Please show the room and your two headboard choices, along with the height of each headboard. I'm assuming that the mirror is just for decor, and you don't want to see yourselves in it, since it wold likely be too high mounted above a tall headboard.

Do you have pets and/or allergies? Leather will be easier to keep clean/dust-free, but can also show claw marks. However, cats may want to use fabric upholstery as a scratching post.

I think leather would go best.

I think it will be better if you put the mirror where it can reflect light so the room will be bright.

I think leather is a great option! I agree with the other commenters though, with the tall headboard, you won't be able to have the mirror there.

I'd go fabric, something like this:

No do not have pets or allergies and the Mirror is just for decor.

I will take some pictures of the full room and will send.

Here is one of the headboard I was looking at:

http://www.pier1.com/leslie-ii-upholstered-natural-headboard/PS77342.html?cgid=headboards

or can go for something like this

http://www.pier1.com/mason-ivory-tufted-upholstered-headboard/PS44686.html?cgid=headboards#nav=top&start=1

Its approx 54"-60" inch high then thinking of having the mirror on the top for decor.

I did got a headboard, but ended up returning it as the color did not seems to go well, attaching a picture of the same.

I think that fabric would look best & as others have mentioned, the mirror could look out of place if it gets too high. Looking forward to seeing what you decide on!

What about in soft grey or blue? Depends on your bedspread and other accents though.

The contrast of both against the dark wood will look fantastic. Depends on your preference as one being leather and the other fabric. Both have texture and if it were me I like the fabric headboard with nail heads as softer lines and color. What are your other furnishings in this room? Lamps, bedding, and wall decor plus the mirror should not be placed over the bed as it will detract from your gorgeous headboard as others have mentioned.

I like your first choice the leslie. I have a similar master, we did a faux wood accent wall and a tufted beige bed. You can also do pretty mirrored night stands. Good luck.

Hi RK...

Hi Julie, Thanks for responding to my post. Looking forward to get some expert advice from you!!!!