My order:

Mitoyo Eggplant,

New York Improved Eggplant,

Ukrainian Beauty Eggplant,

Pepino Melon,

Listada De Gandia Eggplant,

Prosperosa

Total: $16:25 + $3.50 shipping = $19.75

Price: A-

Good to Reasonable pricing for common items, but some items can be a little price for the number of seeds you are getting, since they often are the only company selling those varieties there are no alternative options. THe pro is that since the seeds are heirloom you can keep all the seeds yourself and not need to reorder.

Website: A

Nice feel, comfortable, nice original photos, professional looking, well made.

Selection: A+

Great varied selection. Many unique varieties.

Shipping: A

Amazing speed, it shipped the day after my order. Reasonable shipping cost.

Customer Service: A

Very quick response to questions.

I have not yet germinated the seeds or grown out the plants but I will add more to this thread.

I would recommend Baker Creek to everyone.