Software
Houzz Logo Print
mwrede

** Gas pack replacement options in NC **

8 years ago

Our downstairs gas pack stopped working unexpectedly Monday (apparently rust caused a hole in the heat exchanger). It is a 2.5 ton 10 SEER American standard gas pack (YCP030F1M0AC) put in 2005 by the previous owners (house built in 1993). It has worked without any issues in the last 9.5 years we've been in the house. We are in Durham NC so we have typically hot and humid summers and relatively mild winters. The unit is located outside on the ground level and it has heated/cooled our lower level which is around 1600 sq f. Our downstairs has a very open floorplan and both the foyer/front stairs and the back stairs are open to the upstairs. We also have the Eiklor 30” 4 burner gas logs in the living room fireplace which we typically use every night in the winter for heat/ambiance. Our upstairs is heated/cooled by a Carrier Infinity dual fuel heat pump/furnace system we put in in 2012.


These are the options we are considering – all 2.5 ton units I believe:


Company A: (The company that installed our upstairs Carrier Infinity unit and does our maintenance – mainly a Carrier dealer)


They include 1 year (2 visits) free gold maintenance package on both upstairs/downstairs units (valued at $246) and 2 yrs labor warranty


Carrier 14 SEER single stage gas pack - 48VL-C300603-GP

Stainless heat Exchanger - 81.0% AFUE -Dehumidification Feature

$5520


Carrier 15 SEER 2 stage heat/2 stage cool - 48VG-B300603-GP

Multi-speed ECM Blower Motor-Standard - Dehumidification Feature

$7200 =$7500 minus $300 utility rebate (** see below)


includes 10 yrs parts warranty (20 yr on HX – although I think it becomes lifetime if you register within 90 days)

Replace main supply and return ducts lines with 16”

Remove 25 yr old non working humidifier from crawl space (we didn’t know we had this down there)

New Honeywell lyric T6 wifi thermostat (TH6220WF2006)

* Extending labor warranty to 10 years is an extra $987


They also quoted the Trane 15 SEER unit after I asked them to:


Trane XL 15c 15 SEER 2 stage heat/variable speed blower 4YCY5030A1070A

$6678 =$6978 minus $300 utility rebate (** see below)

10 yr parts warranty/lifetime heat exchanger



Company B:

Include the same things in terms of work performed etc. as company A and same thermostat other than not including the 1 yr free maintenance nor adding the 2nd year of labor warranty. They are suggesting replacing the return flex to one return to 14” (from 12”) in addition to upsizing the main trunklines to 16” (from 14”) – Company A said that was not necessary


Trane XL 15c 15 SEER 2 stage heat/variable speed blower 4YCY5030A1070A

$5973 =$6473 - $500 Utility rebate **


They also quoted the Carrier gas packs:


Carrier 14 SEER single stage gas pack - 48VL-C300603-GP

$5939 (not including 1 yr free maintenance)


Carrier 15 SEER 2 stage heat/2 stage cool - 48VG-B300603-GP

$6999= $7499 - $500 Utility rebate **

**$300 rebate from our Utility company for 15 SEER and up – installer must be certified by them and have special equipment to get extra $200 rebate for smart thermostat and quality installation)


With company B adding a 10 year labor warranty is an extra $1200 – their maintenance agreement is $282/yr additional


I also got some quotes on HP/dual fuel gas packs but they were too high to consider. (Electricity costs have been going down from $0.101/kwh last year to $0.961 this year. Natural gas prices have been going up from $0.88/thm to $0.953/thm.)


Would you consider getting the 10 yr labor warranty? (we asked for it and it was included free (I’m sure the price reflected it) for our upstairs unit but that was a much more expensive Carrier Infinity 16 SEER 4 ton unit and we had multiple issues/repairs with its predecessor over the yrs and didn’t want to risk it)


Thoughts on the Honeywell lyric T6 wifi thermostat (TH6220WF2006)? I believe if we want a different model company A will give us a $140 credit to order what we want (they said the Nest is popular) and will install the one we purchase for free but won’t warranty the work if there are issues. I haven’t talked to company B about other thermostat options.


Financially it makes sense to go with company A if we are getting a Carrier unit and company B if we are going with the Trane 15 SEER unit – we’d prefer to give company A our business but my impression of company B is the salesperson was very professional, thorough and responsive and it’s a large company with a good reputation (but repairs if we go through them might possibly cost more based on some Angies list reviews).


I would appreciate any thoughts as we need to make a decision and schedule installation by Monday.

Thanks!

Comments (5)

  • 8 years ago

    The Trane package unit and add a Trane 2 stage thermostat, Mdl 824...set up dehumidify on demand for AC cooling...how do you filter your return air?

    IMO

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    One thing often left out of many conversations regarding Gas packs is that, the gas pack is a packaged unit. There is no real refrigerant work as the unit is one piece (AKA Package Unit). The company merely swaps out package unit, reattaches duct work, condensate line, hooks up electrical, thermostat and starts up the system. Meaning the skill comes in when it comes time to repair it for whatever reason.

    So taking that into consideration, if something happens to the refrigerant circuit of the Gas Pack (slang for package unit) which company is known to be able to repair the unit?

    Package units are typically installed in a commercial application, some parts of the country use them for both commercial and residential application.

    With all that said, heat exchangers rarely fail this quickly (with your current unit). Was the heat exchanger failure investigated by more than just the first company on service visit?

    Heat exchangers often are warranted by 20 year manufacture warranty. That's not always the case especially since ownership of this home changed hands after the unit had been installed and the unit in question is a gas pack.

    Additionally 10 SEER isn't very efficient these days... so if it turns out the heat exchanger is still under part warranty thru American Standard this may challenge your progress some.

    In my opinion brand matters very little in package unit arena. Commercial warranties on such units is 5 year parts on all brands. Extended labor warranties are a mixed bag, be sure to read the fine print of the contract to see what they cover and or don't cover. These policies change from time to time and vary widely.

  • 8 years ago

    tigerdunes thanks, I really do like the idea of having the variable speed and 2 stage heat of the Trane 15 Seer packaged unit at a price marginally higher than the 14 Seer 1 stage units. I looked up the XL824 Trane thermostat and the reviews were not so good compared to others like the Honeywell 9000 (TH9320WF5003) or the ecobee 3 - it seems Nexia also requires a monthly $10 fee to use. Are there other thermostats that would allow for a dehumidication feature by sensing humidity and telling the ac to run at a very low speed without causing significatly lower temperatures than we want? We do travel a good amount particularly during the warmer months and it would be great to be able to control the system remotely (get the ac cooling before we arrive etc.). We also just got an Amazon echo and might want to use Alexa to control the temperature via voice commands.

    We have been using disposable pleated
    filters at the 2 air return registers. I asked about a media filter (we have an Aprilaire in the attic for the upstairs unit) but
    they did not recommend it because we would have to go into the crawl
    space to change the filters (ceilings are too low and i'm
    claustrophobic). Company A quoted putting a media filter in crawl space for $225, Company B quoted an air purification system for $800 for both Trane and Carrier options- maybe they are referring to Trane clean effects not sure - i didn't investigate further due to the high cost.

    Austin Air: it seems packaged units or gaspacks as they call them around here are the norm in homes is NC for the lower level floors as our crawl spaces have such low ceilings. Company A showed me the rust/hole in the heat exchanger and the heater had already stopped working so I think they were telling the truth about it needing to be replaced. We weren't the ones to put in the system in 2005 - i was told the American Standard heat exchanger only had a 10 yr warramty (XE not stainless). All 4 of the companies i talked to said 12-13 years is a normal life expectancy around here due to the unit being outside in the elements and not having a stainless XE. The new units with stainless XE have 10 yrs on parts and 20 yrs/lifetime on XE - of course labor to replace is a factor that's why i was pricing the 10 yr labor warranties -but good point on reading the fine print.


    Any thoughts on things that would increase the life of the gaspack being that it will be located outside other than the stainless XE i.e. Carrier Armor coat coil tin plating vs. aluminum Spine Fin coils?

    Thanks again!

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Being that you're in NC, is your home in what is considered a 'coastal' area? If that's the case, it is what it is. This condition will effect the warranty provided by any manufacturer regardless of brand.

    Stainless steel option may help the heat exchanger in regards to climates like this but won't help other parts of your system. From what I have seen in regards to American Standard warranty on heat exchangers in a residential application the warranty period is 20 years. However, this warranty became effective after your system was made and in this warranty there is an exclusion for installations in coastal areas.

    In my experience coatings don't do much. Salt spray from ocean is very corrosive environment. Some protection is better than nothing, but nothing on this planet is immune to failure, so keep this in mind in making your decision. Hope for the best and plan for the worst.

  • 8 years ago

    Durham, NC location...