Thanks Beth!! I never thought to get rid of the 4 in. Granite... I like the ivory subway you posted... I’m a big gray fan... might be too much though???

I would definitely get rid of the 4" of granite if you can...

it's hard to tell if that gray would work. why don't you go to tilebar.com and order the 5 samples for $5? That first one is Byzantine Bianco.

look at their other subway tiles. they have some other whites and some grays. this is their Lancaster in Dove

check Home Depot on the online site for subway tiles. they have a better selection than in the store.

Thanks so much Beth!! This helps a lot!

Devon, GL. post pics when you get the samples, next to your granite.

also, that 4" piece can easily be cut away from the countertop and carefully pried loose from the wall.