Software
Houzz Logo Print
merlena87

Does reverting to Dr. Huey ever cease being a problem

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Do Dr. Huey grafted roses ever get past the point of being in danger of suckering and turning into Dr. Huey? I'm pretty sure I saw some Dr. Huey coming from the base of one of my Sunsprite bushes, which has been a vigorous grower, it's in its fifth season and I was hoping after they had been around that long that wouldn't be an issue. Out of probably forty established Dr. Huey roses that's about the 4th one that's happened to. I thought after that length of time that wouldn't even be an issue. The other three happened during the second season.

I think I must be doing something wrong, I know some have stated that has never happened to them.

Comments (8)

  • 9 years ago

    I still buy some on Dr. Huey, mostly from local nurseries. But look into getting roses on own root or multiflora. Palantine roses are on mf and they are great quality. I haven't had any suckers and the rootstock doesn't make that huge graft like Dr. Huey does. I also have some roses on fortuniana, but that is probably too tender for your zone.

    I still get some suckers, in fact my Heritage I thought had a nice new cane, but it turned out to be Dr. Huey. And I've had that rose for years. I have to say that the Austins are famous for it. I got rid of Mary Rose for that reason. And I STILL have Dr. Huey in that bed, I can't get rid of it. I think part of my problem was that I did not bury the graft deep enough and that caused a lot of the suckers.

    Sara-Ann Z6B OK thanked Buford_NE_GA_7A
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I was under the impression that Dr. Huey growth takes over only when the growth from the graft (and above it) got frozen and died--so that the roots from below the graft started growing in compensation.

    I suppose that if the above the graft growth got weakened enough (too little water, or too much sun or disease, perhaps), then the Dr. Huey roots might also start growing.

    In which case, moral of story is baby those roses--keep them well-watered and well-fed and healthy.

    Kate

    ETA: To answer your OP question directly, age has nothing to do with whether or not Dr. Huey takes over, as far as I know. The one case I remember of the Dr. showing up in the spring bloom, it was my big healthy Mortimer Sackler that had been thriving in the spot for 4-5 years! Somehow it got damaged from the cold, limped along half-heartedly blooming for another season, but did not survive the next winter. But Dr. Huey did.

  • 9 years ago

    Sara-Ann, do you bury the graft? I live in zone 4 and ALWAYS bury the graft at least 4 inches under the dirt line. I have never had Dr. Huey come up or have it sprout from the graft. Ever. (30 plus years growing roses). Besides that, when you bury the graft, I think it makes basal canes form more readily under the dirt. You know, cozy, dark, moist... I think I'll make a new cane! :)

    Rebecca

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I see sprouting here without high planting and a killer winter having been involved. Christopher Lloyd wrote about buying grafted roses to get particular cultivars, rooting replacements from cuttings and then discarding the original purchases.

  • 9 years ago

    I cannot answer your exact question. But I will add that my personal rule is that I never again buy grafted roses. Own root or no root.

  • 9 years ago

    This is the reason why I buy own root, if the plant dies, I prefer a dead plant instead of a Dr Huey. If I do buy bare-root, I always try to start a few new plants from cuttings.

  • 9 years ago

    It is because my roses reverted back to rootstock after several years, I went to own root roses. I don't have to worry about replanting my yard again.