Software
Houzz Logo Print
a1an

Miele Ultrabs

8 years ago

I've posted how I feel that tabs in formula in R&D by the mother companies are far superior IME. Well, at least Cascade platinum for grungy stuff, and one notch down would be Finish Quantum.

I tested using the UltraTabs on the hottest / longest cycle my DW will do - Hoods Filters/Grates tonight.

I've alway used my baffle hoods as the baseline for soap testing as I can tell if the soap being used removed the oil film down to the stainless steel or does it leave a softened but still there oil film on the baffles.

The ultratabs for me, in my water (as water plays a huge role in ones experience with any soap) did not clean as well as any of the 2 aforementioned tabs. So what's with the love for the Ultratabs. The fact that's is made in Germany and the affinity of that ?

Don't get me wrong. My cars are german, my preferred wrenches are Hazet, but IMO, the tabs are not worth the entry fee, just short of maybe the cost per is about the same if you split the tab in half...but the tabs are very loose in powder once you split it.

Comments (39)

  • 8 years ago

    Thought I saw somewhere that for the 58min QuickIntenseWash to clean properly, you needed to use the Miele Ultratabs because they are formulated to dissolve quicker in the shorter cycle. Don't they say something similar for the Pro line dishwashers or was it that you just need to use powder....

    For me, big fan of Finish Quantum Max which I've had success with in all water types. Plus I like that I don't have to add rinse-aid.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Miele only recommends Miele product in their machines anyhow, afaik ;-)

    I have not done open door testing to compare....methinks I may skip Quickwash unless I really needed it, bearing the etching on the clear ---I'm really being stingy on the powder I have left and it's like my last breath of air, keeping it until I need to use it.

    I think the answer is going to boil down to dosing. In which powder in the bag is best. Less for QW since the water is more intense and hotter. Cleantabs - when cut in half, the other half ends up being like 1/4 since once cut, the powder just spills everywhere. And or just take all the quicktabs, break them all up .....and then use that as powder in the bag. Still, doesn't clean as good as tabs but sufficient enough for lightly soiled items.


    Drumroll. Not that I ever looked at the specs of how much water it was using. For a cycle of Hoods/Filters with Internesive Wash, the app shows it used 2.5 gallons of water. That's it.


    I'm kinda amazed and how little water it uses - 2 pre rinses, main wash, interim and final rinse. Hell, I use 2.5 gallons of water just doing dishes.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I cut my Miele tabs with a knife and don’t have issues with crumbling. A tiny bit but nothing to worry about.

    I store the full tabs in the sealed OXO under the sink and put a few cut ones in a small dish beside so I can grab one and go.

  • 8 years ago

    Are those the older ones ? They used to make them with tabs...

    I cut one, but then the other half (the powder literally just spilled out as it broke up). It's fairly loose once the wrapper is broken...

    I feel like I'm def. in the direction of going back to powder IF I can find the right powder for proper dosing. If not, I'm not splitting tabs cause even the straight powder types like the ultratabs are one god darn awful mess.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    These are the newest tabs. They have no tab. I just cut with a sharp Henkel knife and no issues.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I do really like the Oxiclean powder if you can find it to try it. You use every little and it cleans pretty comparable to the Miele tabs for me. Larsi liked it a lot too.

  • 8 years ago

    The other half does break/spill out... ?

    In all fairness, I did not cut them per say. Held the tab over the dispenser, scissored cut it with the goal that the other half would be put back into the container.....maybe I need to cut them on flat surface.

  • 8 years ago

    I've actually got a the Oxi and use it for light soiled loads. If you like it, might want to stock up on some ....they stopped making it.

  • 8 years ago

    I have used the Ecover pods and they do a really good job for me.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sea Sea, I had a similar issue when I tried Cascade Pods. And they had such a strong perfume I could smell and taste it on my dishes, yuck! I don't understand why they'd put such a heavy perfume in a dishwasher detergent. I was also very unimpressed with Cascade powder--it just didn't clean everything. I'd always find a dish, pot or cup that remained dirty with Cascade powder.

    I used to use Ecover powder and tabs years ago but now when I want something eco friendly, I use Trader Joe's powder detergent (this is what I'm currently using). I learned about it about 10 years ago when it was very highly rated by Consumer Reports. I like that it contains no perfumes, it cleans really well and it's inexpensive.

    My favorite conventional powder is Finish Advanced Powder; it performs much better than Cascade. If you are looking for a tab that performs great on extra dirty loads, Finish All in 1 tabs are excellent and have just a little perfume.

    I've been using Lemi Shine rinse aid lately and have been very happy with the results. I also keep a bottle of their booster on hand and use it occasionally.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It's good to know Greeny that Trader Joe's dishwasher detergent is a good one. I do have one in the next town. I'll have to pick up a box next time I go. Thanks!

    I made some chicken drumsticks last night on my new stove and the bottom of the pot got thick crusty burnt-on build up since I have to learn how to cook all over again now that I have decent BTUs for the first time in my life. Turns out I had been cooking over candle flame all these years lol. I could not scrub that pot free of the burnt on crud. I put it in the DW with a Cascade Complete pod looking like I didn't spend 10 mins scrubbing it, along with the rest of my dishes. This morning when I checked the DW, my pot sparkled. It also smells strongly of the Cascade perfumes and or chemicals. Ecover as much as I like it, would not have had the power to have budged the mess I made of that pot. Cascade Complete pods have their place, but reserved for the extra duty loads.

  • 8 years ago

    My usual is a Finish Quantum tab and sometime I will add Finish powder if I use a cycle with a heated prewash.

  • 8 years ago

    Interesting responses. I tried a multitude of tabs and I settled in on the 2 in the OP. Cascade Platinum for grungy stuff, and Quantum if I had a less soiled load that I think might also be a more ~gentler~ soap. For sure, Quantum does not clean oil baffle filters as well as Cascade. I did try the lower line tabs in both brands and both did not perform for me, so I stopped looking afterwards. When dishwashers cycles take almost 3 hrs or more to run, cheap soap that will not get the clean is such a moot point, ya know.

    Granted, water plays a huge role in this discussion, and as well, how one loads up the DW may also skewer said results.

  • 8 years ago

    I've never attempted to cut the Miele tabs in the air. I can see them crumbling that way. I do it on a cutting board with a sharp knife.

    I do have 6 bottles of the Oxi powder I grabbed on clearance a while ago. Think that should last awhile.

    Some people here raved about the Method Smarty Dish tabs - saying they worked very well.

    Has anyone here used the Grab Green ones? They seem very scented to me. Saw some at our Winners today (your TJMaxx).

  • 8 years ago

    I have used Cascade tabs and they cleaned fine but like Little Greeny, I've found that it leaves an odor behind inside the DW and sometimes inside of glasses. I don't want fragrance on my dishes or inside of my dishwasher. It seems like P&G is obsessed with making products that leave strong scents on everything.

  • 8 years ago

    Can you imagine using Cascade tabs Gain scented. Not sure if they still make them or not.

  • 8 years ago

    I use Miele tabs because they work and are unscented. I can’t stand these artificial scents and they stay on dishes and change the flavor or water, tea and coffee in these vessels. I also used Method smarty tabs but it is hard to find the unscented version. So at from Germany is also great but harder to get my hands on these days.

    Good luck!

  • 8 years ago

    homepro do you use a whole or half miele tab? I am a powder person, but Miele sent me the wrong thing when I ordered something else from them, now I have a huge box of tabs sitting here. So I guess we shall try them.

  • 8 years ago
    Laps

    Miele does not sell straight powder in a box . Well, err, at least in the USA they don’t. All are tabs
  • 8 years ago

    Lapsang,

    I use the whole tab. I usually have a super full load. I have split these tabs in the past with no issues. I use a sharp knife and it is easy to do.

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks A1an, --- I do know Miele sells only tabs--what I was saying above, probably not clearly enough!, was that I usually use a powder detergent (Ecover actually, same as box pictured above), but when I went to place an order *for something else*, not detergent at all, from Miele (I think it was rinse aid or salt I had actually ordered), they shipped me a huge box of Ultratabs instead by mistake. They didn't want them back. So now I have a big pile of Ultratabs. So I guess I will be trying them. Was wondering to try the whole thing or half.

  • 8 years ago

    The last time I used Miele tabs it was the original version( I still have about 20 tabs left from some year??). Does the current Dali version work as well as the original version that was made by Claro of Austria?

  • 8 years ago

    I personally like the newer tabs because they are less sudsy. They clean very well for me with just half tab. My loads are never really filthy.

  • 8 years ago

    In the GW laundry forum of soaps, I know some of ya'll are collectors......

    IMO, I would say certain ingredients in things can lose it's true effectiveness over the life of XYZ months/years.

    Whaddya say GW. Does the primary stuff (enzymes) in DW tabs had a lifespan of X ? I try to maintain fresh stock to some degree....rotating back the older ones from the weekend getaway back to the main house, bringing fresh ones to the weekender, etc.

    Today was a headscratcher.....about 1/3 of my load did not come out clean. And of course I chose the extra dry option, so things were nice and hard. Ended up doing a manual soak on the dirty ones and handwashing....

    So how big is your DW stash

  • 8 years ago

    I have 1/2 of one box of the first edition of Miele tabs and that's all. I am not sure why I stopped using them and then switched to Finish Quantum. I do know that if I use Finish all in one it causes the Dw to do 3 rinses instead of two, so I stick to Quantum. These Miele tabs must be at least 3 years old. Tomorrow I will wash dishes accumulated from Friday lunch to Monday Lunch so I will use a tab and see how it works out.

  • 8 years ago

    Do report back Jerrod. Fresh product/stock is always on my radar - hence I try to rotate them...


    Always sorta amazed on the fellow GW who stockpile laundry detergent, etc. I would think to some degree, certain components may not be as effective

  • 8 years ago

    Ok so this is really about stashing detergent but I am going to share the pics of the load that is currently running with the 3 year old detergent. Will see how it comes out but I think this would probably get done better with newer detergent, but at least we will see stuff stays good.

    Here are pictures of the items that are in the load running now: these items are representative of the soil since I had whole wheat pasta, cheese, fish sticks, maple syrup among the food


  • 8 years ago

    This is the old detergent with the scoring line in the center:


  • 8 years ago

    This is the lower rack:

  • 8 years ago

    Here is the center rack:

  • 8 years ago

    The upper rack:

    The lonely old timer tab:


  • 8 years ago

    Call it the OCD in me. Spied the tongs/spatulas. Same POV for plastic /glass storage containers with the silicone insert as gaskets. Or barrel handled stainless shaped kitchen utensils with the caps on them. I avoid those things in the DW as I'm concerned dirty water might make it into the tightest of all cavities and lurk in there, without me knowing.

  • 8 years ago

    No silicone inserts, they are lids. The black utensils don't have caps on them, they are open loops on the ends. The spatula that is in the upper rack; I pull the wooden handle off of it and inspect it for soil. The rest of the spoons are cheap wooden ones that can easily be disposed of.

  • 8 years ago

    Jerrod. The last post was not directed at your load. Just in a general blub. The round handles are aka, Rosle style with the end caps. The silicone tips on metal handled utensils are usually fixed and you can't pull out.

    All I was just trying to say was those tight crevices, is it just me, the OCD clean nut, who has concerns about dirty washwater making it into those crevices.

    Kinda like glass lock containers if you are familiar with them. It has a silicone insert....that's a whole nuther post I suppose as I can go all day on their design flaw.

  • 8 years ago

    Back ontopic, for the Wiki, I'm a huge advocate on checking batch codes on like a million things I buy/consume.


    For cascade, on the back , there is a lightly embossed #'s. The 1st number is the year and the next 3 numbers is the day of the year in which it was produced.


  • 8 years ago

    How did the test go Jerrod. Did you end up cussing up a storm with hardened dirty dishes. Per my other recent post, yeah, it was a headscratcher....literally 1/3 of mine came out not clean, and I can't even guess why, just short of a bad tab. Might just toss out the rest of this particular batch. I really hate it when after 2 1/2 hrs in a cycle and you end up still needing to rewash the dirty ones that now are harded off due to the heat cycle.

  • 8 years ago

    The old tab worked like a charm. I was shocked. Everything is clean and shiny. Here are the plate and dish. They are scratched because they are about 28 years old but they are clean. Everything else is clean too.

    I always liked this detergent because it creates no suds at all. If I open the DW during the wash the water looks clear. I guess I need to use it up or maybe try the current version of the detergent. I have been afraid to try it because it it now made by another company.


  • 8 years ago

    Jerrod. I don't know if this applies or not, but maybe your old tabs (being euro) might have more phosphates than ANY of the new Euro tabs which are phosphate free.


    Go figure. Either that one particular tab went south or ??? I told you it was a headscratcher when 1/3 of the load had bits stuck on.

0
Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional