Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_129235

Pergo - do you hate it?

9 years ago

I am debating putting Pergo in our master bedroom or possibly all the bedrooms upstairs. I always thought I would hate it, but we have it in two rooms here and I think it looks OK and doesn't feel weird to walk


pergo highland hickory

we bought our house almost a year ago. there was an unplanned bathroom remodel and some electric work to be done. In other words not a lot of money for renovations at the moment. However, there is carpet in the master bedroom and DH feels it is causing him breathing issues. the PO's or the ones before him had dogs, it traps dirt, etc and DH is allergic to dustmites, dog dander and a few other things. we have had the carpets cleaned. In a perfect world I would wait a year or two and put in hardwood floors.

This house has so many flooring types now :( Not counting the bathrooms.

  • Main Floor: site finished oak in two rooms, the pergo above in two rooms, a cream tile in the kitchen, a different cream tile in the entry, and a dark red rug.
  • the stairs have a dark green rug (which for some bizarre reason I don't mind it)
  • upstairs there is the dark green carpet in the hall and then grey 30 yr old carpet in all the bedrooms.

DH can install this and the price is obviously good. It took me awhile but I was able to track down the same pergo flooring that we have in the family room and sun room. I think at least that will be some consistency with the rest of the house.

DH wants to use something different. some other kind of engineered wood ( I think that will be twice as much) and won't start the path to standardizing the flooring in this place.

Thoughts?

Comments (20)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Well, "hate" is kind of a strong word and usually reserved for something that really strikes you hard on a personal level. So I dont "hate" it, but I really dislike it.

    However I do like the vinyl plank flooring in my mom's house - so Im not necessarily opposed to plastic per se. it has a solid look and feel to it, feels nicer underfoot, also less vulnerable to water damage.

    Boopadaboo thanked Debbie Downer
  • 9 years ago

    I'm not crazy about any product that looks like wood. The ceramic tiles I maybe could like...maybe.

    Since you have some oak, why not just use oak? We've actually patched an oak floor from the 70's with some new oak from Lumber Liquidators and you can't tell at all. You could carry on in the entry and the red carpet, rip up what's upstairs (who knows? You may be lucky and find wood underneath), have a bit of a clean and use new area rugs until next year....then when you've saved your pennies get the upstairs done....

    Do it right.

    Boopadaboo thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    If you want to do something inexpensive and fast and DIY that matches, yeah, do it.

    I think there is no reason to try to match the Pergo downstairs though. Find something you like that your DH can install instead. You should definitely get rid of the old carpet if there are allergies!

    (And no, I don't like Pergo but it has a lot of good features so I'm not gonna hate it.)

    Boopadaboo thanked Fori
  • 9 years ago

    Many people like it, but I don't like how it feels when I walk on it. I am also picky so take my opinion with a grain of salt. I wouldn't put it in my house but it doesn't mean it isn't a good choice for your situation.

    Boopadaboo thanked deegw
  • 9 years ago

    I never did, but that was years ago. It looked fake and sounded weird when walking on it with heeled shoes.

    You have it and like it. Maybe the quality has changed.

    i like the wood look ceramics and vinyls.


    Boopadaboo thanked eld6161
  • 9 years ago

    I don't think DH can DIY the Oak as easily. and then you have to sand it and finish it correct?

  • 9 years ago

    in the last house we sold we had so many negative comments about the fact that there were two kinds of flooring in the house! when we bought the house there was a different rug in every bedroom, in door outdoor carpeting in the family room, ugly tile in the powder room, kitchen and entry (all different) but the DR and LR had decent oak. I didnt want to rip that out but didnt want that everywhere so we left that and replaced all other floors in the house (up and down) with a different wood. clearly not trying to match. I can't tell you how many realtors gave us grief about it!

  • 9 years ago

    We installed ourselves, had someone come in to finish. We also had carpet, indoor outdoor carpet, 4 layers of vinyl on the kitchen area....what a mess, but so glad it's all done now!

    I have found that the best way to do something, is to just jump in and go! The carpet has to go anyway, right? Use masks and gloves and duct tape and chuck it all out a window.

    Boopadaboo thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    I wouldn't DIY a site-finished floor (the tools and mess are a big part of it), but there are some really nice prefinished wood floors that are probably only a little bit harder than Pergo to install. I bet you can get a pretty close match to the downstairs floors and nobody will be able to put them side-by-side to compare.

    It'll probably cost more, but be nicer, and in a few years, you can do the rest of the upstairs.

    Boopadaboo thanked Fori
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't mind Pergo. It was in our kitchen when we bought our house and it has been super easy to keep clean. The downside we have found is that if I drop something, like a knife or scissors, chances are good a black knick or chip will be the result. That's probably not such a risk in a bedroom, but you never know. I agree I would prefer wood, but I think if would be fine in a bedroom, especially if that's what fits your skill set and budget.

    Boopadaboo thanked Bluebell66
  • 9 years ago

    a lot to think about.

    in the last house (I know I sound like a broken record :0 ) the wood we put in the kitchen, family room, powder room, entry and all bedrooms was prefinished hardwood. maybe we picked a bad kind? It was not that cheap as I remember, but the finish rubbed off in some spots (white looking) and scratched pretty easily. Unfortunately DH is not very careful which drives me a bit nuts. All that money spent in the last house and it looked like it needed refinishing in 5 years!

    I think that is what is leading me to this pergo. it looks brand new. I wish I was in the south. :) I would do tile everywhere!

  • 9 years ago

    LOL your experience with hard wood is called "patina" and from what I have been told is part of its "charm". I know nothing of Pergo because DH insists it looks like a picture of wood--no depth. We put in vinyl plank and LOVE IT. My parents put in the wood look tile. It is cold, hard on the joints, LOUD and ANYTHING dropped on it breaks.

  • 9 years ago

    :) too funny arcy! the HW in the living room and dining room did not get this way, and the house we had before it with site finished HW flloors did not get that way either. I don't know what vinyl plank is. I will look at that. any recommendations?

  • 9 years ago

    I think it also depends on the house...it sounds all sorts of snotty, but some houses you can't put pergo in. It just brings down everything. Some you can, it elevates them.

    (Gosh we're really helping here, aren't we?)

    Boopadaboo thanked User
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We installed it in our basement. DH wanted it. We picked the most expensive kind they had and tried very hard to scratch the sample with keys. I was fine with him selecting the color and when we went to place the order we discovered they had discontinued it. Ok, so we selected another one and had it installed. Fast forward not long from then and we had some water damage due to our stupidity in the basement that flooded a large section. We had extra flooring but apparently not enough to repair. Well they discontinued that color as well and we've searched all over the country as well as had flooring companies search and can't get it. Maybe it was just a fluke that this happened twice but I'm done with Pergo. The whole thing irritates me. I also couldn't find an email address on their website when I wanted to communicate with them. They did have a phone number thankfully. I honestly also don't like how it feels to walk on it. If not real wood I think I'd rather have vinyl or carpet under my feet. Whatever you go with buy a lot of extra!!

    I think arcy's DH is correct when she says it looks like a picture of wood with no depth. It just doesn't look like real wood no matter how hard I try to convince myself. It might be the combination of that paired with how it feels under foot.

    Boopadaboo thanked User
  • 9 years ago

    If you really want hardwood you could do what I once did. I tore up the flooring and bought a very cheap, synthetic, large, flat weave rug to cover the sub-floor. The rug lasted several different rooms as flooring was replaced. Once in a while I took it outside and pressure washed it. That is done regularly with early childhood classroom rugs. I have asthma and will never live in a house with carpeting, it truly is a problem for my breathing.

    Boopadaboo thanked hcbm
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you all! I do feel for DH with his breathing Hmorton. I just feel like we wasted so much money in the last house with the flooring. we are not in an area where houses appreciate much and had bought at a bad time which didn't help either, :)

    I don't think he likes the pergo although we are still discussing it all. I don't know why, but I really am Ok with this pergo, I don't think it is me just trying to save money. to me I will like it just the same as wood and I like that it wont scratch, and in the bedrooms you hardly see any of it between the bed(s) dressers, a rug etc, so it seems like an easy decision. of course it is not just my house!

  • 9 years ago

    I had Pergo in my last house and really liked it. It was easy to clean and the dogs didn't scratch it like they did the hardwood floors in other parts of the house. In my current house, I put down Luxury Vinyl Tile were there wasn't hardwood floors. I like that too.

    Boopadaboo thanked pamghatten
  • 9 years ago

    I didn't take it that way at all Hmorton!


    I think what I really meant to say is, if DH has allergies and is having trouble breathing, I get it, totally, and if I am happy with pergo, why can't he just suck it up and put it in! :) it is one bedroom, two closets and a small bonus type room over the garage (that are all in the master) worst case in 5 years he could rip it out. it is the cost $2.25 a sq ft and his labor. just do it already!!! :p but he won't listen! so he has the allergies AND is being picky. I don't get it.



Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH