Software
Houzz Logo Print
whypraytellwhy

What is a ''good reliable soil test''?

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

The phrase seems to be seen here quite a bit. Just exactly what is a ''good reliable soil test''?


Or perhaps better expressed, how does one know if one is getting a ''good reliable soil test''?

Comments (9)

  • 9 years ago

    A good reliable soil test is one where a laboratory does the testing, one that puts reports out with readable and understandable information and not just graphs.

    Those home soil testing kits sold by garden centers are not good reliable tests because they do not provide you with the information you need to make good decisions about the soil. Those home test kits also do not have an important test, soil organic matter.

  • 9 years ago

    That's a good point about home soil testing kits. Chemically, those kits are credible, but they require that instructions be followed very carefully, and that's often hard for the home gardener to do. A number of kits have been tested by the UC ag extension, and that's what they found. The price of a professional soil test isn't a lot more than the price of a good quality home kit. So why bother with the latter?

    But no, a good soil test is not necessarily one where a "lab" does the testing and provides "understandable information". Any crappy lab can do a bad job coming up with incorrect results, and dress it up to make it look "understandable". There are home gardeners with cheap kits who sell their services as a "lab". Again, reputation is a good discriminant. Many ag extensions who don't do their own commercial soil tests will provide a list of labs that they consider to be reputable.

  • 9 years ago

    The Haney Britton test (a.k.a. Solvita). But it is expensive, although getting less expensive by the year.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Haney Britton test (a.k.a. Solvita), I'm rooting for them, but not ready for "prime time" yet. In fact, a long way from it.

  • 9 years ago

    that surely explains the near exponential growth in its use. what is prime time? chemistry only?

  • 9 years ago

    The OP is unclear here. Are you asking how you can know if you are getting a reliable test done for you, or are you asking how you can know whether a soil testing system you can get is reliable? Kinda different questions.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    exponential growth in its use - That's meaningless as an argument. If one person out of 100 did it and now 4 people out of 100 are doing it, that's exponential growth, but not necessarily, in itself, a convincing argument.

    "Prime time" is a colloquialism meaning not yet ready for use. It has yet to be sufficiently correlated to results or calibrated to give accurate recommendations for fertility amendment.

    The H3A component alone is subject to wild discrepancies between the few labs that provide the service. In addition the P and K recommendations are drastically inconsistent with those derived from current standard testing methods.

    Hopefully, in time, enough field site studies will improve it's accuracy and reliability-or not. Rome wasn't built in a day. :/

  • 9 years ago

    I see my comment of two days ago was not posted. It is clear that the test is best (currently) w.r.t. N, simply because N is more coupled to C than anything else. I appreciate that P is largely regulated by micro-organisms which are a tiny fraction of the total micro-flora (by weight).

    According to Gabe Brown (a farmer whose ranch is studied a lot by the nearby NDSU group), you can grow corn well with very small measurable inorganic N in the soil. The point being that you can prove the chemical tests wrong, too. I think a lot of the noise is studies done with fields which have not undergone a full 5 years conversion to new methods. The micro-flora is not built in a day either.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting