Software
Houzz Logo Print
kariyava

Herringbone pattern in small space

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

I have a kitchen remodel design dilemma. We are planning our kitchen remodel and are slightly over budget. We are thinking of ways to cut things out of the project to bring the cost down. One obvious candidate is keeping our two-tiered island as is (our original quote included transforming our existing two-tier island into a single tier island). I am aware of many pros and cons of a one v. two tier island, and while we originally liked the idea of a one-tier island better, given the cost savings, we are seriously considering the two-tier (which we frankly don't mind).

My current dilemma may sound silly, but if we keep the two tier island I am worried about how the backsplash on the island would look. Finding the right backsplash for our kitchen has been the most difficult aspect of the project planning to date. We finally found a glass tile that is the perfect color. It is in a typical "subway" rectangular shape. I am personally not a fan of laying that type of tile horizontally. I do, however, like it laid in a herringbone pattern, which is what we planned on doing. However, if we use the same treatment on the backsplash on the island, the backsplash area is so small top to bottom that I am worried the pattern will look odd. I am attaching a picture of what the tile will look like (it is not our exact tile, but pretty close). As you can see, it's not flashy and has no contrasting grout, so perhaps it would not look as odd as I think it might. I haven't been able to find any pictures of a larger herringbone pattern in a small space, however, so I am a bit nervous about it. What do you think?

I know we have options, but none of them are ideal, (one tier = expensive, I really don't like the look of laying subway shaped tiles horizontally, the idea of choosing a different backsplash gives me hives, and I don't like the look of extending the granite up the backsplash of the two-tier island) so I want to at least explore this one.



Comments (15)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks Sophie. I agree that if we disliked the two-tier island we wouldn't choose it just to save money. We see the pros of the two-tier option, however, and truly don't dislike it (the one-tier beat it out narrowly), so I don't think we would be compromising much to keep it two-tier. We will, however, think about the functionality more to make sure that we are ok with that option.

    In the meantime, I did find a picture here on Houzz that shows what a small strip of herringbone patterned tile would look like in a small space (under the window on the left side of the picture). To me, this doesn't look bad. Thoughts?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sorry, It doesn’t work. And that single level island will totally change how the kitchen works in a very positive way. You don’t know, because you don’t have it. But do not give that up!

    kariyava thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    My current kitchen layout is very similar, and every time the dishwasher is open, the drawers or cabinets to the left of it cannot be opened. Also standing near the sink and reaching into the upper cabinet that is above the island requires a lot of stretching. I cannot believe someone put in so much work redesigning this kitchen and didn't think of those issues.

  • 8 years ago

    You could just use the counter material instead of a tile back splash on the island (it's what we have if you want a pic I can take one), I think that would look better than squishing in a tile pattern. Although I have to agree with Sophie, I'd spend the money to have a single tier island that you can easily access from both sides, have more flat counter space not to mention how much more open a space looks and feels without them. Just my 2 cents!

    kariyava thanked kim k
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks everyone for your honest feedback.

    Let's assume I go with the single level island, which disposes of this dilemma. I have a similar question that I would love Houzzers to weigh in on. Our kitchen opens up to our family room, which has a dated fireplace (see picture below -- the furniture/fan/decor items are from the previous owner and everything has been changed except the fireplace). Our plan is to paint the wood mantle white, replace the front of the fireplace with an all black front, and replace the tile with the same tile we are using for the kitchen backsplash. All of this would be done professionally.

    Originally I thought that there was no way we could carry the herringbone pattern onto the fireplace because there would not be enough space around it for the pattern to show up nicely. Now I'm not sure because I will have more space around the fireplace than the space under the window in the picture I posted above. So now I am wondering whether it might look good to tile it in a herringbone pattern. What do you all think?

    The alternative would be to use the same tile, but lay it horizontally in an offset pattern. Although I really dislike this style in the kitchen (I know most people love it but it reminds me of subways), around the fireplace it reminds me more of brick and less of a subway. I think this would be the "safer" option, but I wanted to see what everyone else thought. Is it weird to use the same tile in different patterns if you can see both the fireplace and the kitchen backsplash from the same spot? Or would it be a nice coordinating but not matchy-matchy look?

  • 8 years ago

    Can you choose a smaller herringbone? I don't think it will look strange to use the same tile, I actually think it will be nice and flow really well.

    kariyava thanked kim k
  • 8 years ago

    I wish! This tile doesn't come in a smaller size, unfortunately, and I really had to look long and hard to find a tile that was the right color and had the right undertones to go with the rest of my kitchen choices.

  • 8 years ago

    Skip the herringbone. You can love it all you want for someone else's space. It does not work for yours.

    kariyava thanked User
  • 8 years ago
    I don’t think a small strip of the herringbone pattern on your island will look bad at all. IMO it won’t look any worse that a small strip of a brick pattern. The photo you posted looks kinda funky because it’s a small strip and then ends awkwardly in the middle of the window.
    kariyava thanked User
  • 8 years ago

    I'm also a fan of herringbone and chevron patterns. I'd consider two options for your fireplace. #1- Pick another smaller tile in a natural marble like the chevron pictured above to apply in a herringbone pattern. It'll look good without having to be a direct match to the kitchen area. The pattern match will be enough of a tie. #2- Take the kitchen tiles and cut them down sideways so the width becomes the new length of the now smaller versions. Quick for your tiler using his wet saw. So not a big expense and you'll get the match with the smaller scale herringbone.

    kariyava thanked dan1888
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Thanks. I agree that we aren't stuck using the same tile on the fireplace as we will have in the kitchen -- that's something to consider. I also considered cutting the tile, but the edges are slightly beveled, so that won't work without a ton of labor (and money).

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sorry I am confused the best way is a single level island or peninsula and no backsplash on that area. Change tiles a beveled tile shoud never be laid in a herringbone IMHO

    kariyava thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I think that tile looks very kitchen-like for a fireplace. I like black slate - goes with everything and won't stain from the heat of the fire.

    kariyava thanked Anglophilia
  • 8 years ago

    Frame out the herringbone in the larger area and then do horizontal on the smaller areas.

    kariyava thanked mamadada