The HD Artistic Weaver and the Overstock rug I believe are the same. The Home Decorators aristocrat according to the specs is thinner.

I bought that same rug from Overstock a couple of years ago for my son's bedroom and it's very nice. He has since taken it with him to his new home and is using it in his living room and is very happy with it.

This is truly amazing and why I spend hours browsing the web when I am shopping for something. I am having a similar time with Wayfair/Joss and Main/BirchLane which are all related. I do find sometimes one has a promo and or free shipping but all in all, it's just amazing the disparity in pricing for the same item.

I scrutinized the descriptions and see where the overstock seems slightly different but it's to the point where I suspect it' still might be the same item.

I believe Home Depot/ home decorators are related.

I would try ordering the two first pics from Home Depot. Delivery free to store and then when it is ready for pick up I would open both in store and compare them .return the one you don’t want.

Oh wait. Well since I uploaded these photos it might not be the exact rug but the one I put on my wish list a few years and a friend purchased for me as a gift looked like those online photos color wise. Mine was from Overstock. I thought I was getting a rust red rug. I said thank you but I would have returned it if it wouldn't have been a gift. I was very disappointed in the red color because it leans much more rose/pink than a rust red. I couldn't believe it. I also don't care for the blue. I would get a small size first for sure to check it out.

And you can see how the rose color isn't even across the rug. If I vacuum it all the one direction it looks better but that also drove me nuts on this rug. It's a 2'x3'. I do realize the smaller you go in a rug like this sometimes the detail can get lost.

The Collection on the back of mine says Caesar. I received mine two or three years ago. There weren't any useful reviews at the time with mention or color or additional photos.

Kitch4me, you're right. The Aristocrat is thinner.

Overnight the HD Artistic Weavers rug increased a couple hundred bucks.

Still have the Overstock rug in my cart.

Shee, that does look similar.

Overstock has coupons and participates in ebates -- and their prices fluctuate too. It does pay to shop around. I was looking for a 2x3 for my powder room and spotted a small wool rug I suspect was priced in error at around $250. I found it later on Overstock, put it my cart while I tried to decide between 3 or more. The price went down, so I ordered that one for less than $20 along with another one that might have been a little over $20.