Software
Houzz Logo Print
lmuhlhan84

Trying to find a cooking range - Frustrated! Help please!

9 years ago

I'm looking for a range to replace my parent's '95 Jenn-Air dual-fuel LP 30" range. The old girl has lasted 22 years, but the broiler has gone kaput and the once-reliable burners are no longer; three out of four are basically simmer burners. With Christmas nearing, it would be the gift of gifts.

Both my father and brother are becoming more adventurous in the kitchen and my mother has been dying for an upgrade for extended family meals. To satisfy everyone's cooking styles there are key features I've picked for a new range. 60 days later...here I am still searching for the all-inclusive product; the models are becoming a blur. I just can't find one! This is what I'm in the market for:

  • Price up to $6,000, prefer around $4,000 - $5,000 (or lower)
  • 30" Dual-Fuel LP slide-in gas range
    - Self cleaning a must (unless there is a concealed baking element)
  • Four or Five Burners with at least one high-output (20,000 - 25,000 BTUs or close), one 15,000 (or close) and one simmer burner.
  • True/Euro convection w/decent fan size (trying to avoid dual-fan; reviews of cold spots due to positioning)
  • Infrared broiler

These are simple requests on their own, but finding them all (or most) in one range is proving difficult. I've narrowed down my choices to:

  1. Viking VDSC530T4BSS or VDSC5304BSS (No information is forthcoming on differences)
  2. GE Cafe C2S985SETSS
  3. Blue Star Platinum Series

The biggest issue I have is LP conversion BTU loss. Viking's 5 series is a line to consider and all the oven attributes I want are there, but Viking does not offer the 18,500 BTU power burner on the 30" range. It comes standard with 15,000 BTU output on all burners. With LP it's drastically reduced to 12,500 BTUs. That's a deal-breaker for me and I can't move up in size to the 36". Confusing as well are the model numbers listed above. No discernible features pop out to see that they are, in fact, different. The only things I can see are the VDSC530T4B has been discontinued and there has to be a meaning behind "T" in the model number.

The GE Cafe model C2S985SET, albeit on the other side of the spectrum from Viking, is another I was attracted to because of the price ($2298 locally), it includes a fifth center burner and GE is known to retain most of it's BTU energy in an LP conversion. There is still quite a bit of loss going from 20,000 to 15,000 on the power burner and the oven specs aren't quite what I'm looking for. There is a standard broiler (no infrared) and a small fan reverse air convection system. I'm also worried about GE turning over it's appliance division to Haier and what that might mean for the warranty and quality replacement parts.

I did look into the Blue Star Platinum Series and, though adding up to more than my top end budget, entertained expanding my price cap for nothing less than a hole-in-one. Thought I was there and realized they don't offer dual fuel! Back to the drawing board.

At this point I have neither the time or mental capacity to keep looking. Lol :)

Does anyone have suggestions on a range or can you point me in the right direction? I know 6K is my cap, but I'd like to have some left over for minor renovations if needed for the range to fit. Since more than likely a down draft will not be an option, a hood purchase may be in my future.

Thank you all so much for any help (and for reading through my venting rant...haha!) ;-)

P.S. Advice on venting systems/hoods are welcomed also; it would be above a 30" range and island measuring approx. 60" wide, 72" long. The ceilings are 13'. Currently there is nothing set up so I am clueless on how to begin that venture - or if I even truly need it.

Comments (15)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Email me with your email and I'll shoot you the info on my source for high end ranges at 60% discount.

    Several GWers have been very happy with their purchases. You'll have to ship from California.

    i bought my Blue Star rangetop from them and FP DW.

    BS range will be around $3k? You'll have to wait for when they come in. I waited 6 mos for mine and snapped them up the first day.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Beach - what a generous offer!

    OP, if you liked the Jenn Air, why not stick with it? Fwiw, the biggest issue with gas ranges is getting low heat, not high searing heat, even with lp that burns cooler than natural gas. Were I choosing a range I'd go with the Blue Star or Capitol Culinarian, but many around here love the bertazzoni with a passion.

  • 9 years ago

    eam44 - I've only looked briefly at the Jenn Air models, mostly because none of the features jumped out at me and I was looking for a change. Have you researched them at all? I could take another look. I agree with you on gas ranges and low heat - I am looking for a range that offers one (true) simmer burner or the ability for all burners to provide this feature.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I know that Blue Star is generally well liked, and I seem to remember that Viking is not. I would suggest that you also post this in the Appliance forum. The Appliance folk really know their appliances! Here is the link.

    And before someone else beats me to the punch, I'll also suggest induction.

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you Sherri1058, I'll post to the Appliances board as well. I'm purchasing a range for a bunch who are adamant on gas-power stoves so I don't think I can sell them on induction. Thank you for the input :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Don't be taken by the fifth burner. At 30", you'll likely never be able to use more than 4 at a time. Also, you mention a new hood. Do you have a ventilation system with make-up air? If not, there is a limit to how many BTUs you want to have.

    The Jenn Air 30" Pro-Style dual fuel range with multi mode convection has a lot of what you are looking for and is under budget. The Wolf, well the Wolf is like the adult version of the Jenn Air. All of its burners are dual stacked 20K burners and the broiler is IR. It is over budget, and there were issues at one time with the blue porcelain interiors chipping. I don't know how those were resolved, or whether they are ongoing. These are sealed burners whereas the BS and CC are not. This one will definitely need a hood with MUA.

    I used to research this stuff until I was blue in the face, hoping to find the best option, trying to figure out which would be the best one for me. Half of the meals I've cooked in my life were in rental apartments or in friends' homes. The truth is that a great range makes life easier than a crappy one, but OK appliances are usually just fine. You don't want one that needs to be repaired often. In my case, I don't want one that will need a ventilation system with MUA.

    My sincerest advice is not to break your budget, but to find something that is reliable and close enough. You're not choosing a spouse (something I also haven't done).

  • 9 years ago

    Definitely post in the appliance forum and may I suggest you take your parents to test out induction? Much safer especially if they're getting up there in age. Plus if they do lots of simmering, it's so much better. No more burnt rice or oatmeal!

  • 9 years ago

    As usual, I'll add my recommendation for induction. As powerful, more controllable, no waste heat and very simple to keep clean. A search in the Appliance forum will give you added info. The new model of the Bosch Benchmark is one to look at. Here's a review. You can also choose a 36" cooktop with an oven below. Miele makes excellent choices.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    May I ask why you are so dead set on dual fuel?
    I had dual fuel Thermador for 27 years, and four years ago switched to an all gas Bluestar 36RNB. Other than a bit longer pre-heat time, (which is more than likely due to the cavernous oven), I do not notice any major differences in baking or roasting. Honestly, after some time, I've learned to like the gas oven over electric, but that just may be me...

    lmuhlhan84 thanked cookncarpenter
  • 9 years ago

    Get a wall oven plus a cooktop (I like induction, but the choice is yours). Bending down to get things out of the oven is a pain when you're younger--it's more than a pain later in life.

  • 9 years ago

    You'll notice that I suggested induction, no more, no less. I totally get that people like what is familiar; what they are used to. If they have really investigated all of the alternatives and want gas or induction or even electric, then fine. That's one of the best things about this forum, you get a variety of opinions I will tell you that induction was the best "surprise" of my new kitchen. I read everything here, took a giant leap of faith and am not looking back. I am thrilled with my induction vs the electric and gas appliances I used for the previous 45 years. On the other hand, I absolutely do not need the 4' aisle that everyone here seems to suggest is the bare minimum required for a kitchen to function. It's all about choices. Everyone is going to push what works for them.

  • 9 years ago

    cookncarpenter; I prefer dual fuel because of the accuracy of an electric oven w/gas burners as well as the familiarity of the duo.

    Jerry - if I were setting up my own kitchen, I would definitely consider wall ovens and a cooktop. The current set up at my parent's house is limited since they aren't interested in doing a kitchen overhaul. I'm afraid a 30" range is the style to which I must stick.

    eam44 - thank you for the good wishes. I'm not sure M&D will be switching to induction anytime soon; they are still young in their 60's and wielding around the kitchen with a full line of All-Clad cookware. Lol! :-D I really do appreciate the advice on JennAir, Wolf and whether or not an island hood is needed. I'm going to rethink the burner output to avoid the necessity of a ventilation system. That is too much of an undertaking at this point. The Jenn Air you mentioned actually has a downdraft element that's sort of been "grandfather'd" in and the swap will require absolutely no changes to the current set-up. So again, thank you!


  • 9 years ago

    I looked at some old emails. The dual fuel came in Viking, Bertazonni, Bosch, and La Cornue were some choices. A 30" American Range was right at $3k and it had two 25k BTU burners. A 30" all gas Bosch was only $1500 while the 30" duel fuel Thermador was $3700.

    This was in April and those are already gone probably.

  • 9 years ago

    I absolutely love my Kitchenaid dual fuel with double ovens range. It has 5 burners, true convection, it's in the price range, and it's beautiful.