Software
Houzz Logo Print
martha205

Cut native perennials down for siding work?

9 years ago

I'm having my siding torn off and replaced with new siding and gutters. In the foundation planting in the front of the house I've got a native perennial garden thriving. Normally, I would leave them up all winter for the insects and for winter interest. I'm considering cutting them all down to about 6 inches so the siding crew can put a tarp over them before they start. I'm very concerned about them surviving this treatment. Has anyone had this situation, any opinions?

Comments (18)

  • 9 years ago

    im tossing a coin over leaving them at height and letting the guys ramble thru them ...


    or cutting them down... so they can squish the heck out of them ... how messy do they expect to be ... what kind of siding is being removed???


    either way .... the Brits call it healing in a plant ... and i doubt you will have any long term damage to a vast majority of the plants ...


    your timing of the project is spot on .. in the sense.. it might have been very ugly if you had it done in june or july ... for all practical purposes.. the season is over ...


    ken

    Martha thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    my thoughts exactly on tossing the coin. All the cedar siding on a one story ranch is being torn off, Tyvek and then new siding going up. A lot of work, rambling and squishing in my second year of prairie dropseed, switchgrass, shining coneflower, agastache, butterfly weed, amsonia, guara lindheimeri, etc. All thriving. I believe they will survive, I just hate to cut them down. Originally, my thought was to transplant them temporarily to another place in the garden, but preparing the soil in new areas and doing all that digging changed my mind. I think I'll go halfway and cut them to about 9 to 10 inches. The great blue lobelia toppled over this summer, so I'm going to move that one for sure.

  • 9 years ago

    Don't underestimate the power of determined repetitive tromping...I hope they all survive it. I could see crown budders like agastache, amsonia, and gaura in your list, having possible issues, with all the incipient terminal buds being tromped into mush.

    I think I support the idea of not cutting back and laying a tarp (or 2) over them for "insulation".

    Martha thanked dbarron
  • 9 years ago

    You might also want to have a chat with your worker(s) that the plants are important to you, and within reason do what they can to avoid excessive damage.

  • 9 years ago

    a pic might help ....


    so much for my speel checker this morning [lol] ...... im going to have to have a talk with him ...


    refresh my memory.. what is it called.. when you grind your heel into the crown of a plant.. to force more divisions ... i read about it.. in a Brit hosta book ... what was her name... diana grenfell????


    ken

  • 9 years ago

    Never heard of that, Ken. No idea what its called.

  • 9 years ago

    And I would have to say that it doesn't sound like a very efficient or successful way to encourage divisions :-) Stomping on plants IMO is never a good thing!

  • 9 years ago

    Yes Ken, Diana Grenfell, and she was referring to Hostas only in her book but it could translate to other plants too I imagine. I just read the passage and she does not put a name to it. It is done very early season as the shoots are emerging.

    She goes on to say mowing the foliage twice in a season down to 3/16 to 3/8 of an inch is an even more reliable way of promoting growth.

    I have not done it but the trampling could happen if I lost my footing.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Noooo- nothing to do with dividing...but a lot to do with extreme pruning, to encourage growth...like tillering in grass...or pinching out in new growth. We also do a thing called stooling...where the crown of a (woody) plant is covered in a layer of soil, encouraging surface rootgrowth which can then be split with a spade. Cotinus, daphia and (some) hebes are receptive to this treatment.

  • 9 years ago

    if the workers repeatedly have to walk in the perennial space it could be helpfull to put down a layer of coarse mulch (wood chips, bark...) about 2-3 inches thick

    that could help to spread the weight and reduce fatal damage to basal rosettes or buds.

    no idea what size the border is you are talking about.

    and even if you mulch perhaps it would add another protective layer if you let the long stalk on the plants so that they lay flat under the mulch.

    just a tarp might be too little protection

  • 9 years ago

    When I had siding work done, I put big plastic nursery pots or planters over stuff I wanted to make sure didn't get trampled or broken. Assuming your plants aren't growing right next to the house, can you fashion some type of barricade to keep them from trampling the area (i.e. barricade off the area but leave them a walking path to work on); you can then throw a big tarp over the whole area. If you've planted right next to the house, that's a topic for another day...

  • 9 years ago

    Maybe do the bucket/pots over the specific plants you want to stay save...and then just get some free pallets (posted on craigs list or may company's try and get rid of them)... and lay them over the beds you know are going to be trafficed areas..... then it all gets cover in tarp. That would spread out all the weight.

  • 9 years ago
    There is about 3 feet between the house and plants. A few pots will help with the coreopsis. Also, the wood mulch is a good idea, I'll do that. I think I'm going to transplant the shining coneflower to another spot for the winter. Not sure about the butterfly weed; it did so well this year and it has a long taproot. THX for the suggestions.
  • 9 years ago
    A few more photos:
  • 9 years ago

    Martha, your garden is lovely. I'm glad you waited until fall to replace the siding. My home will need a new roof in the near future and I'm dreading the damage to my foundation plantings. Like you, I'll try to do it in October when things are already winding down.

    Martha thanked cecily
  • 9 years ago

    have you asked the contractor what his preference is??? .. perhaps he has dealt with this before ...


    do keep us posted on how it all works out ...


    it is basically late in the season ... and even if they damage the upper parts ... they werent going to hang around intact for winter for the most part ...


    just get the job done.. plus.. the old farmer lament.. there is always next year ...


    and you note.. there is 3 feet from the house to the plants .. bazinga.. someone who left space at the foundation for house maintenance .....like we havent mentioned that a couple hundred times over the years ... sounds to me.. like you were planning this all along ...


    ken

  • 9 years ago
    Ken - I did ask the contractor and he said his crew was careful around the plants. I feel like I want to give them as much space as possible as they are not only installing siding but gutters as well. Never had gutters and I'm so excited I can be done with the 6 inch space where the rain fell off the overhangs and made it difficult to plant there. I do really like the space so I can easily wash the windows. Will post after photos.