Software
Houzz Logo Print
tahoebigah

Need help deciding between gas/electric package units.

8 years ago

I live in TN and currently have a Carrier 48SS024060311AA on a 1200 sq ft home will be replacing it very soon. It is basically rusted to death and is limping along and duct taped together.


I have three options


Goodman GPG14240M060M41AA - 14 Seer - $2000

Goodman GPG16240M060M41AA - 16 Seer - $2700

Rheem RGEA15024AJT061AA - 15 Seet $2500


I dont know much of anything about Rheem so it is hard to consider it. I also dont know if the 16 seer vs 14 seer Goodman is worth it. All three are from the same installer.




Comments (5)

  • 8 years ago

    looks like all 2 ton AC with 60 KBTU gas furnace at 80% eff ...don't care for any of the models but I suppose the Rheem over the Goodmans...

  • 8 years ago

    Is there any reason you prefer Rheem over the Goodman units? I know Goodman units have a cloud of reliability issues hanging over them but it doesn’t bother me. I just don’t know which one would be best if if you take into consideration that all units won’t fail and are working perfectly.

  • 8 years ago

    $700 for 2 points of SEER may be worth it over the life of the unit, assuming it lasts for 20 years and you use AC enough.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    The Goodman models listed basically come down to features and functions you want in terms of better comfort for the structure. The 14 SEER model is single stage either on or off for both heating and air conditioning functions. The Goodman 16 SEER model is 2 stage for both heat and air conditioning.

    If you decide on the Goodman 16 SEER option, it is much better in controlling humidity and providing better overall comfort. However, it must be controlled properly it needs a 2 stage thermostat for both heating and air conditioning. Then you need to make sure it is wired properly this may include running new thermostat wire. Neither of the Goodman units are micro channel.

    The Rheem unit has micro channel coils (evaporator and condenser coil) Because this is a package unit it's no big deal on installation of the unit, but when repairs are needed it can complicate things.

    Micro channel benefit is that less refrigerant is needed. However, these are critically charged units which means if the unit loses a few ounces of refrigerant it will not work properly.

    Micro channel units can not be pumped down to service unit. Refrigerant must be reclaimed to work on refrigeration circuit. So the costs to service a micro channel designed unit leaves little to be desired as the unit ages.

    Because micro channel coils are critically charged it would be pointless to attempt to recharge a system temporarily until parts can be found to make repairs or in most cases replace the leaking micro channel coil. This doesn't mean the Goodman units can't leak refrigerant, just that they can be recharged temporarily until repair parts can be obtained like over a holiday weekend or something like that.

    Micro channel has been around a while now, but early on they were prone to developing refrigerant leaks and still are as far as I know. For those reasons out of the choices shown I would choose Either of the Goodman units. But only the 16 SEER model if it's properly wired with a 2 stage heat and 2 stage cool thermostat.

    The devil in any HVAC system, is in the finer details.

    Micro channel mostly benefits the manufacturer, as this design cuts manufacturing cost not only in material costs but also refrigerant costs.

    I service the Katy, Texas area.

    Andy thanked Austin Air Companie
  • 8 years ago

    I wouldn't lose sleep over brands - they are all pretty similar in terms of features, performance and reliability at any given price level. I have a slight preference for Rheem but would definitely go for the 2 stage unit for comfort.