Software
Houzz Logo Print
peter_r_green

Standing Seam or Asphault Shingle

9 years ago

Wifey and I are building a home in Northern California and we are having discussions on roof material.. she likes the look of standing seam because it will go well with the style of our home. Our house will be an off white (grayish brown) stucco finish with wood beams post. Given the added cost with metal, I like asphalt shingles. I also feel the metal can look a little too harsh, trendy and in our climate, does it add much benefit? Looking to save money where we can but this is our forever house.. Appreciate any insight In making this decision. Thanks.


Comments (30)

  • 9 years ago

    We have a standing seam metal roof and love it. It's beautiful, durable, and longer-lasting than other materials, including asphalt shingles. We live in the middle of a forest, and we get a reduction in our homeowner's insurance because the metal roof is so fire resistant. We have solar panels, and with a standing seam roof they can just be attached with special clips to the seam, so there's no need to penetrate the roof at all, reducing the risk of problems and maintaining our roof warranty.

  • 9 years ago

    Hi Kristin. I had not heard about the insurance benefit or ease of solar panel connection. Good to know. Thanks.

  • 9 years ago

    A forever home needs a forever roof. That's proper standing seam. Not just a generic "metal roof" that is screwed down through the peaks.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Standing seam metal will be much more expensive than a 40 or 50 year asphalt shingle with a class A fire rating. It will not be the roof that catches fire.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Hard to beat a standing seam roof for looks and durability. Maybe save some money on the granite counter tops? :-)

  • 9 years ago

    Another vote for standing seam metal roofs. The insurance benefit is huge and that means a lot in my area of S Fl. But the durability and the maintenance-free aspect is also a big factor. https://www.houzz.com/magazine/materials-the-advantages-of-a-metal-roof-stsetivw-vs~560023

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    What about a 5v crimp metal roof? That's what we're doing and what a lot of the homes in FL have and they are somewhat less expensive than standing seam.

    The other benefits to a metal roof are with passive solar cooling.

    However if I were still a year or more away from building I'd use Tesla's solar panel tiles.

  • 9 years ago

    I don't want to derail the thread, but I'd love others thoughts on the Tesla Solar Tiles. If they live up to the hype it seems they'd be perfect for us, but we are worried they're too good to be true. One catch I suppose is Tesla is notoriously bad at meeting production dates, so who knows when they'll actually be available. We also wonder about the glass tiles - if they were really such a good roof option and less expensive, why aren't they already in common use? And finally, do you think Tesla's cost info they've been promoting will be accurate?

  • 9 years ago

    CP- I'm hoping Tesla releases standing seam solar!! I emailed them asking if they would be doing something like this. Never heard anything back.

    Im very interested in the Tesla product!!

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Don't get me wrong. I think a metal roof on this house would look great.

    In Colorado I talk my clients out of them. Google "killed by falling snow" for a few examples of the seriousness of the safety concern. A foot of snow on a roof can weigh tons. We often have several feet of snow on the roof. When it hits the ground it's like concrete. When this amount of snow hits a person the results are often fatal. With current design trends calling for more and more access to the outdoors it's almost impossible to design a home that sheds snow away from all walkways and doors.

    I know this is probably not your situation. These comments are for folks in snow country considering a metal roof.

  • 9 years ago

    Great comments everybody. Thank you.... The Tesla roof looks awesome. But, I'm assuming it'll probably be a few years until they get the kinks out and the production costs down.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    ^^^ Yeah they're probably a while from getting the kinks out, which is why I said if I were building in another year or two.

    I would definitely go with a metal roof over asphalt.

  • 9 years ago

    ditto on the standing seam roof. Never heard of how they attach solar, that's great!

  • 9 years ago

    Do make sure SURE they put the 'snow bumpers' on the eaves of your house, cause if you get ice on that metal, and it starts to melt, it comes off like crystal breaking in a china cabinet,...it can kill or injure anyone or thing. Never noticed such a dilemna with asphalt shingles, it melts and comes off as water. Not the metal ss roof! ALSO, if you have alot of trees overhanging your roof, we note alot of "sap' damage to the pretty metal roofs from trees in the spring and fall and all thru their green months. If you choose a showey roof color, make certain your trees are beside your home when fully grown, not over the roof. You will cry when you see it turning ugly black. Also, in our area, the metal has advantages such as fire resistant, but the property insurance reps claim they will NOT pay for cosmetic damage to a metal roof(such as small hail stones, or larger)unless of course HOLES are punched into the surface. So be aware of that, if hail is something you deal with very often, and perhaps you do not. It wreks havoc on the ridges and it can make the pretty paint color deteriate to a rusty state sooner in it's life time. So your home metal roof can deteriate as it ages, but the insurance company is likely not going to pay you for it. You may want to keep your paint finish wty so you can talk to the manufacturer if you want financial compensation.


  • 9 years ago

    Have you considered rainwater collection? If so, metal...


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    If this is your forever home, you might as well put a forever roof on it. The standing seam roof will outlive you; Asphalt will not (we hope). And standing seam is the coolest looking roof.

    A side benefit: I remember as a child lying in bed in our vacation house in the Adirondacks (the 'camp'--a 2-story log cabin). The bedroom ceilings were the actual underside of the roof--hand-hewn boards spanning the tree-trunk beams. In the mornings we could hear the squirrels and chipminks scampering from the overhanging limbs and onto the roof. And every once in a while we'd hear the frantic rapid scritching of their little claws as they lost purchase on the fairly steep, smooth metal surface and slid down and off the roof. There were no gutters. They never seemed to be harmed; They landed in lots of pine needles that covered the ground. Great fun. For us.

  • 9 years ago

    I can attest to 'Red Silvers' comment. In Wyoming I wanted to replace my shake roof with metal. As my house was 6" poured concrete 'frame'. I thought it would help lower insurance cost- wrong- they said due to hail damage they would not insure it, even with a rider policy. I am now in Florida with a beautiful metal roof- with a concrete framed house. And get a better insurance rate due to less fire risk.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I have a "z" lock standing seam metal roof and love it. I live in Kansas and we do get some snow. As far as insurance goes, sometimes an agent may tell you one thing that is not the policy of the actual insurance company. Covering the roof for hail, well hail does not affect the integrity of the roof, simple cosmetics, that's why we chose it. However, snow and ice are issues and they can push the bumpers right over. We have most of the roof sloping away (also for cosmetic reasons) from the front of the house, and we have large steel beams and steel grates to catch the rest in the front (as well as the slope over rear facing basement door) Snow and ice are dangerous and it can come off it huge icy chunks, it does sound like someone has hit a gong when the snow hits those grates. The cosmetics are minimal depending on what color metal you choose, the darker the roof the more they show. These roofs are thick and take a really big impact before they dimple. This roof will be here long after I'm gone.


  • 9 years ago

    ^^ Your house is funky! But we really can't see your roof! ^^

  • 9 years ago

    Just bought a house with a standing seam metal roof. My new to me home has the screw down metal panels. Under no circumstance should you use this type of metal roofing material on a residential roof. It's meant for barns and out buildings, not homes. The screws will work their way out as the heat expands and contracts the metal. It's the cheaper type of metal roofing. Don't use it. Use the G-seam metal roofing. We are going to spend the next 20 years changing out and tightening metal screws. If it's worth doing, it's worth doing it right the first time. I'd like to kill whoever made the decision to use this type of roofing material.

  • 9 years ago

    It's a budget decision. Sure, standing seam will last 'forever'. Shingles provide good service for a long time, if you buy quality and hire a quality roofer. If you really will not move and depending on your age, you may replace a shingle roof what? - once, twice, not at all?

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Standing seam has become a generic background like the stone countertop. If you want your house to be noticeable use millennium roof tiles. Otherwise you can't beat the value of asphalt.

  • 9 years ago

    We thought about it long and hard, and while I generally opt for the long lasting solution when the prices came in it turned out we could re-roof twice (three times total) for the price of the standing seam. If you figure out the lost opportunity cost of that extra money over the next 50 years, standing seam starts to look very expensive indeed. We went with nice, but boring, asphalt shingles.

    If I were to spend that kind of money on a roof I think I'd go with slate, it would only be twice the price of metal but would look orders of magnitude better and also be good for well over 100 years.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    You are exactly right that you really can't see the roof, and that's by design. Roof slopes away from public spaces and eyesight from the street. That way I didn't have to worry about snow or any cosmetic blemishes from hail. We have a very low pitched roof, 1:12 and 1/2:12, so in my case standard asphalt shingles are not an option. I designed and built the house for low -no maintenance, the area I live in requires lifetime roofs of tile, slate, etc. This was my best option.

  • 9 years ago

    I fully understand that, as I also have a standing seam, low pitched roof and build a low maintenance house. So same design constraints. I used standing seam, thermally isolated, insulated panels, and I am not sure hail would even dent it, but - also like you, my roof can't be seen. (but I can still share a picture... LOL!)

    Roof in progress with protective plastic still on.


  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Are those precast walls?

  • 9 years ago

    Yes! Thermally isolated sandwich panels.

  • 9 years ago

    There is a metal roof with EXPOSED screws to the outside world. I don't think it is called 'standing seam'. I thought it was called R panel and than there is 'barn tin' which is ~ across the top. R Panel is a 'pseudo standing seam'...and if you had to buy a house like that, you will never be able to keep up with the polywashers that deteriate in the UV sun within 5 years of installation! You would likely be better off, carefully removing the panels, installing new roof deck and perhaps that radiant barrier?..which has it's own issues...and than, either go back with asphalt shingles or the true Standing Seam as janni seems to have pictured, or tile, or slate or even other various options.. I agree, it should be against the law for anyone to install R panel metal roofs on a house. They are okay on a barn, if you don't mind the drips of rain water here and there on the contents, but NOT on a house. It is a wood structure and you will have stained sheetrock ceilings that are no where close to where the water has come in by the time it's molecules cling and drift down till they are so heavy, the drop. If you do remove your roof, you might find someone who needs to construct a shelter, or desires some for interior decor, to take it off your hands and get some money out of the pieces that are fit. There are alot of artistic and imaginative folks in the world, I bet someone would have a way to use the metal, even if it included large animal shelter or hay storage...

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    True story. @jannicone you should post your house project. It looks obscure.