Software
Houzz Logo Print
roarahgw

Do you track your kids?

9 years ago


My eldest is only fourth grade and will not have a smart phone until she can pay for it herself, so we are still years away from this but I was amazed at how many of my peers are tracking their child's every move. I am a Luddite and feel I am often very anti today's latest and greatest new technology but I want to do research now to make an informed decision when the time comes as to if or if not I agree with tracking apps.

Would you please share your opinions on this type of parenting with tracking our child's every move. Are you using it or not and why or why not. I am leaning against it now but really am undecided about in the future.

tIA

Comments (54)

  • 9 years ago

    Dh, dd (teenager), and I all have iPhones, so we can see each other's current location. It is more for trying to figure out when someone is on the way home. We let her track us, so she likes it....she uses it to see how close we are to picking her up. If anyone tells her it is creepy, she just shows them she is also allowed to see her parents' current location. :)

    roarah thanked TNflowerlover Zone 7a
  • 9 years ago

    Three of our four kids have phones; two in h.s, one in 8th grade. My 6th grader does not have a phone and regularly points that out to me! ;)

    I do have some sort of family feature as part of my icloud/itunes account b/c we all share the same music/apps. My kids are all required by their school to have iPads so this enabled us to share the same paid-for, school-required apps and textbooks. As part of this feature, it also shows the location for all of the Apple devices we own. This has been useful when, on a couple of occasions, one of my kids left an iPad at school and we were able to verify that it was at school and that no one had taken it.

    There is only one reason I have used the feature to find one of my kids rather than to locate a device. When d17 got her license, she also started working. Her hours change often, so on a couple of occasions I did not know where she was and she wasn't answering her phone. I was able to look at the app and see that she was at work. I also used it once when she was out late at night and had to drive home from an unfamiliar area. Since she was a new driver, it gave me piece of mind to follow her and see that she made her way out of the area safely by tracking her progress. But I would never routinely use it.

    roarah thanked 4kids4us
  • 9 years ago

    My thirteen year old has a cell. He's had one since he started middle school. It's a hand me down as dh has been getting new iPhones through his work every 18 months or so for several years now. He is allowed to ride his bike places and he gets dropped off at practices and so on. So we decided he should have a phone because there are no pay phones anywhere anymore and we didn't want him stranded some place due to a bike breakdown or miscommunication about practice time. I see it as a way to give him more independence while still having a safety net.


    We can track his phone to find it in case he loses it. We have not ever used it to track him. He has been told that we reserve the right to check his texts,smear him history, photos, etc at any time.

    roarah thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Any parents of Waldorf students? I am keeping it as a very viable option in my back pocket if/ when my kids may try the "but everyone else has it" whining. Many Silicon Valley execs kids are often enrolled in no/ low tech schools. Here was a nice article comparing a very high tech private school with a nearby Waldorf no tech one.

    https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/high-tech-vs-no-tech-dc-area-schools-take-opposite-approaches-to-education/2012/05/12/gIQAv6YFLU_story.html?utm_term=.b350a0f4d60e#comments

    Neither comes out above the other and let's face it with tuition costs in the 20k range, students from either fortunate group have all the makings to be successful students with or without technology. I just like the idea of not having peer pressure dictate when parents decide it is appropriate for a child to have a phone.

  • 9 years ago

    Roarah, I've seen reference several times to tech execs not allowing their kids to have electronics and find it a bit ironic that at the same time, their companies push "educational tools" for kids. Personally, I have not found iPad use to have much merit for my middle schoolers AT ALL. Sure, there are some neat things they have been able to do with them, but the negatives outweigh the positives. Their use in school begins in 6th grade, just about the same time all the social media comes in to play and it has just been a mess to deal with. This is the third year they have been in use and I feel my kids' school rushed into it without necessary research and they rely on them way too much in the classroom. The high school my younger son will be attending next year has a much better iPad program in place from what I can tell so far.


    And I totally agree on the peer pressure thing dictating when parents decide on a phone. My oldest really was one of the last kids in her private school to get one and she was going into 8th grade. Now I'm seeing kids much much younger getting iPhones, like 2nd and 3rd grade! My 8th grader initially did not have an iPhone but by the end of 8th grade, it became a HUGE social problem for her. Because she did not have one, she was being excluded from lots of group texts, etc. Not intentionally, but because of the way the phones work - like she could receive the initial text, but then not see any of the responses. Making plans became a problem. She complained about it all the time but I didn't believe her until one time we went on a social outing with several girls. Another mom was driving and I sat in the middle row. It was then that I truly observed how she was being excluded as the girls were sharing things (like videos, etc) back and forth between their phones and my dd could not join in b/c she did not have a smartphone. She could only make calls and text. She was already having some trouble with her social group and this just exacerbated it. it was painful for me to witness and a sad example (out of many) of how technology can have a downside in the social arena with kids.


  • 9 years ago

    I think many parents do not discuss cell phones with other parents. My friends' kids keep saying " I am the only one with out one" in my DD 's class of 9 and 10 year olds. Turns out at a school gathering a mom asked me when I got My daughter a phone to which I answered I had not and was not helping her to buy one anytime soon. Another mom in the room said oh I am glad I am not the only parent not buying a phone til after my kid is 12 and than TEN! other parents said they thought they were the only ones! Out of a class of 18 only three actually had phones but many kids were guilting their parents into thinking they were the only ones...

    just like I hope my children and I will not give into all "the cool kids are smoking" will I, nor they, hopefully not give in to all the cool kids are always using their phones. Let's face it phones and devices are made to brain hack and be just as, if not more, addictive as slot machines, alcohol and heroine.....this is why people in the know hold off letting their own kids use these very addictive and most likely, to soon to see all the studies results yet, dangerous devices.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    my goodness i do not want to follow my kids to middleschool let alone college. i have anxiety issues as is and part of my therapy is trying to allow myself to trust in myself, trust in my family and trust in the universe and try to let go of my need to feel control over yhe unknown i think trackers feed into this type of anxiety so i would become obsessive with it most likely. not sure if it would serve to calm my mind or activate my fears.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't know if I can track my kids' locations or not using our iPhones, but I would not consider it creepy to do so. The adult kids are obviously free to go where they want and if I was tracking them it would only be if they failed to show up somewhere as planned and I wanted to make sure they weren't dead. They would not mind at all. They watch Dateline!

    The teen has a phone but she has never been somewhere she's not supposed to be, so again, same as above.

    The middle schooler has no phone. He does not have a phone because I am a therapist who must endure daily hours of hearing from tweens and teens about the wrongs done to them on other people's phones or the trouble they have gotten into on their own phones. Some kids are mature enough to avoid all the traps, but I suspect my middle schooler is not one of them, yet.

    If he did have a phone, I'd have no problem with tracking him if I wanted to know where he was. There are three parks/basketball courts/tennis courts and a half dozen friends within bike distance of our house and if he was out playing and I wanted him for some reason, I'd have no problem with tracking his phone--he's a middle schooler, he's not supposed to have freedom. I would not consider that helicopter parenting or spying, I'd just consider it convenient.

  • 9 years ago

    I think many parents are open with their kids about using a tracker in my friendship circle so less spying and more trying to control safety or maybe like you say for convenance not for controlling their actions per say.

    Maggie the reason I do not want my tweens to have phones has alot to do with the drama and hurt they so often lead to, not to mention I want my tweens to still play and converse with others for a while longer. Is their equal peer pressure for boys to have phones in middle school like it seems to be for the girls? My neighbor's 13 year old son does not have a phone and is not bothered at all by that but all the girls walking home from his school are texting away with their heads looking down as they walk home " together" :(

  • 9 years ago

    Roarah, among the kids I work with, I would say that boys and girls feel the phone pressure about equally, though perhaps for different reasons. I think boys are more likely to want one just so they can say they have it, or to access funny memes and show them to each other or to play games on. Whereas girls may be more likely to use it for non-stop texting and regrettable selfies. That being said, I know many boys who do a lot of texting and engaging in drama via the phone, especially in middle school.

    Part of the downside to my job is that I am almost always working with very troubled kids, so I probably don't have the most balanced perspective about what "regular" kids are thinking and doing. But DS has told me things he has seen on other kids' phones on the bus or at school lunch that leads me to believe it's not just my patients who are in over their heads.



    roarah thanked maggiepatty
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I tend to believe it is not just your patients either....they are designed to entice certain responses and they are addictive and that alone carries danger for all who are not ready for it. I am hoping my kids never show an interest but I know the day will come sooner than later.

  • 9 years ago

    I hadn't thought about tracking! I see how it would be nice to know if a kid or parent is on their way already, or to find a missing phone (does it work with low battery? Because currently I just call the missing phone.).

    I think my kid will get a phone (limited data!) when she goes to middle school. We don't have pay phones everywhere like we once did and I'd like the kid to be able to call her parents or 911 if needed.

    Tracking? Nah. Not unless she turns out to be a bad kid.

    roarah thanked Fori
  • 9 years ago

    The only one I kinda track is my college graduate. It started when he went to Europe one summer with my credit and debit cards (his name, my accounts). We turned on text alerts every time the cards were used to watch for fraud, but we also were reassured to know when he bought breakfast at the airport: he'll make his flight! or that he'd gotten to the little hotel before they closed the desk for the night. We still have it on, and since he lives in the city and often works late nights, I'm reassured to see that he took Uber or Lyft home safely.

    roarah thanked bpath
  • 9 years ago

    I will preface at this time all my questions for my own situation are purely hypothetical and to be honest if I have a child I suspect is up to no good all bets on how I behave are off...and if I see my child being left out for not buying her a phone I might give in as well.

    Bpathome , does your son know you are tracking him? If so I see no harm I guess other than who else sees his activities. These apps are not for the greater good they are to track us and than sell us a package of goods appropriate to our patterns...

  • 9 years ago

    He knows, but it's not like we are tracking constantly and commenting on how often he goes to the grocery store or the coffee shop, so I think most of the time he doesn't think about it. Neither do we, to be honest. And we don't pay close attention to it. We can't track where he is at any given moment, we would never do that. We really are just on the lookout for fraud on the bank cards. And now that he's been working and living on his own and will get his own credit card, all that will stop anyway.

  • 9 years ago

    It wasn't an option when my SSs were teens but I would have used it. They weren't evil but they weren't angelic either...I would like to think I would have downplayed my tracking and not checking every second of the day. Not my style in other aspects of my life

    roarah thanked bossyvossy
  • 9 years ago

    Funny story about this. On the show "The Middle" the kids were tracking their parents and the parents were tracking the kids. Neither group knew this until one night the cell service had issues and both groups were upset because it appeared they each had been in an accident. The location service froze in a location they had driven by. It pointed out the feelings of both parties and was enlightening and entertaining. Yes, I'm RN and I watch junk TV before bed!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Bossy what would you have done to your daughters when you found out they were off track if you had the technology back than? Do you think tracking can help kids toe the line or make parents follow through on discipline threats....or does it just make us know are kids are not Angels?

    Also does tracking keep anyone safer or is it just letting us know they are in danger earlier? I think it might just be a false sense of security. We still can not prevent the worst case senerios from happening we just might not have to wait as long to find out our kids have been harmed, does that make sense?

    Rn, I quite like the middle and to be honest I see a little Sue Heck's unfailing optomisism and social indifference in my daughter....

  • 9 years ago

    Roarah, I can sense where you are coming from. I was really adamant about not getting my kids electronics/phones when their peers were getting them, nor did I want to submit to peer pressure. This is why I held out so long with my oldest on getting a phone and yes, she really was one of the last few in her grade to have one, and it wasn't even an iPhone. I really felt backed into a corner when she later was having social issues b/c of not having an iPhone. It wasn't until I witnessed her exclusion with my own eyes that I realized the situation fully. If she was more outgoing and made friends easily, I would have held firm, but it was really a delicate situation so I gave in and let her get the iPhone. But I begrudgingly did so b/c it annoyed me that I was giving into peer pressure and even more annoyed that parents were buying them for their kids and creating the haves/haven nots. But hey, to be expected when my kids are in a private school with lots of spoiled kids. In hindsight, this is one of those things where I said "I will never...." but then had to rethink my stance once I was faced with it.


    As far as the tracking, so far DD17 has given me no reason to not trust her so I don't feel the need to track her whereabouts (except in those couple of instances above but those were not related to a lack of trust, just concern for safety). I*hope* I don't feel the need to track DS16's whereabouts when he gets his license, but let's just say....though I trust him so far, his peer group is definitely more social than dd's is and I know I will worry about him ALL the time when he is out at night with the car, or even moreso when he is in a friend's car!



  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    My son has had a phone since 3rd grade, he is now in 6th. However, I am divorced and his father and I share custody of him. Our decision to get him a phone was for having direct access to him when he is with the other parent. That being said I have never tracked him nor has he given me any reason to want to.

    roarah thanked Caroline Hamilton
  • 9 years ago

    Roarah, I truly don't know. i think i would have considered it another parenting tool for safety concerns and also for discipline. Would it have been 100% effective, I doubt it.

    roarah thanked bossyvossy
  • 9 years ago

    Would you have wanted your parents to track your every move?

    roarah thanked rosesstink
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I would not have wanted my parents to track me, but that is because I was often lying about where I was and who I was with. Same with my siblings. My parents were very hands-off because they trusted us to be smart and do the right thing. We were not and we did not.

    My mother still doesn't know about the stuff we got up to, and if anything she thinks I was a goody two-shoes. Not quite...

  • 9 years ago

    Tracking wasn't an option when my kids were younger. But if it had been available, a tracking app would have been installed on their phone.

    My kids weren't bad, and never gave me a reason to not trust them. I don't feel it's "snooping" when you're protecting them or being cautious.

    There was a period when as a teen, my daughter was going through a tough time. I admit I read her diary to see where she was "emotionally." I read it twice within a 2 month time span and was able to get her redirected and the help she needed.

    If she were a teen today and I thought she needed to be tracked to keep her safe, I'd do it in a heartbeat.

    I will even go as far as suggesting an app calledLife360. It's free.

    My husband & I both have it installed on our phones, and our adult kids can access it as well. (We don't track them. LOL) My husband has a medical condition, and it's been a blessing!

    roarah thanked pudgeder
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Sometimes the lack of trust may be about one's parenting skills. For ex. My SS had this HS friend that I really liked. Afable, friendly fellow, looked like the pilsbury doughboy. He had an open invitation to our house. I learned thru the teachers that Pillsbury doughboy was a drug dealer. I felt shocked, stupid, bretrayed, totally devoid of ability to read these kids. Temporary, but i felt very insecure about my abilities. You bet I would have been on a tracking frenzy, at least for a while. I guess just as well that it wasn't available to me, ha.

    @rosestink, my mom had a super tight leash on me and yet there are a few things she never knew about my teenage years. Tight leash effectiveness: doubtful, but it probably made her feel in control of my safety and behavior. I hold no grudge whatsoever about her need to control me.

  • 9 years ago

    bossy, my parents kept a tight rein on my sister & me as well. And I have no grudge either. In fact, I feel blessed that they took their parenting job seriously and loved us enough to be parents and not "friends."

  • 9 years ago

    You survived. And probably learned a few things along the way. I think it is stifling for kids to be tracked 24/7. I made mistakes and bad decisions too when I was a kid. Still do on occasion. Children need to be allowed the freedom to make mistakes and learn from them.

    roarah thanked rosesstink
  • 9 years ago

    I'm not sure anyone here is advocating tracking 24/7. Well, I certainly am not anyone. I do think there are times it can come in handy. I have not used it with my dd to ascertain whether she is being honest about her whereabouts, but have used it on a couple of occasions when she first got her license when I was unable to reach her and had no idea where she was (she was at work and couldn't use her phone).


    I do agree that 24/7 tracking is stifling and that kids need to be able to make mistakes and learn from them. These type of apps have a convenience to them that can certainly be abused or overused but that does not mean that at times they can have a convenient use.

  • 9 years ago

    How about your college kids?!! Our oldest was one of the first generations to go off to school with a cell phone. When they removed all the land lines one really has no options but to buy these insidious marvels of modern technology. It was a mere 30 years since I myself had been in college, I remembered the freedom rush like it was yesterday. DS and I made a pact. If he called me once a week I would NOT be one of THOSE mom's texting him all day..He kept his promise and I mine. The daughters followed suit and now I have adult offspring living in far off places who take an hour each week to check in. Perfect.

    roarah thanked arcy_gw
  • 9 years ago

    I would bet most kids wouldn't care if they were tracked. As parents of kids with phones, we insist on frequent communication especially when it involves a car. For ex, "Text me when you get there" or "Text me when you leave". It's a way of life for them and if they don't have to "speak" to you, they usually comply. My kids are older so I didn't have to deal with IPhone technology and more specifically, the ability to take pictures. That feature can be TROUBLE and it can happen in an instant. I know of a child who was expelled from a private due to sharing ( and content obviously). A simple click of a button can change your life--that's a lot of responsibility for a 12 year old.

    roarah thanked ratherbesewing
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Ratherbesewing, the constant need to share, pictures and often location scares me very much. I was stalked in college and boy the creep would have succeeded in always finding me if I used a cell phone back than like many do today.

    no one worries that with these apps you are not the only ones tracking your kids' moves? The apps sell the info to marketers often and others can easily hack your tracker to also know where your minor is especially easy if your privacy settings are not secured.

  • 9 years ago

    I have three adult offspring and a younger one who will get a cell phone when she's in 8th grade. DH, kids, and I have always, since smart phones, been able to track each other. My mom and I can also "see" each other. It was never about trust (or lack thereof), but about reassurance and safety. It's not something that I check frequently.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    This is a real question. Those who say they track to keep a love one safe, how do you think it keeps us safe? I understand as a reassurance that one we love is where they are meant to be when they are meant to be there but how does tracking prevent any unsafe incident from occurring exactly? I am not being snarky I honestly wonder if there is some aspect of safety I have over looked. I honestly only see tracking as a way to find out earlier than with out it that a horrible event has occurred. And honestly the extra time before a tragedy is a godsend to be honest. If someone with a phone is missing or kidnapped the authorities will track their phone anyway so how does us having the app actually increase safety in your opininion? What am I missing?

  • 9 years ago

    My kids range are 18, 15, 13, and 10. The 18 year old has a phone that he pays for. There is no tracking app on it right now because it has not proven necessary, yet. For my 15 year old, I fear we are going to have to pony up for an iphone. I am not thrilled about this as it is a significant expense. She is diabetic and the continuous glucose monitor we are considering works with an iphone. She is not out a lot without us but she would most likely have a tracking app because of the diabetes.

    For the 2 younger ones, neither has a phone right now. Attending open house at the middle school opened my eyes a little bit to the usage, though. Teachers often use a lot of different programs for checking homework that are easier with a smartphone but still possible with computers. One teacher allowed kids to text her questions if they were too inhibited to speak up in class. Kids would often also use the phone to take pictures of notes. I am not sure how we are going to approach this in the future. I kind of resent the additional cost in an already strained budget (especially with daughter's diabetes mentioned above) and the gulf between the haves and have nots is definitely widening.

    roarah thanked tishtoshnm Zone 6/NM
  • 9 years ago

    I never thought about using one to track insulin, that is a safety feature for certain. My husband works for a company that makes diabetic monitors, I will mention that they should be compatible to all devices, seems like to not be is fleecing someone with a medical necessity. Shameful of apple! Good for you holding off til 13. I think at twelve or thirteen will be when my child decides it is worth using her own money to buy her samsung tracfone...

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm not planning on tracking but who knows when the time comes. This probably won't be popular, but I dislike kids having smartphones. Unfortunately it's not going away. Why add one more layers of issues to deal with? I guess taking away a smartphone doesn't eliminate the internet for kids. Technology is a great thing but I know I wasn't responsible enough to handle one growing up and I believe I was actually pretty mature compared to some classmates.

    And for young kids, I can't picture a situation where mine would be without an adult somewhere nearby. I don't see anything wrong with a stripped down phone. DH is determined our kids won't have a phone until they can pay for one. I don't want our kids to have to deal with social issues because they don't have one. I dislike that I'm going to want to give into the peer pressure.

    Grown adults have problems with using their phones so I don't understand why we think it's a good idea to give kids smartphones. From talking to people I know it seems like it's even harder on girls. Many parents try and monitor and guide the best they can but some don't. I think the whole thing is a shame.

  • 9 years ago

    I agree 100 percent Shee! To be honest the waiting till you can pay for it is working with my 10 year old. She has enough to to buy one with her own money, granted a Samsung smartphone with a tracfone pay as you go plan. It would give her the phone 1500 minutes, texts and 3G to last a year and than she can refil as need with her allowance but even though some friends have phones, she has no desire to use her own money for it, but would jump for one if I was footing the bill. So even with light but still existent peer pressure she is saving her money for a cooler bike. I think their having to buy a phone they can afford to keep and self support lessens the us giving into peer pressure issue in multiple ways.

  • 9 years ago

    Ok, I can revise my statement to just "reassurance" from "reassurance and safety", because you're right: the safety aspect is largely reactionary. But if a bad thing did happen, having extra time to respond could be critical. (For example, knowing almost immediately that a child didn't get where he or she was supposed to go, vs. finding out late that evening that something was amiss when he or she didn't come home.)

    roarah thanked fouramblues
  • 9 years ago

    Good point fouramblues.

  • 9 years ago

    I have no kids so can't say anything about tracking them but I'm glad to hear most people aren't helicoptering with the tracking. Call me old fashioned but it sounds ridiculous.

    DH and I have the find my iPhone set up - usually just use it to find DH's missing phone. However I have once or twice used it to try to find DH when he didn't respond to texts or phone calls. Ever since he had a stroke when he was home alone I'm a little more paranoid that something might happen to him and he'd go down alone somewhere. If I find the phone not moving in some strange place I might go there to see if he's okay.

    I did once find it at a golf course - not moving. It was late in the day and I thought he might have gone down out by himself and no one came by to find him. I actually called the golf course and he was standing there talking to the pro. Fortunately he understood my concern and didn't think I was tracking him....

    roarah thanked 3katz4me
  • 9 years ago

    I will mention that they should be compatible to all devices, seems like to not be is fleecing someone with a medical necessity. Shameful of apple!

    To be fair, my research in this area is rather early so I am not 100% clear yet on the ins and outs and I am not sure if any shame needs to be applied to Apple yet. Fleecing, medical necessity, etc. seems to be par for the course. Have you seen what insulin pumps run? I shudder to think about it and will probably get nauseous when we have to pay for one.

  • 9 years ago

    I wish this technology had been around when my sons were young, especially the older one. He liked to get away with things and it would have been nice to know exactly where he was. Good that most of you seem to have well behaved kids, but let's face it, many teens are challenging and not always where they say they are. I know I told my parents I was going to the library when in fact I was meeting up with friends. I'm sure my parents would have greeted me at the door with the evidence if they had had it! After age 18, kids deserve the right to not be tracked.

    Should have had one for my ex. There were times when I wondered where he was, too! LOL

  • 9 years ago

    So far I haven't felt the need to track my kids. But for those who do keep tabs or think they are keeping tabs, there are ways around it. Although I don't like the expense of the cells phones, it's nice to know I can be in contact when they are out. Neither drive yet, so I'm still dropping off and pick up but we're getting close to the them driving in the next 3-6 months. Poor DD I'm sure will be using her map app. on her phone as she has terrible sense of direction!!


    roarah thanked always1stepbehind
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Too funny dedtired! I have young ones now I have no idea what the teen years will bring so that is why I am trying to acquire lots of points of view on this technology so if I do feel I might need it I am informed of its pluses and minuses.

    tishtosh, sorry that you and your dad are faced with this horrible disease

    . ((Hugs)) to you both.

    3katz, I am glad your DH is doing well now!

  • 9 years ago

    My DH uses the legal term "expectation of privacy", as in "until you are a self-supporting adult, you should have no expectation of privacy". If we are paying for the devices and the service, we own it all, just like an employer.

    In our house, what it means is that we need to have everyone's passwords for their devices and accounts, and we reserve the right to periodically review their activity/messages/images etc.

    We hardly ever do any of that. And none of it is foolproof anyway. Like a lot of parenting, there is some smoke and mirrors involved.

    I don't think we can compare today's world to our teen years. It's not about reading diaries. It is about real world risks well beyond their years to assess. I often tell my DH, kids get expelled today for things they text, when kids used to *say* the same things when we were teens, but there was no record of it. (at least in private schools they are very strict about tech)

    As is the fashion in our circles, we held off mightily on technology of all kinds. I think I related before that this once resulted in a long car ride with my son and another middle school student who spent most of the the time talking about StarWars. My son had never seen or heard of it, but he was an opera buff. LOL At what point were our good intentions handicapping him?

    One of my DD actually burst into tears the year she opened a present and got her phone, so belated was it in her peer group. They have become a vital means of being part of communities for kids.

    As a parent, I like that my kids have phones. I can reach them when the urge strikes me. I can text rather than nag or yell. And it is very handy for punishment. My youngest DD has not had her phone for weeks as a punishment, and my DH points out it hurts us more. It complicates logistics and, ironically, if she does something, I can't think of how to punish her because I already have her phone. Maybe I need to get her another one. ; )


    roarah thanked MtnRdRedux
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    My ten year old prefers classical to modern music and was sad when we went to Disney world instead of the U.K. one vacation. My mom had always hoped to have a family vacation in Disney with all her grand kids so it trumped our yearly visit home to see my in laws you would think we the worst parents in the world from her reaction when we told her we were going to Florida not England that year....

    i fully intend for my kids to have access to cell phones at the appropriate age, determined by us not society though and affordable to them so not i15s ;). I want them to budget texts and gigabytes and money before they are on their own too and thus they will need to pay for their devices.

    I agree with my house my terms! I actually have a basket for kids' tech gadgets when they come to my house to play with my kids, they are asked to leave their tabs or phones in it til they go home. They are here to play with my kids only....my eldest has about three friends with phones and they are not permitted to use them in my car nor house at all. The texting In front of one friend to another friend drives me insane with my adult peers and feels like rude whispering and gossiping behind my back to me a, 40 something confident woman, I can only imagine how hurt and insecure it must leave a ten year old...

    It is the being a vital part of being a community aspect that really saddens me. Many kids, over 5 percent, in my town are on assisted lunch and can not afford food. And we have a lot of kids bussed here from new haven to receive a better education. These kids are already alienated from neighborhood gatherings because they live outside of the town and everyone knows who gets free breakfast and lunch and it becomes a stigma in and of it self and now not having a phone only adds to that isolation . This all before middle school :(.

  • 9 years ago

    roarah, having kids check their devices at the door isn't a bad idea. I don't do that, but I generally don't give them the wifi password, explaining that play dates are for: playing. together.

    roarah thanked fouramblues
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Geez, I never even thought about kids bringing phones and tablets along and spending time on those instead of playing. *Sigh* I don't feel ready for life past Curious George and Disney's Planes.

  • 9 years ago

    One of many reasons I am happy my grandkids have phones-- yesterday in Polk County, FL. Horrible accident where 5 kids were hit by a drunk driver. One of the classmates was able to phone her dad (a Polk County deputy) who was one of the first to get to the scene.

    You never ever think it's going to happen to those you love until it does.

    roarah thanked maddielee