I have unusual tastes so I never give advice on combos for it is a very personal thing. However, I will give form advice and I strongly advise not to use any natural stone on a shower floor when there are so many great looking and functioning porcelain tiles available. Stone is a roll of the dice in how it functions, wears and looks after use.

Oh wow, I do agree that bath needs a redo ;0) Although a little better maintenance by the formers users might have saved it, not made it so urgent.

I can't advise you on colors not knowing you, my own taste runs to light, bright, and most of all for baths - easy to keep very clean. Please rethink your travertine shower floor, or at least research further so you know what to expect from it after actual use.

I appreciate the feedback. I will definitely take the advice and stay away from the travertine floor and check around for something else that looks like travertine possibly.

We haven't had any plans for a sink yet, thinking maybe a darker wood cabinet (something smaller to fit) and probably just choose a counter top to go with everything else.

I think the 12x24 tile would be too big for a shower in that size of a room but then again I can't even decide on anything since I can't see it lol. I also wasn't sure how I felt about a 12x12 tile but shown in that picture it looks nice with the diamond pattern. I wasn't sure about the 3 different styles and agree its very tough to coordinate, another reason why I'm having so much trouble.

This is a lot more tough than I thought it would be

Stay away from travertine in a wet area period. Walls or floors. Large tile that looks like travertine in a 32 x 60 shower no problem.

I agree with the above comments about staying away from natural stone. There are many great looking porcelains these days that can mimic that look if you like it. I would go somewhere else other the The Tile Shop to shop. At least in my area, the Tile Shop has a lot of natural stone products, not so much in porcelain. And they usually don't have different formats or trim pieces available for their porcelains which makes coordinating difficult. Best Tile is a better option if there are any near you. Or locally owned places. They can help you find a qualified contractor too.

Another suggestion would be to look at the Houzz photos to get an idea of what style appeals to you, and take those photos to the store with you.

Here are all the pics posted in the links above.

Here is a picture of the old nasty bathroom we plan to remodel

This is the tile that we ordered recently for the floor, looks a little different in person maybe a little lighter.

this tile was shown to us by the sales person at the tile shop also for the shower wall

this was the shower floor (looks lighter online)

also the accents

I agree; no travertine. Look for a porcelain tile. Its a small space so you don't want too many competing elements. Either one tile for both, the wall and floor. Alternatively, a slightly darker one for the floor can work, and you can continue it up the wall opposite the door too. Get one tile for the floor, (shower and the rest off the bathroom) not two.

Also, with these dimensions, a closed shower is better. You could incorporate a seat as well.

Here's an idea. You'd have to check out the dimensions around the toilet though

Shower seat for 800mm, 100mm of a higher ledge for toiletries. Then continue this ledge outside the shower, have a wall hung toilet against it, and a vessel sink above

This is a lot more tough than I thought it would be.

So true! With my kitchen remodel, choosing materials wasn't too difficult, but we are on our third serious attempt at trying to remodel our master bath. We haven't been able to coordinate the floor and countertop because of limited choices so we moved on to other projects. Fortunately I've learned a lot from thinking about bathrooms for three years.

If you want to limit your materials, you could do a Kohler cast iron shower pan. Gardenwebbers who have them love them. They come 60" x 30" and also 32" and 34". They look nice with tiled walls, and it would give you more options for using a patterned tile on the shower walls because you won't have to coordinate the shower floor tile with the shower wall. You'd just need to work with the travertine floor and the shower wall and a possible accent tile.

Here's a web photo of the Kohler Bellweather cast iron pan with 12" square tiles.

I didn't find a great representative Houzz photo of the Kohler pans,
but I did come across this photo to show you how a touch of a dark
color looks very nice on white tile. If your shower walls are white tile, I would do a chocolate brown accent to bring the color of the travertine floor up to the white. This shower has a white Kohler shower pan. You can see it by clicking on the photo and looking at other views of this bathroom. You could still use a brown accent tile on the walls if you tile your shower floor in a brown mosaic. I'm recommending you bring the brown into the shower in whatever way possible--floor, wall tile, or accent.