Software
Houzz Logo Print
sawyer212

Help With Cabinets

9 years ago

I need some cabinet advice...I have met with 3 local kitchen designers about my layout and different options. Two of the designers I really like...the other one I like, and I have a history with, but she doesn't seem to offer as much advice besides the basics and I feel like I'm kind of on my own to decide what I want/don't want and present it to her/ask if it is available. The others seem to present more options upfront and seem a bit more pleasant to work with. However, she did my last kitchen and it came out beautifully, so I know I could still have a beautiful end result if I choose to go with her.


Between the 3 designers, these are the following cabinet brands we have discussed:


Omega

Brookhaven

Kemper

Decora

Medallion

Tedd Wood

Design Craft

Holiday

Kraftmaid Vintage


I have read through the boards, searched for each specific brand, but a lot of the threads are pretty old and it is hard to wade through all of the information.


So my questions are--do you have any personal experience with any of these brands? Are some known to be much higher quality than the others? Are there any you would suggest I stay away from?


I do realize that there will be a price differential between the brands, although at this point I'm not sure how significant it will be (goes to my not knowing how the brands are "ranked" with respect to quality, for lack of a better term). Perhaps that will be a deciding factor eventually, but right now I'm trying to get an idea of what we are dealing with quality-wise and if there are some I should immediately eliminate (or alternatively, move to the top of the list!). Basically, I'm trying to narrow down my choices...


I should also note--we are looking for a white shaker type cabinet with a gray wash island, and all brands seem to offer that, so that isn't really a concern of mine.


Anyway, would love some insight. Thanks in advance!

Comments (10)

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I bought Shiloh (wanted inset), but Medallion was my 2nd choice.

  • 9 years ago

    Brookhaven is very good quality but not the cheapest, I would say mid priced. Very satisfied with ours.

  • 9 years ago

    We have Medallion in the house we bought and they have held up well for their age. They are also one of the least expensive in the "mid line" group we have quoted so far. Omega is, I believe, full custom and much higher price point, but I hear good things about them on here. Dynasty is the semi custom line from Omega, I believe still higher than Medallion but would be less than Omega. I believe Kraftmaid is probably close to Medallion price wise, I haven't gotten a quote yet. That's about the most I can help with.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I have Schuler, aka, Medallion. Difference is that Schuler is from Lowe’s. I have a white shaker style called Sugar Creek. It was much less price then the other shaker style. Sorry, I forget the name, but I want to say Manhattan. I’m not sure if they are called by different style names in Medallion. Same product though. I’m happy with the brand because is semi-custom.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    I have Shiloh, too. I also wanted inset and Shiloh does NOT charge extra for that - BIG savings.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for the comments everyone. So Medallion seems like a common brand and a good company to try. Based on your responses, I'm guessing Omega will be pretty expensive and Brookhaven was too (the quote I got on Brookhaven was about $22k more for the same kitchen in Holiday, but I haven't priced the others yet).

    I haven't come across anyone selling Shiloh, but I will look into it...

  • 9 years ago

    Bumping to see if anyone has any info on Tedd?

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    The brands you posted many of them belong to the same "Umbrella Co." called...Masterbrand. We carry teddwood. They used to be only custom but have since split into three brands....landmark is their version of semi custom. They will customize some cabinets.....Then you have their Luxury....frameless line modern...then their usual you think it they make it custom...they are a great brand. All of the brands you have posted are tried and true companies that you should be happy with the result. Just depends on your budget and design of the door.

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you Filipe--I appreciate your insight!

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH