Vera, I do vote for Liberty...

Mine, bought from Van den Top last year:

This year a little late because I made the mistake to plant the crown too deep:

Noted the price on Cicely's Sagae...a pizza costs more than such a wonderful plant...The longer they are on the market the cheaper they get...Easy to start a nice basic collection with twenty or more plants for 100 € or even less if one does not focus on the fancy specimens...

Karin

Looks like liberty to me. Give it time. It won't disappoint

Thank you, guys! I do hope it will improve one day... And that it won't take 4 more years ))))

As it gets older the margins will get wider.

I think it looks like Liberty to me. It could take another two years before it becomes a stunner. I bought mine in 2012 and it had three eyes. Here is a photo of it at four eyes the following year. I think your hosta looks a lot like mine did.

Yes Liberty, I think that everyone should have at least one, fairly fast grower in my experience.

Just took these photos - Sagae is mature; Liberty is in its 4th year but 2nd year in this location. Not that you need a sixth person to confirm that what you have is a Liberty, but here I am anyway, lol!

Individually - apologies for quality, forgot to use HDR setting on iPad ...

I think the tell is in an obviously-wider margin from the get-go and lot more ripples in Liberty. Even when my Sagae was young it had a big ripple in leaf in midsection resembling a fold which has flattened with age whereas Liberty, due to a wider leaf, displays more flounce in its leaves.