Software
Houzz Logo Print
zackwisemangardens

Strange Soil Test Results

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Hi All!

I have a small garden design/maintenance company in Z6 Lexington, KY. This Spring we got a call from a rosarian looking to get some extra help with her garden. All hybrid teas. The large majority of her roses(60-75) are in four parterres, with nothing else inter-planted. The are protected on two sides by 12' Hemlock hedges and a structure on the third, but have enough space from the aforementioned that they receive solid, full Sun. Drip irrigated twice a week through the growing season. The first thing that struck me was that she was losing ~15-25% of her roses each winter, and replacing. The roots get a 2-4" topdressing of pine bark fines in the fall for protection. Between the topdressing and the large amount of new plantings each year her soil is almost entirely a mixture of potting soil and pine fines as deep as I have ventured(~12"). This made the soil my primary suspect in her (to me) unusually high annual losses. I had a soil test done, as she hadn't done one in all her years of growing roses in these parterres. Test shows some crazy irregularities. The first is a pH of 4.4(7.2-7.5 or our native soils). Obviously a concern, but also a fairly easy fix. Bit of a calcium deficiency, as well as very high potassium and phosphorus levels(common even in our native soils here). Again, useful information but not a big deal. Here's the kicker: organic material is at 33%. I've never seen, or even heard of such a thing. Native soils here are usually 4-9%, with old, well tended gardens more in the 10-15% range. I believe I am the only person who is Googling with concerns about too much organic matter, as I cant seem to find any information. Does anyone have any thoughts on the implications of this?

Comments (8)

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I appreciate the quick response. I guess based on your post I think I should clarify a bit. The soil is not and has never been intentionally "amended" with potting soil or pine fines. The process of losing substantial amounts of material in a densly planted bed and replanting 3 gallon roses year after year has simply left us in this position. I understand the how and why we ended up with the pH and OM situation we are in. I guess my main question is, "What are the implications of a high OM percentage, beyond acidification?"

    As far as fertilizer, I'm not sure yet. We've taken over pesticides/fungicides, but she is still doing fert. I am going to recommend a low, pure nitrogen(x-0-0) based on how high her P and K are.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi ZWG, any there any evidence of garden worms ?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    David,

    Can't say I've paid much attention, but from my recollection I would say very few earthworms.

  • 9 years ago

    Wow, this is very interesting! In my garden, with it's terribly poor, depleted soil, I'd never have imagined it was possible to have too much OM!

  • 9 years ago

    As interesting as I find this discussion, you might want to post the question over in the "Soil, Compost and Mulch" forum. I have found them very helpful on these types of questions.

  • 9 years ago

    Many potting soils have a larger percentage of organics than 33% and are fine for growing roses. The usual problem with high organics in the soil is a tying up of nitrogen. If the leaf color, size of leaf and growth of plants seem normal, I don't think that I would worry about the organic content, pH, or nutrients in the soil.

    I really think that the key here is winter loss

    Winter soil tend to be wetter due to less evaporation. One worry about too much organics can be poor soil structure. If the soil has become mucky, not loose and friable, it may lack pore space. Lack of pores mean less air and that could cause root damage. Also this would explain the unusually low pH. Pine fines that are soaking wet will lower the pH, dry fines tend to have little effect on pH. I would not use pine fines in a garden for fear of compaction but would prefer to use a large size pine bark. (Hopefully they are using pine bark fines or composted pine wood fines, raw pine wood fines could cause problems)

    Another cause of winter damage is dieback. This can be cause by freeze damaged canes becoming infected, this infection can spread and kill the plant. Sometimes winter dieback is caused by warming periods in which new grow appears and then is damage by late freezes. This is a real problem where I live and I lose roses to it every winter.

    Still another winter problem could be not having rose varieties that have the cold tolerance needed to survive the winter conditions.


    I hope that you find the cause of this problem.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I have raised bed which is 4 to 8 inches of leaf compost pile on top of clay soil. At one end I have a really big Hot Princess (diva HT) and at the other end I grow American Pillar which competes with Wisteria and maple tree roots. Based on how well the roses in that bed grow, I don't see any need to mix the leaf compost with anything. When time allows I do cover my beds with wood mulch. I just got another five bags of mulch. At the rate of 3 cubic feet per bag, 20 bags works out to 2 yards of mulch.