lot. It might even be a climber - I have to get over there and work on it and see.

Here are a bud, a half open bloom and leaves & thorns, and a fully open bloom. Any idea who this might be? It looks and grows like a HT, but it was obviously planted at least 15-20 years ago, if not longer. I love the colors.

Jackie



Comments (23)

  • 9 years ago
  • 9 years ago

    It also looks to me like a Pernetiana. You might try trolling through the Pernetiana section on HMF. It is not 'Autumn', and I think it has a few more petals than any of the 'Talismans', but eliminating those two popular roses leaves many other possibilities.

  • 9 years ago

    Compassion?

  • 9 years ago

    What a stunner! whatever it is, am pretty sure I've never seen it before. A memorable rose..

  • 9 years ago

    On second thought, perhaps 'Talisman' should be considered.

    http://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=21.17441

    The color on your rose looks to be identical, so much as one can tell in photos. I seem to recall 'Talisman' having fewer petals, but I only grew it for about two years, and I have not seen it in eight years. I had 'Talisman' and 'Yellow Talisman'; I seem to recall YT having that curious, but not unattractive, four pointed shape which appears in your photo.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks so much. While I am looking up those names, here are two more pics - one of the red new growth, and one of a bloom which is open but not fully blown:


    Jackie

  • 9 years ago

  • 9 years ago

    Your rose looks Pernetiana to my eye also, not that I can say which one. My grandfather grew Talisman in TX, and the blooms were very similar although I think the petal count varied with temperature. It was VERY fragrant. I believe Pedro Dot created some Penetianas which were popular into the mid century and grew well in warm places like California. A lovely rose and great vintage rescue! Carol

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for all of the suggestions! Right now I have to go work in the garden (my 50+ yr old Duet, which is in a large pot, has just decided to die - I ran out and took 3 cuttings last night so I can try to root them), but I will definitely look all of them up.

    Jackie


  • 9 years ago

    I agree on Pernetiana -- and I'd guess it could be Talisman -- and I think it's drop dead gorgeous. :-)


  • 9 years ago

    I'll nominate an outlier here. Climbing Tiffany. I know, HelpMeFind shows a pure-ish pink specimen, but I do discern a touch of peach too. The one I grow looks a lot like your niece's, a tad peachier in hot weather. I call the rose Climbing Tiffany because that's what the former house owner's called it when we moved in. I've always been curious as to its true identity, though calling it Tiffany seems close enough.

  • 9 years ago

    Jackie, so sorry to hear about Duet. Best of luck with the cuttings! Carol

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I think this rose has more Tea in it than does 'Talisman', frankly. And it most definitely isn't 'Tiffany', which doesn't display folded or creased petals as shown in photo #2 above. I'm not convinced any of the tentative ID's are correct, but its certainly got the Pernetiana vibe.

  • 9 years ago

    Probably pernetiana. Definitely not Talisman- that has a yellow reverse, and this appears to have the same color range on both surfaces in the photos you've posted. If it's one we have at the Heritage, I'll probably see it Saturday.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks, everyone. Jill - if you could look at the pernetianas you have at the Heritage, that would be great.

    I did not show that part in the photos, but this rose definitely gets blackspot - isn't that what most pernetianas get? Sad to be a negative clue, however...

    Jackie

  • 9 years ago

    OK - I finally got a moment to look up some of the names (it started raining just 2 minutes after I got 3 cuttings of my Duet into their bags of potting soil and into my "rose cutting rooting miniature greenhouse", which is an upside down small fish tank on my glassed-in back porch). So far I have looked up 6, and the one which is currently my favorite is a tea - Clementine Carbonieri, which was suggested by someone on the "rose" forum. Two pictures of the blown bloom, and the half open bloom on HMF are identical to those of my niece's rose. Most of the pictures of CC show WAY more petals, however, although these two do not. Anybody know anything about CC, or could you look at it? Would it have more petals or less petals depending on the weather?

    Jackie

  • 9 years ago

    I don't believe CC is as thorny as your rose. Carol

  • 9 years ago

    Whatever it is, it's gorgeous. If it's a pernetiana, it knows disease.

  • 9 years ago

    Teas are more likely to get mildew than blackspot. And I agree with Carol that the rose is too thorny to be a tea.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I would like to toss in 'Gruss an Coburg' (HMF page) for consideration as a candidate. It is a Pernetiana that is quite thorny and has moderately glossy leaves (not the super-shiny ones that some, like 'Etoile de Feu', have). It also has new growth that is very red (see this photo on HMF).

    Here are some photos, the first two being of a bouquet I just picked:

    Bush last year around mid-April:

  • 9 years ago

    My first thought was Lafter, but I stink at IDing and not sure the new growth and thorns are right for that one. It is beautiful...what a find! I hope you are able to get a positive ID on it.

    http://www.helpmefind.com/rose/l.php?l=21.144032