Software
Houzz Logo Print
alliehopster

Wonky thermostat and heating system

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

Hi, ever since the winter started our heating system has been really wonky. We have three thermostats: upstairs, downstairs, and a bonus room above the garage. If we keep the downstairs thermostat below 58 degrees, the upstairs thermostat works fine and we keep the bonus room closed off and really cold. The downstairs temp stays around 62 and we turn the pellet stove on for additional warmth.

However, if we turn up the downstairs thermostat to 60 or 62 degrees, heat blasts in the bonus room up to 75 degrees (even though that thermostat is set to 50) and blasts in the rest of the upstairs around 72-73. The downstairs will get to 66-68 with the thermostat set to 60-62.

What is going on? Could this be solved by simply replacing the thermostats or is this a larger issue?


We had an HVAC person in but all he could do was replace the dampers (which didn't do anything). He couldn't seem to figure out what was going on.


Thanks.

Comments (2)

  • 8 years ago

    We have a similar setup with two thermostats (and one furnace). In our system, if both thermostats are turned to "heat" setting, then they both have the ability to turn on the furnace when their area gets colder than the setting. On our house when we first moved in (we are the second owners, previous elderly owners were unable to tell us anything about the house), we had similar problems you do: the basement was always cold and would command the furnace on which would overheat the upstairs.

    As it turns out, our system has an electronic damper very near the furnace that is supposed to be controlled: When the upstairs thermostat reads cold the damper is closed so heat only goes to the ductwork that feeds the upstairs and the basement is "shut off" from having heat entering those ducts. When the downstairs thermostat reads too cold, the electronics both turn the furnace on and turn a flap in that dual zone damper to only send the furnace heat thru the ducts that heat the basement.

    Look at your furnace and you may see a place where the main duct that comes out of your furnace may spit with a "Y" (or a three-way split in your case). You may see a little electircal box there, or a flapper that you manually set to choose how much of the heat goes to each zone.

    Or call a different HVAC company and tell them you think you have a multi-zone system and they should only send a repairman capable of dealing with that...

    good luck!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Zoned systems are complicated. The designs of the zone system have to be configured to not only handle normal temperatures for the climate in which they are installed, they also have to be designed to handle the cooling aspects as well as heating aspects and temperature extremes of those aspects.

    Cooling and Heating have different objectives and sizing of the zone(s) come into play here as well.

    If the zone system is not designed properly, the cure is to typically take it all out and start over. It's unlikely there is a simple fix for it. With that said the system needs to be diagnosed by someone that understands zone system design as well as the challenges of such.

    With that said, there may be some other problem outside that of the design of the zone system. On a forum board all I do is many times throw out guesses as to what might be wrong.

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County