Software
Houzz Logo Print
robert_brown97100

Biggest and Best Induction Cooktop

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

Hey Everyone,

Wife and I are looking at homes to purchase and most we like have gas
already in them and that's exactly what I want for the range. Already
have a 36" Blue Star RNB 6 burner range picked out for when the time
comes, but today we are actually looking at a house we really like that
probably doesn't even have natural gas in the street. Electric stovetop
there now that I would replace with an induction cooktop.

As I was looking at having a 6 burner range I was hoping to find a 6 burner induction cooktop. No luck so far.

I know you can buy induction units as single burners like the Mirage
Pro, but I was hoping there would be something out there that would be
more of a cooktop. Worst case I guess I buy something I like, like the
Thermador Freedom induction top, and then buy 1 or 2 of the single
induction tops when I need more than 4 pans.

Anyway, haven't had to think about induction until these past 24 hours and wanted to reach out for some insight.

Thank you so much and look forward to hearing some replies!

Comments (35)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The reason you don't see many electric or induction cooktops with lots of burners is that they would be power hogs. A lot of people wouldn't have the available capacity in their electrical system to support it.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Although Viking has a 6 element 36" unit, I'd stick with the 36" Miele with 5. Two 24" Miele units will get you 6.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Oh wow that bluestart looks pretty awesome. Love the knobs. Too bad I don't have space for a 36! Wish they made it in a 30"!

  • 9 years ago

    Does Gaggenau (or was it Miele?) still offer the modular hobs?

  • 9 years ago

    Both, and they still do. Offer modules.

  • 9 years ago

    Having owned a few induction ranges (love induction), I would personally stay away from any company that hasn't had an induction range or cooktop on the market for at least five years. Things do go wrong and without experienced service people diagnosis and repair can be a nightmare with these things. Samsung replaced our range three times because they either couldn't diagnose the problem or couldn't get the part necessary to repair it.

    If you love gas but don't have a gas main, consider propane.

  • 9 years ago

    Well for biggest, I'd vote for an array of Cooktec induction cooking units, including the wok unit. However, the problem with biggest is that the hood has to be comparatively biggest also. It is possible to combine e.g., a Cooktec wok unit with a 36-inch cooktop (see second image below), given proper cabinet layout and the largest Wolf Pro hood.

    Biggest hood I've seen (credit: http://www.handcraftedmetal.com/):


    A more modest 5 +1 hob layout:

    kas

  • 9 years ago

    It's not just the limitation in what stove technology to use, but also a problem with being required to heat electrically. That can get quite expensive. You can reduce some of that problem with good insulation, heat pumps or geothermal instead of resistive heating, and photovoltaic systems. But all of these cost significant upfront investments.

    Alternatively, you could look into propane, which is noticeably more expensive than natural gas. But unless you have really cheap electric rates, it is still much better than electric heating.

    I think, personally, I wouldn't buy a house that doesn't at least have the option of getting natural gas service. The hidden ongoing costs and the practical limitations are simply too high. YMMV

  • 9 years ago

    Don't forget propane! Lots of communities without natural gas use propane or oil heat rather than electric. Virtually everything is cheaper than electric.

  • 9 years ago

    Why is the cost of electricity being brought up w.r.t. induction cooktops? We aren't refining steel here, or even drying clothes. The cost of hard-boiling eggs is approximately one cent in NH. I expect that for most people, the pro-rata cost of the induction cooktop over its lifetime will be commensurate than the cost of the electricity used to run it over that same lifetime.

    You will have to run a suitable electrical power cable to the unit if sufficient power is not already present. A 36-inch induction cooktop will likely require a 50A circuit (AWG 6 conductors) to handle the theoretical full power on every hob case, rounding up for available breakers.

    In any case, the induction cooktop is by far the safest way to cook, and the easiest to clean up after. However, unless one has an inadvertent flambé, one can't roast a marshmallow over a hob.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We have no idea of OP's location! Electric rates vary widely and heating isn't a big deal in all climate zones. "Virtually everything is cheaper than electric" is extremely location dependent and not accurate at all in my experience. Where I used to live in the south with cheap electricity and mild winters nobody had gas and everyone used a heat pump. For all you know OP could be in Florida where some winters go by without heat being used at all. Propane and oil are ripoffs. Even here in New England with our chilly winters and pricy electricity those are going the way of the dodo bird with the latest heat pump technology. Anyhow this is all irrelevant since it's a kitchen appliance forum.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Well, it is effectively a kitchen appliance forum, but nominally the Appliances Forum. And so I'll comment a bit more on this kitchen-wise off-topic diversion. Here in NH, I have observed that heating with an oil furnace is more expensive than with a Mitsubishi split system heat pump (air conditioner/heater) above about 40F, even though the Mitsubishi is rated to -4F. This will depend on the furnace efficiency. Below 40F the electricity cost (due to the lower heat-pump COP) will sky-rocket relative to using an oil burner. Here propane per BTU is more expensive than oil, but less expensive than natural gas. [Edit: Should be "and more" not "but less"]

    However, natural gas is generally only available here in high housing density areas. A recent natural gas pipeline passes only a block from my house, but the gas company is not going to pay to run a line up the street when the take-up from people with built-in oil burner systems and tanks will be slight. The feeder supplies a school and an apartment complex. As far as I can see, there were no connections made to houses passed by the pipeline.

    Even if there were raging demand to replace oil with gas (and its attendant higher fire risk), NE has issues with expanding the natural gas pipelines that would be required to supply the gas. People in the path of the pipelines do not like the idea of having a nearby source of risk, and the intermittently located pumping systems are reportedly fairly loud. Hence there is (at least argued) insufficient gas for industrial expansion, much less housing take-up.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    You sure about natural gas being more expensive than both oil and propane? If this were the case than why would anyone even bother with it? For me propane is by far the most expensive per BTU, with natural gas the cheapest and oil in between. And this is with an 80% furnace, with a 95% which is what pretty much everyone up here who can is installing now, natural gas looks even better.

    As for heat pumps, that depends to a large degree on how tight your house is. Yes, most people will want some sort of fossil fuel backup for colder weather up here. But with these super tight houses some people are building now, it barely takes more than a few 100 watt light bulbs to heat them so the high efficiency heat pumps works great.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Viking has a 6-element with knobs. Hob sizes are identical handling 5"-12" pans, each hob the same size. I think their older one used different sizes, like 7", 8" and 9".

  • 9 years ago

    I did look at that Viking but I don't have the space for it. I would consider the 30" but I really don't like the knobs. Not precise enough for me.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    @hvtech42 Eh? Opps! My bad. Sentence should have read as I have noted above.

  • 9 years ago

    Stay away from Viking.

  • 9 years ago

    Yep. I'm between a Bosch or Miele.

  • 9 years ago

    Other than lack of faux pro styling, the Electrlux induction range has very similar specs to the Bosch and Miele. Costs about $1500

  • 9 years ago

    I actually prefer the Bosch.

  • 9 years ago

    I was able to use the Bosch. Hoping I found a place that has the Miele so I can try it out. Bosch was alright. Liked some of it, didn't like some of it. It'll come down to minor things. Either one though is great.

    I don't like the look of the electrolux at all. Just doesn't suit my eye. Thanks though!

  • 9 years ago

    Robert,

    When you said you used the Bosch, can you elaborate on what you did? Did you cook with your utensils and cookware on a unit? Can you elaborate on what you liked and did not like? If you have a Miele showroom in your area, they have induction models set up for use.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I apologize for being vague. I didn't use my own cookware or cook on it. I boiled some water in a pot that the store had available.

    It heated up quickly and performed as well as I'm sure a Miele will or any other induction top for the post part will.

    I did not enjoy the touch screen. This was a 36" Bosch Benchmark. It did not respond well to my touch. I did not like that to adjust a temperature I had to first select the cooking zone. The cooking zone selection was small and where I spent most of my time tapping over and over until it registered my finger. God forbid I have a por over boiling or a pan burning. That wouldn't be good. I didn't like how the Flexinduction was on by default.

    Haven't used a Miele yet but from what I can tell I already prefer each zone having its own temperature controls. I like it has a Stop/Go function if I have to quickly keep a pot or pan from burning/over-boiling. Great safety feature too. I also like the look of the KM 6365 over the Bosch Benchmark.

    Here's hoping the Miele touch screen isn't any worse than the Bosch!

  • 9 years ago

    Depending upon your fingers, touch screens are always a bit fussy. My experience is only with Wolf:

    0. Put the pot or pan on the element.

    1. To start you press and hold the unlock button until the icon goes away.

    2. Touch the control for the element you want to use, and select the temperature.

    3. If desired, press power boost.


    Gotchas:

    1. If your finger is wet, the touch screen will not respond.

    2. Wiping up spills over the controls will change the settings (I know you never spill, but I do).


    All in all, I am happy with the Wolf, but I see that Bluestar is coming out with one that has real control knobs. Once enough have been built to gain a reputation, that would be one that I would seriously consider when replacement time comes.


  • 9 years ago

    Two issues with knobs.

    One, they seem to be set settings of low, med low, med, med high, high for the most part. Not a lot of inbetween options.


    Two, I like the fact induction can be flush with the counter. Not a huge kitchen and the more counter top space the better. Won't be chopping onions on it, but gotta put grocery bags down or sheets of home made pasta across the counter? I like the flatness.

  • 9 years ago

    The Bluestar shows twelve settings.

  • 9 years ago

    Electrolux has about 14-15 levels but accessed via up/down plus a medium and power boost buttons. A continuous analog type knob would be more desirable but the Electrolux system works.

  • 9 years ago

    Agreed. A continuous mode would be ideal if it can be consistent. I'm not sure it can be, which may be why no one is doing it. The other possible reason that comes to mind is that it's not linear, so half way between 0 and 100% isn't 50%--maybe not even close. Another touch screen solution is to have the touch screen remote from the cooktop. That would eliminate the spill problem. It could also be larger with finer controls. I can see it being mounted on the front of the hood.

  • 9 years ago

    Vollrath Mirage Pro is a single induction hob with a dial that goes 1-100 so fine tuned induction is out there.

  • 9 years ago

    Technically, all of this is certainly possible. Modulating power with PWM (pulse-with-modulation) followed by a filter to remove noise from the signal has been done for ages. Maybe, combine all of that with a feedback loop too. But again, that's all very well understood. Every PC power supply does that internally these days.

    But since we are talking about relatively high power requirements, it is expensive though and might require more difficult cooling. So, I am not surprised that stove manufacturers don't want to go too crazy for a commodity product.

    Also, even if the power curve was non-linear, that wouldn't be a big problem. All of these stoves are computerized already. Even the smallest microcontroller has enough computing power to turn a non-linear curve into something that feels more intuitive to humans.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Robert, I had a Bosch electric cooktop for years and the setup for how to use the buttons is pretty much the same. It becomes intuitive to push the hob you need and then the setting number. What I like about the Bosch is that it has actual setting numbers I can see along with the 1/2 steps.

    I also like that each hob has its own timer, so for example, if you're cooking rice, you can set the timer for the one hob the rice is on, and a second timer for the hob cooking the soup. So no more burnt rice, etc. If you set the timer for 20 minutes, the hob shuts off after 20 minutes.

    Personally, I have no need for the bridge element, so I'm going with the 36" Bosch Induction 800 series.

  • 9 years ago

    Awesome cpartist. If the Miele doesn't work out I'll be going with the Bosch but after convincing my wife into putting a 24" Miele Combi oven underneath the cooktop, I think I know where I'll be heading ;)

  • 9 years ago