Software
Houzz Logo Print
abqconiglio

2 qt. potted from David Austin

Has anyone else purchased the 2 qt. potted roses from David Austin roses? My Munstead Wood arrived 2 days ago, and when removed from the bag, there were a lot of lost and yellow leaves and the plant collapsed. After watering and misting, I placed it in the greenhouse with the orchids and the mist system, pruned off the wilted tips and it has not revived. I'm wondering if other people have had this experience.

Comments (32)

  • 9 years ago

    Yellow leaves, yes, collapsed, no. The clearly stressed plant I received was watered well and left in open shade to shade. It took about three days for it to recover and shortly thereafter it resumed growing. I would definitely call D.A. a.s.a.p.

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked Lynn-in-TX-Z8b- Austin Area/Hill Country
  • 9 years ago

    Yep. Still looks like this:

    I sent DA a message.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Could there be too much moisture in your greenhouse or something else going on with the conditions in there that are less than ideal for your rose?

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked Lynn-in-TX-Z8b- Austin Area/Hill Country
  • 9 years ago

    I received a "two gallon" Abraham Darby with the leaves stripped off from Antique Rose Emporium a few weeks ago. That's two gallon, not quart, and it is a twig, smaller than your DAs. It's since leafed out, but this is the first and last order ARE will get from me. Diane

    Twig Darby

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
  • 9 years ago

    I tried it outdoors in the shade, it looked even worse. But I'll try again. Thanks for the advice! This happened with the WS2K I got from HIgh Country roses, but they perked up right away after watering and taking out of the sun. This one didn't. I guess I'm not too optimistic.

    Diane, I got twig Darby's from DA roses, own-root this year, they are barely coming up even now. Look how small it looked next to my rake. It's body-bag size or smaller. I know how disappointing it is to receive a poor quality plant!

    I've ordered from ARE twice, and the results were mediocre. The first rose I purchased was also a small rose in a big pot. The two Marie Pavie that I bought this year were big robust plants, but have not been particularly happy once planted out, and I have 3 other MP's that are happy so I don't think it's my garden. Maybe they just need time. Your Abe looks nice now, and looks like you did some nice soil prep. I hope it takes off for you!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The ARE roses grow great for me. The own root businesses I have been purchasing from for years/decades always send out younger and smaller roses than the grafted roses. They catch up in size in a hurry. I have not yet gotten a 2 qt from DA.

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked Sheila z8a Rogue Valley OR
  • 9 years ago

    Noseo, ick, that looks awful. And I had such good luck with bare roots over the years, but they were from Palatine, Hortico, Pickering, and Edmunds. Edmunds can't ship to Idaho now (don't know why), and Pickering is gone. I try to buy local, but when I went to buy Abe from my favorite nursery, the Abes were all gone. So I ordered online. A couple of weeks later, I went back to the nursery, and there was an Abe. The worker said a customer had come in and bought all the Abes. Then a few weeks later, brought back four of them, and this was the one left. I did not send out nice thoughts to that customer--good thing she wasn't there. I already had my ARE Abe by then. Oh, the trials and travails of the rose gardener. I hope your Munstead Wood perks up and comes through all right. I am baffled at what caused the plant to collapse--the heat en route would be my first guess. Diane

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
  • 9 years ago

    Hey Diane, your Abe looks robust compared to the one I received from another place...it has sprouted out some leaves since then but wow it was so tiny that I transferred in a gallon pot the same day it arrived afraid that it was going to die if left as is.

  • 9 years ago

    These small ones are typical of the own root roses sold by the specialty nurseries that I've purchased for years. They will do well.

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked Sheila z8a Rogue Valley OR
  • 9 years ago

    Sheila, I understand and admire your supportive attitude toward the online sellers. I just wasn't used to ordering potted roses online, only bare root. Plus, Edwards Nursery has switched over to mostly own root Austins and those babies are just as big as the grafted ones--huge plants in five gallon pots, with buds and usually blooming, too. Getting used to the much smaller online potted plants will take time. In my case, the pot was two gallon, but not the plant.

    Liakawak, that's pretty bad, a plant with only two skinny canes. I hope its hanging in there, and ends up doing well. I put my Abe in the ground because he seemed ready for this and loves it. Sheila is right, I'm sure, and he will explode in a month. Then I'll have to find a permanent spot for the poor rose--little orphan with no home and surrounded by monstrous sized roses. It looks pretty funny, actually. Diane

  • 9 years ago

    I purchased 2 two-quart roses from DA last year. Both arrived with virtually no roots and were 90% dead. I emailed photos and received a full refund. All my other purchases from DA have been great but they really need to improve the 2-quart product.

    Ann

    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked Ann9BNCalif
  • 9 years ago

    I'm beginning to think we should all stick to bare root plants when ordering online. They have been great for me. Diane

  • 9 years ago

    For $28 I expected a better plant than this. Thanks for your thoughts. Yes, they need to improve this product. Maybe it's just a bad year for rose growers...

  • 9 years ago

    noseometer - $28 for THAT??!!! Oh that's terrible!

    Carol

  • 9 years ago

    Diane, you can't get these special varieties we may want in the large size. Many parts of the country have no nurseries that sell them close to them, and own root are too labor intensive to grow very large, like Tea roses for example. This would be true too for many rare roses like Vintage used to sell. The whole problem is that some people want some of these other varieties.

  • 9 years ago

    rosecanadian - yes, PLUS shipping. Shocking, isn't it?

  • 9 years ago

    Sheila, as far as DA roses go, I can get a big selection of huge own roots locally at Edwards, so I would think the online companies could sell a little larger plant, too--not necessarily a five gallon one, but something a bit larger to fit the pot they come in.

    Noseo, did you get your money refunded for that plant? What happened to it? Diane

  • 9 years ago

    Wow! When I ordered own root from DA, they were huge! So much bigger than the own root that I had gotten in the past from Heirloom. Guess things have gone down hill since I did that three/four years ago. Rose, did they come like that from DA in Texas? I would agree to call right away and let them know.

    I have a feeling that this is just not going to be a good year for roses. Weather has been too variable. Whizzed by the rose fields in Wasco yesterday for Star roses. They looked big and healthy but their test garden looked smaller to me this year than in the past. However, the test garden was the only thing blooming at the moment. Looked like they had some pretty ones. The other ones in the field were nice and tall but no blooms. My hunch is they cut them off for shipping. They were very big plants however from what little I could see.

  • 9 years ago

    I agree nose, that is a pitiful specimen. Not only small but bedraggled. I would be askino for a replacement.

    I ordered dark desire from Jackson & Perkins on Mother's Day. I called the other day to see where my roses and when it would be delivered and they said they had a very bad crop of dark desire and they would not send them out. Even though I was disappointed I appreciate that they didn't send me a sickly crappy Rose

  • 9 years ago

    I ordered 3 own roots from DA this year. And they arrived healthy. These are big plants, the stems are as thick as my thumb.

    I planted them 3 weeks ago and they have been thriving since the weather warmed up.

    I do think you get more bang for your buck if you go own root/bare root. The potted ones almost always end up smaller unless you buy them in person.

  • 9 years ago

    I have had great success ordering from DA, ARE, Chamblees, and RU.


    Sometimes it is dependent on the time of year you order and the heat they were exposed to in shipping. Sometimes they have arrived worse for wear but they have always perked up after I water them in and get them planted.

  • 9 years ago

    noseometer...7A...ABQ It's quite possible there may be some root competition in the pot. Here's my 2-quart Wollerton Old Hall from DA. If the stems do not look like they are coming from a central point in the pot, you might consider submerging the plant in a bucket of water and separating each plant. The soil should crumble easily in the water. They should recover and perform much better individually. Matt


    noseometer...(7A, SZ10, Albuquerque) thanked Matt 6a Boston
  • 9 years ago

    Matt, did you receive 3-4 bands in the 2 quart or was that several 2 quart plants?

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Kelly - They were 3 bands in one 2-quart pot.

  • 9 years ago

    That's surprising. I've received doubles from Chamblees before but assumed the DA's were field grown, pulled when dormant, then potted up. I had no idea they're just stuffing bands into 2 quart pots. To be honest though, 3 well-rooted cuttings like that for $28 ain't bad.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Mine looks like 3 cuttings in one pot, but I'm not sure if any of them will live at this point. I tried putting the pot outdoors in the shade, but nearly all the leaves and the leaf buds are dried now. I called DA and they said they would record my complaint and someone would get back to me, but there was only one person to do it, and they were backed up from the holiday, so that he couldn't tell me when. It's a bit frustrating but DA has had good service in the past. At least the stems still have some green and haven't dried yet, so there is some hope, but it is very disappointing.

    Update: Received e-mail that they would like me to give it a week. Hmm.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Well, doesn't look like there is any viable part to this rose:

    I sent photos to DA and they are replacing it in the fall. They agree that it looks like it got heat damaged in transit and want to wait until the weather cools down. Unfortunately that means more waiting. But then isn't gardening called the slowest of all the performance arts? I suppose I need to be patient.

    Matt, I did break it up and there were 3 cuttings in the pot just as you said. Unfortunately not one survived.

    At least I already have one Munstead Wood.

    Sheila, thanks for your positive attitude. I am used to receiving small bands, and you are right, the variety of plants from on-line/mail order vendors makes it worth it even if it is more expensive for a smaller plant. Own-root plants are not available locally for me. This experience will not make me shy away from ordering more roses by mail (I just wanted to know if others had the same or similar experience with the 2 qt. Austin product)! I'm bummed that I missed the ARE sale. Or rather, I didn't miss it, I just don't have room for more plants! The first bare-root plants I received from DA a few years ago were 3 Bishop's Castle, and these were huge plants, with many 2-1/2 foot long roots, so I was disappointed that this year's shipment didn't compare to those.

    When I planted that Abe, it looked like this:

    Now it looks like this:

    It's still much smaller than yours, Diane, but it is growing!

  • 9 years ago

    Looks great! Too bad about the cooked rose.

  • 9 years ago

    Ouch, so sorry to see that noseometer. It must have been something other than overcrowding in the pot. I hope your next Munstead performs better! Good thing DA has a 5 year warranty on their plants.

  • 9 years ago

    I've had trouble with incorrectly labeled 2 quart roses from DA. I ordered 2 jubilee celebration in 2 quart pots lasted and they turned out to be Lady Of Shallot. The replacement roses they sent last fall have started to bloom and they also are LOS and not JC.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Jubilee celebration's patent expires. It's hard to root and a WEAKER plant than Princess Alexandra of Kent (per HMF picture comparing the two).

    LOS is extremely vigorous in my zone 5a as own-root, 5' x 3'.

    David Austin wrongly sold L.D. Braithwaite (very vigorous up to 6' tall) AS Tradescant (hard to root & small and weak plant). This mistake carries through with other nurseries, but it starts with DAVID AUSTIN'S MISLABELING of vigorous plants as the weaker plant that the buyer wants.