I think that you will find positive and negative reviews about all of them. I discounted kitchenaid because I had so many problems with my previous one and the service was awful. I found that looking at as many as possible helped me narrow down my choices. I checked how the interiors were configured, whether they had ice/water in the door, whether I liked the look, and the dimensions. In the end I chose the Samsung counter depth 4 door flex with food showcase. I liked the set up inside, liked the way the freezer had doors instead of a big drawer. Each freezer side has a shelf and 2 drawers as well as door bins. Also liked that one of the freezer sections can be switched to fridge by adjusting the temp. And I liked the look. So far I’m really happy with it.