Software
Houzz Logo Print
a_leclaire

Thoughts on through-the-wall AC?

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

My contractor has suggested through-the-wall ACs, rather than central air, to save me money. House is a small ranch, about 1000 sq ft. (24 x 48 exterior). There would be one AC for the entire living area, one in each bedroom. It's the living area that most concerns me as there is only one possible wall space (lots of windows) and it's at the farthest end of an ell off the LR. A partial center support wall separates the LR/dining area + ell on one side from the hall, kitchen, small laundry/utility room on the other side, with the bathroom farthest away from the ell at the end of the hall. There are open areas at each end of the center wall, 12' at the end closest to the AC (but around a corner), into an entry/closet/hall area next to the kitchen, and about 5' at the other end. There is also a small "window" in the wall between the hall/kitchen and LR. The LR is about 26' long; the ell is an additional 8'.

I wonder if adequate cooled air would circulate to the kitchen/bath side - ? Also whether the ell/office area would have to be frigid to keep the temp down in other areas (I spend a lot of time there) - ? Also whether even with proper installation, they are drafty - ? I live in northernmost NYS.

Thanks, Ann

Comments (27)

  • 8 years ago

    Is this an existing house or a new build? If you are retrofitting an old house, do you have a basement or attic in which to run duct work?

    Ann thanked latifolia
  • 8 years ago

    Do you currently have central ac? If so I wouldn't change it...I personally wouldn't buy a house with wall units

    Ann thanked Elizabeth B
  • 8 years ago

    It's difficult to give good information without inspecting the house in person but here's a couple of one size fit's all ansewers. Wherter through the wall is your best solution depend's on how well your contractor understand's hvac. As far as moving air around corners and/or to other areas,it's easy to do with small fans you buy at Wal-Mart.

    Ann thanked klem1
  • 8 years ago

    I would also never buy a home with air conditioners in the wall.

    Ann thanked grapefruit1_ar
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Not a new build - renovating damaged home - no basement - currently no ac.

    14 year old gas furnace in attic, but ducting is incomplete and incorrect for heating, so it would be a lot of work to finish for that purpose (new return runs in walls throughout, for example). Contractor said it would be cheaper to go with electric heat, which is about the same cost as gas to operate here (municipal electric).

    AC is impt to me, both for health and comfort. I did plan on central air... there would still be some work to do on installation, but both supply and return registers are already in the ceiling, fine for cooling. On the other hand, this is a very rural, dying mill town - major industries have left/are leaving, along with chain stores. Home values are in the sink and highly unlikely to improve.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Had it one place I lived and was surprised how effective it was. It was in the DR and cooled that room, the kitchen, living room, bath, and bedroom.

    Ann thanked mdln
  • 8 years ago

    People were using through the wall ac units before central was even available and many still use them. If there was no demand,there would be no supply,sometimes you have to do what you have to do. I've had a window unit in an annex of my home for years and I'm an hvac pro. If it didn't do the job I would install something different.

    Ann thanked klem1
  • 8 years ago

    The success of using thru the wall air conditioners depends on air flow. I have a 2 story cape style house . The first floor has a central stairway to to the second floor, a front to back living room with passage ways at the front to the dining room and a return page way to the living room at the back of th reoom which creates a circular circulation patter.n I have the Thur the wall AC positioned so that the air flow is directed to the front passage which sets up the circulation . The kitchen , den and bathroom which ar not in the direct circulation stay comfortable, only a really hot day I use a simple box fan at slow speed to increase the circulation. Is this ideal now. But it works . Ideally I would install a mini split system. But 12000 BTU thru the wall,ac keeps the 1000 sqft 1rst of my Connecticut home quite comfortable,

    Ann thanked jimct01
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    For such a small home, I think it really comes down to what you want to spend. Through the wall AC's can't compete with central air because of noise in the room in which you run it. More modern thru the wall units may be a bit quieter than years past. The other less obvious is drafts around the opening in which they sit.

    Thru the wall are spot dependent when it comes to cooling and or heating they provide in weather extremes. So during heat waves or extreme cold the 'spot heating or cooling they provide will be diminished.

    Certainly using spot fans to move air around and circulate it can do the trick. Some people don't like being in what is commonly referred to as 'a wind tunnel'.

    Given that the structure is so small, it's a toss up... comes down to what you can live with and what you want to spend. Cost wise no one will compete with them because they are more or less a window unit in a bigger form factor.

    The more thru the wall units you buy the more you will have to replace at some point. You will replace them, because it's unlikely you will find anyone willing to work on them to repair them. The manufacturer's of these units don't cater to repairs. They are designed to be replaced when they fail. Models and sizes change often which can lead to construction projects having to change the opening.

    Because many AC contractors will not work on them, the manufacturer's realize this and in many cases design them to fail by making it hard for the average person to keep them clean and by using plastic parts that are prone to breaking and or cracking. If you've ever taken one apart recently they typically make the air supply route into an out of the unit out of Styrofoam. This is directly under the housing of the unit.

    Given your climate the units may last a decade or so with minimal fuss. In a climate like mine, far less.

    Ann thanked Austin Air Companie
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Even in norther NY........ the electicity bill over a few years with even a couple hot summers, will be more than the April Air central air.!!! Bad investment, and ugly to boot if you can do otherwise. Not to mention the darn things are often very difficult to replace when the compressor dies and it WILL DIE. A decent GE through the wall is 600.00 bucks or more,..........that's one 12,000 BTU, and any less is a total waste.. Plus the sleeve, cut of the wall.......nope. Wouldn't do it. Properly installed there are NO drafts, and the exteriors of the unit should be covered in winter months anyway. Even then....nope.

    Ann thanked JAN MOYER
  • 8 years ago

    Have you just tried to live with window units?

    Are you the one doing the hole in the wall? My one concern with these for you is that there will be a decent amount of heat loss in the winter even with covers. A window unit can just be removed.

    Funny how someone would be worried about your a/c bill given where you live and how you plan to heat the house. And with no knowledge of your solar gain, not sure how they can have issues with your BTU's.

    Window unit is my vote given your climate and financial constraints. Minisplits something else to consider - perhaps a single one in the main area. Pay off in heating and cooling seasons.

    Ann thanked David Cary
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you so much for the input/discussion/ideas offered above. You've mentioned points I hadn't considered about both options as well as another option. I'm grateful for the range of opinions and perspectives offered, and for the benefit of others' experience and knowledge.

    I'm sorry I neglected to mention that window units are not possible. The LR and ell have a bank of small (34 x 36?) single hung windows high on the wall (no view - for light, air, privacy). Bedrooms each have one wide 3-pane awning + one casement for egress.

  • 8 years ago

    By northernmost New York, do you mean the Adirondacks? We had a summer place up there between Lake Placid and Crown Point and never had air. If that's where you are, cooling needs should be minimal.

    If you're rehabbing the house, why don't you just reframe and replace a couple of windows so that A/C units will fit?

    If you do go with through-wall, get Friedrich units. They last forever, and when you have to replace one, the standard sizing means that you'll be able to get an exact fit. It's virtually all you see in New York City.

    Ann thanked tatts
  • 8 years ago

    tatts: Not the Adirondacks, directly across from Cornwall, Canada. Cooling is needed in the hottest months. Thank you for the advice on Friedrich!

  • 8 years ago

    In your situation, If I had hydronic heat it would be a no brainer to keep that and use inexpensive through the wall or more costly mini-splits to cool. I've looked at ranches, albeit larger, in NYS with an eye to adding mini-splits to hydronic and some would be easy to do with a combination of high wall units, and minimally-ducted units to serve 3 or 4 rooms. The latter can be done via furr downs and with the small AHUs in furr downs or grabbing the upper reaches of basement stairwells that are typically surrounded by the kitchen, living and dining rooms.

    If you are going to have ducting, I'd just go ahead and use it for cooling. It is not clear to me, however, what kind of electric you are proposing, baseboard, under the floor, furnace,...?

    Keep in mind two things if you are rebuilding to a high standard of insulation and air sealing. High efficiency equipment becomes less important with every upgrade in your home's envelope. Second, you keep better temperature uniformity between rooms as heat and moisture transfer through the envelope slows due to better construction. Transfer through partition walls and through open space is going to have a much higher rate than inside-outside if you emphasize the envelope.

    Ann thanked ionized_gw
  • 8 years ago

    I agree with Weil Friedman Architects. Sounds like your house is a perfect situation for the split duct systems.

    Ann thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    Do not know if you decided yet. From cost wide and past experience zi definstely would do mini split system. There is NOT any reson for expensive indtallation. IMO some hvacs cannot adapt to learning. "My daddy did this for 80 years".....

    Just like some farriers think they should still shoe a horse the way it was done 50 yesrs ago. NOT....

    MITSUBISHI makes a specific series for diy- Mr Cool. Multiple btu sizes. These can provide air and hest, decreasing your expenses of having a different dystem for heat. I have used diffrrent systems as I had a C9dy Wyoming home and south Texas home later on when it became more difficult for me to stay in the cold after an injury. Northern heating= NOTHING beats a good EPA rated woodstove- gets the heat deep into yer bones! No ac needed up there. Texas- mini split- has both ac/heat. Extremely quiet and efficiant. Can run just the dehumodifier if you want. Monthly electric costs significantly lower than old system. You can have rooms set at different temperatures. Or some rooms off entirely. I would never do a thru the wall. My neighbor has one and it is so loud you can barely talk. Good luck.

    Ann thanked Ed(Edwina) and Stephen Ci
  • 8 years ago

    Ed and Stephen: I am glad to receive your comments. I thought the cost of mini-splits ruled them out for me. Contractor was pressing, so I decided to try a couple window or portable acs in the large LR this next summer and see if my ceiling fans (2 LR, 1 each BR) would circulate sufficient cooled air to the two bedrooms, bath and K in this small house. Of course, the mini-splits would be nicer.

    Question for you: Would mini-splits require going into the walls again, rewiring? If so, is this a big job?


  • 8 years ago

    "Would mini-splits require going into the walls again, rewiring? If so, is this a big job?" Probably yes ,but it depend's on (A) Voltage of before and after (B) Amp capacity of before and amp requirement of after (C) If cassette is located at or near same place old unit was. Then you should be informed MS require's two differet circuits.

    Now here's a question for you: If I buy a car to commute to work,can the same car later be used in a car pool?

    Ann thanked klem1
  • 8 years ago

    Efi here Klem1 stated it well. If you use a cassette in the ceiling it would depend on if you have access to rafter. If using the wall head you do not need to go any further than the outside walls. The hole addess is only 3 inches. The most important part is the electric power being correct. Our main box happens to be within 1 foot of the MS and there was extra 'space' for adding other items. As I mentioned Mitsubishi units made for 'diy'- in my opinion that is still not a job for the accountant hubby, but for someone who does have electric knowledge. If hiring a licensed elect. it should not take long- the Mitsubishi at other house took about 3-4 hours. I do say I prefer the Mitsubishi over the current Fusitshu(sp). Mit seemed to respond quicker- but maybe that is just in my mind- if compared side by side maybe they would respond the same.

    Ann thanked Ed(Edwina) and Stephen Ci
  • 8 years ago

    "Northern heating= NOTHING beats a good EPA rated woodstove- gets the heat deep into yer bones! "

    That would be the feeling of predominantly radiant heat. Some people love it. Hot on one side and cool on the other, like a toasting marshmallow :-) A radiant electric heater will do essentially the same thing.

  • 8 years ago

    Klem, A mini split requires two circuits? How do you mean? You only need one circuit to the outdoor unit and then power from that to the indoor unit. That is two cable runs, but not two circuits. If you mean spaces for two breakers in the panels, sure, for a 230/240V circuit. If the existing panel can support window or through the wall units, they will support mini splits. If more space is needed for additional circuits in the panel, a sub panel can be added. The power requirements of the mini splits will be lower than for window or through the wall units. In fact, the start up current is less for the former if they are the most common, inverter types. That makes them easier to run on back up gensets as well. (I see virtually no start up surge in mine.)

    Ann thanked ionized_gw
  • 8 years ago

    "...they would decrease the value of any home...."

    Strikes me as, sort of, a first world problem. By that I mean that value of what someone might call a fishing camp or cabin or a rustic beach house of the type that is going extinct (think outdoor shower, and sand on the floors) is going to be little affected by window or through the wall units. A highly appointed, 10-bedroom (each with its own bath) country villa, will look sad with window units.

    Ann thanked ionized_gw
  • 8 years ago

    Window units are getting better all the time with respect to their ability to keep humidity low (when properly sized), noise, and efficiency. They have the ability to throttle back your cooling capacity by turning on some of them rather than all of them further extending good humidity control. I suspect that through the wall units are similarly developing.

    Ann thanked ionized_gw
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Your house may be small enough for only one mini-split system to be required, depending on layout and room orientation. Perhaps ceiling fans in the bedrooms could provide enough cooling there unless they are south facing. In any event, mini-split(s) are quiet and unobtrusive and will ADD to the value of your home, not detract.

    Ann thanked RappArchitecture
  • 8 years ago

    Sincere thanks for all the additional input. There was no unit previously, so nothing in place to work from.